CZ & Michael Saylor (MicroStrategy CEO) Fireside Chat
Binance · 2020-12-08 · 1h 00m · View on YouTube →
good morning and good afternoon to you
all thank you for joining us for what we
hope is the first of many finance
fireside chats i'm your host josh
goodbody and what better way for us to
kick off this series than by having two
esteemed titans of the crypto industry
michael saylor the ceo of microstrategy
and our very own cz founder and ceo of
finance michael cz welcome to you both
yep um glad to be here and michael
thanks for joining the show
very exciting
great stuff so guys today we're going to
start with a few hot topics then we're
going to move off piste into some
quickfire questions and then we're going
to finish up with some live q a does
that sound all right
yep awesome excellent okay so bitcoin
bitcoin bitcoin uh everyone's talking
about it it's the hot topic of the year
if not every single conversation right
now in wall street and main street
cz you've been known to encourage people
to slap themselves for selling their
bitcoin very brave may i say
and michael you're quite clearly
practicing what you preach at
microstrategy
michael why are you so bullish on
bitcoin tell us a little bit about how
you got here and where your current head
is at with respect to bitcoin
you know i didn't pay much attention to
the crypto industry until march of this
year and in march of this year we had a
k-shape recovery so i think that the
major macroeconomic event is is the
expansion of the m2 money supply
we were we had a money supply expanded
by about five and a half percent a year
for a decade
and starting this year it leaped forward
by about 24
and looking forward it looks like it's
going to expand by 15
every year for the next five years so
another way to say that is the cost of
capital just tripled
and if you're not beating the expansion
of the money supply with your returns
and investment you can't preserve wealth
you can't store value
so when the cost of capital tripled what
that meant was a bond that's not
yielding more than 15 percent is losing
value
and it meant that a stock that's not
growing its eps faster than 15 annually
is losing value and it meant the real
estate that can't grow its rents by
faster than 15
is losing value so the short of it is
there's 300 trillion dollars of of money
in the in these in fiat investments
they're all going to be cut in half
over the next three to five years
they're they're all in essence
everyone's going to lose half their
wealth
if they don't find a solution to the
problem so
why am i interested in bitcoin and the
crypto industry in general is because
there's a mad scramble to find a store
of value we know that cash won't work
and we know that bonds real estate and
stock are fiat instruments and they're
all going to be debased at the rate of
expansion of the money supply and so
what are you going to do you you search
through gold you consider silver you
consider commodities you consider buying
a portfolio of rare art
and eventually you settle upon the idea
of perfectly engineered
digital gold
something that is superior to gold in
all respects
not none of the liabilities of gold all
of the good attributes of gold and
that's 21 million gold coins called
bitcoin sitting in cyberspace
right and so once once you've found that
you think well this is the ultimate safe
haven asset and store of value for every
investor on earth and by the way it's
the solution to 7.8 billion people's
problem on art because everybody on the
planet has a currency that's collapsing
the only difference is in america and
europe is collapsing at 10 to 15 a year
and everywhere else it's collapsing
faster
so how can you not get enthusiastic
about that
yeah yeah fair point i think cece you've
been really you know banging that drama
and talking to those those themes around
currencies devaluing for a long long
time you've been in these crypto
trenches since the very early days
how does it feel for you now to see
companies like microstrategy and people
like michael saylor saying these things
publicly and being champions do you feel
relieved do you feel vindicated
well i just feel it's great to meet
people uh that are taking public
companies into crypto now um actually i
think michael sailor is definitely one
of the early adopters from a public
company perspective so before i was i
was always more talking on the
individual basis much easier to invest
individually so uh
seeing that uh seeing the uh taking
action to take publicly listed company
allocating a percent of that treasury
and publicly um uh doing intercrypt into
bitcoin is is really really refreshing
um i i didn't know how long it would
take i i thought it would take a long
time so uh seeing pioneers like michael
doing this now i think this is gonna i
actually think this is gonna start a
whole new trend and something that we i
actually didn't expect before but uh for
all the reasons michael said all those
reasons were there before
but this year definitely uh super kicked
that into like high gear and
supercharged it
so i think now
but but having um having all these sort
of crypto ogs talking about it on crypto
twitter in smaller groups is it's that's
one level of impact like we are we're we
usually talk we usually say we're just
talking about ourselves because we're
just trying to convince each other which
are already convinced but now we're
seeing this new wave coming in which is
really really refreshing and
and also michael is also a very um
articulate person um i follow your
tweets your tweets are always worded
really really um
well and it
has it has resonance so um i think yeah
just having having michael uh sort of
being the first public company to do
this and also being very vocal about it
is really really refreshing and we're
i'm just super happy
for more and more people like michael to
to join this industry
awesome and michael do you think we're
getting to this point that it actually
starts to become a conversation within
treasury functions in in not just public
holistic companies but other companies
whereby you're almost not doing your job
by considering bitcoin as a store of
value for your treasury function you're
almost remiss
for not looking at this in more detail
at what point do you think we're going
to be getting there or are we actually
already there and these conversations
are happening in more and more treasury
functions
i i think that march of this year was
the inflection point
if you had asked me what did i think
about bitcoin and what our treasury
invested in bitcoin in february
i would have said what is bitcoin or i
think i read about it but i'm not paying
attention to it and
if i'd walked into my boardroom and said
we should do it they would have thought
i'd gone crazy
and uh and by the way i didn't know
about it i wouldn't have done it i
wouldn't have been allowed to do it and
i wouldn't have had a good reason to do
it
and then i think in march we kind of got
hit in the head with a 2x4 it was a
wake-up call
and and again
the the rate of of asset inflation
tripled or quadrupled or quintupled and
so you could all the sudden the entire
industry shifted every rational investor
in the world today
knows
inflation is coming they know there's a
problem
so starting in april people had a
problem it was three times as intense as
it was in february
all the media started covering it
and all of the other solutions to the
problem started to look like they're not
working again so if you if you think
about how fast institutions move
you know it takes if you're if you're
wicked fast in three months you're
working on it in six months you've done
something and otherwise it's quarter by
quarter by quarter and so i think
i think you know we did it you saw
square do it and um
there's been a parade of a hundred
institutional uh
positive milestones that happened since
march and each one of those is is
building a tapestry
of momentum
and uh and it's making it easier for the
next company i think it's a no-brainer
that private companies i see a lot of
private companies working on it but i
also hear
institutions pension funds and
unions and endowments and things like
that are starting to move and uh and i i
also think public companies will do it i
think i think the hardest the hardest
hurdle is for public companies to do it
because there's
there's interlocking regulatory and
governance and accounting and and
strategic issues and communications
issues which are which are really tricky
to work through
but i think that uh
you know the hedge funds
the paul two to john stanley druckenmill
bill moore all of those they can move
faster and they typically want to front
run
the bigger players and then you have the
lumbering institutions and of course the
private companies and high net worth
individuals and family offices they're
uh they've got the same problem and uh
they can move faster and they don't they
don't have to put out a press release
saying what they did and why they did it
and justify it
yeah absolutely absolutely so
what's really clear is that you're
you're both super passionate about
growing this industry
cz 2020 has been a really
really good year for finance how do you
plan to continue this growth and kind of
try and foster a 10 in of this economy
that we're in what are your thoughts
around that
um so my thoughts on this industry is
actually quite simple um i think
basically the industry has to grow for
uh for us for businesses in this
industry to grow
but i'm very confident that the industry
will grow i think we're seeing
institutional participat before when we
talk about institutional participation
we're talking about
institutional traders potentially like
allocating some funds trading bitcoin or
something but now we're seeing treasury
institutional treasury come in and i i
actually i heard different versions of
this um of this rally and they were
saying that they're just a few
institutions allocating one percent of
their of their treasury into bitcoin and
that's that's causing this rally already
so uh and uh just imagine like uh how
much more demand there is one once more
once more of the treasury managers
figure out that this is what they need
to do
so um from from our from my perspective
i think this year yeah it has been
pretty bad in almost every other
instance but it has been good for the
crypto industry that is really showing
that the fundamentals of bitcoin
fundamentals of cryptocurrencies that it
is limited supply there's no inflation
it is a hedge against all these
other macroeconomic changes
and uh i think for uh
our our goal is really just to keep our
servers up
oh wow
why this industry is rallying so we got
to be able to handle the number of new
users coming we gotta handle like peak
traffic pick volumes uh gotta do our
kycml all of those things take although
most of those things don't scale very
well because they're sometimes human
components to them so we're just trying
to find out better ways to to be able to
service institutional participation as
we define it now like treasuries come in
um they will want they will want to they
will want to do due diligence on us and
how to service potentially um uh
micro seller uh micro strategy
firms like this so this is this is going
to be our challenge going forward i'm
not worried about the i'm not worried
about the industry i'm very worried
about the economy overall um but the
crypto economy the crypto industry
will be will be very good so i think
michael's really joining early and his
own words kind of front running um the
other late adopters so i think that's a
really smart strategy to adopt
cool so on that theme michael of trying
to ten times this industry let's think
even bigger let's let's say 100 times
this industry
what's your view on how we've got to get
there we were talking earlier around
things like demonstrating to people how
big the bitcoin economy is how do you
quantify the bitcoin community things
like that i think are really important
and you've got some great ideas on that
so do you want to share with us how you
think we can 10 times 100 times elements
of the the bitcoin economy
well i
yeah i i think that it starts by
rotating from then
from one uh narrative which is well
bitcoin is a very interesting
uncorrelated digital asset with high
volatility with high potential returns
and you can put one to two percent of
your portfolio into it with or without
leverage
but that's one
that that was unnarrative you know and
that the speculative narrative uh
was predominant before march but that's
not the that's not going to appeal to 99
of the investors or the money in the
world they want something different they
want
bitcoin is the ultimate synthetic
long-term treasury reserve asset it's
it's an engineered safe haven asset to
engineered to be superior to gold in all
aspects
of a bearer instrument that's a store of
value and if i go from one to the other
uh then i'm not talking about getting
one percent of the money from one
percent of the investors i'm talking
about getting fifty percent of the money
from a hundred percent of the investors
okay so
so uh what does that mean well i mean it
means that
the people that we want we we want to
appeal to are
the people that put their money in gold
because they don't trust fiat
instruments so there's 10 trillion
dollars there
so they'll be looking at you know how
does bitcoin compare to gold how does
bitcoin's volatility compared to gold
returns compared to gold trading
liquidity compared to gold
etc how many people hold bitcoin versus
people that hold gold
i think uh the second big by and that's
10 trillion dollars right so that gets
you a factor of
20 to 50 there
the second bucket is people with uh with
bonds
17 trillion dollars of negative yielding
debt a hundred trillion dollars of zero
to three percent yielding debt
what why are you putting money in bonds
sovereign wealth it's a safe haven so
people's reaction is the market gets
scary they run to a safe haven i think
it's pretty important in the in the
crypto industry and with regard to
bitcoin you position bitcoin as
the the ultimate long duration safe
haven asset so they run to it instead of
running to sovereign debt
to again another factor of 10 20 30. and
then finally
you've got a pool of big tech investors
a lot you could argue a lot of people
are using uh big tech like tesla apple
amazon as a store of value
they've lost faith in the currency
they know they can't invest in negative
yielding bonds
they're not quite sure about gold i mean
gold is defective it's an antiquated
store of value it was the best store of
value for 5 000 years until we invented
the computers easy right like yeah
it's like it's like the canon
camera was the best way to take photos
we put put photos and shoe boxes in our
attic until we invented the iphone it
was a good idea until it became not a
good idea libraries were a good idea
until google gave away a million books
for a nickel for everybody on earth and
then it became not so good an idea
and so what you've got here is people
running running to these things like
they're running to big tech they're
running to they're running to gold and i
i mean people are i don't know why
anybody would run to bonds by the way
like like slobber and debt yielding
negative i can't figure that one out but
they're all looking for a store of value
add up those three
it's 150 trillion dollars
you know bitcoin is 350. so the only
reason people wouldn't
buy into the idea of a crypto asset as a
treasury reserve
is because they don't understand it
or or they're afraid or when they show
up like when they show up to the
exchanges they get confused
so i i think that when i show up to
exchange if you show me
bitcoin versus gold versus sovereign
debt versus big tech and bitcoin
volatility versus apple volatility you
know by the way everybody says bitcoin's
too volatile apple's been more volatile
than bitcoin for the last 90 days you
know if they saw bitcoin versus tesla
vault tesla volatility bitcoin
volatility tesla is more volatile
than bitcoin and so when they see this
compared to big tech to debt and to gold
then you're telling them you can trade
the one for the other when they see
bitcoin compared to tron
eos chain link
and 37 currency pairs you're telling
them they can trade bitcoin versus tron
in in
cny or brl or ars but there aren't that
many people with money in ars in tron
that are going to convert it into
bitcoin so
you're and what you need to do is you
need to frame the investment hypothesis
for people
because anybody that sees gold debt or
tesla's tesla on the ticker is going to
say oh well this is a way i could tr i
can buy this or i can buy that right
you're going to attract the money into
the industry by looking outward
to the other and to the alt assets
and comparing bitcoin to that and then
once they get into bitcoin
you can you can then trade from bitcoin
into other cryptos if you're pursuing
privacy
currency stable coin application smart
contract all the other value
propositions of the crypto industry will
come through the gateway of bitcoin but
bitcoin
bitcoin is a bitcoin is 0.1
of the ocean of investable assets
99.9
are in the asset ocean
and we're talking about 0.1
so we need to carve a channel between
that ocean and that pond and we need to
tell people it's safe to convert your
gold to bitcoin
you're not low yielding debt to bitcoin
you're big tech to bitcoin and this is a
compelling idea i think that's how we
grow the industry
that's a really great idea you've given
us an idea michael i think finding a way
to
to show volatility of bitcoin versus all
these other assets that everyone invests
in all the time
is a really digestible way to demystify
and debunk the fact that bitcoin is
actually
not as volatile as people think um so
we've got an idea there cece let's take
that one and run with it
yeah and i think it also sounds like we
have to list uh gold um tesla and a
bunch of other
other
sorry platforms soon yeah
i think this is really good actually
yeah you know you know cz i spend so
many hours with my eyes glued to the
binance screen i have i have the binance
yellow
burned into my head i have stared at it
so long because you have
the liquidity minute by minute and the
best trading information in the industry
and if i'm trying to read the market i
go i go to binance
worldwide but but and you have you've
got you've got the makings of the
bloomberg of this space
if you
if you actually started to park tesla
amazon apple gold
you know and bond index metrics or
nasdaq metrics or or
or the like there then every big ev
every conventional investor that's not
currently a bitcoin or a crypto investor
would be going there thinking this is
cool i'll make one more point you know i
give a lot of interviews and i meet a
lot of people whenever anybody wants to
impress me with their deep knowledge of
investing in bitcoin you know what they
say like well you know that's very
interesting but you know isn't it
volatile
that i mean it's like the only thing
they've learned in a decade is sometime
in the last decade it was volatile
and what i say is i've stared at it
every day for the past 180 days
i have investments in 30-year u.s
sovereign bonds many days they're more
volatile
you know i have investments in apple
it's more volatile i've watched the
nasdaq be more volatile some days i've
watched 10 and 30-year debt be more
volatile i've watched silver be more
volatile nobody knocks those things
tesla obviously is more volatile than
the poster child of volatile and most
people don't really know what how
volatile it is and
if we had the rolling 30 and 90 day
volatility or the rolling 12-month
volatility was parked as a number
then then people wouldn't be you know
they're remembering that mount gox was
there was some volatility back then or
2017
and you you can't compete against
someone's memory of what you were when
you were 13 years old or when you were a
kid and they're like did you throw a
temper tantrum when you were in junior
high school i'm like well
i'm like 28 years old now i'm i mean
like why are you holding that against me
and the answer because we don't put it
in front of their face and if we could
if people are just saying
yeah you know bitcoin is 82 percent as
volatile as apple this month and here we
go
oh wow
yeah completely narrative
yeah yeah well so on picking up on one
thing that you've you've said there
michael um gold
i'd be
probably uh remiss not to talk about
gold for at least a minute or two um
bitcoin digital gold that's been the
narrative some people say that's
generous some people say that's not
doing a service at all uh to to bitcoin
um i remember you saying that bitcoin
was i think it was a million times
better than gold that's a bold claim
um so do you believe that it's already
replacing gold and if so you know why
it is a million times better than gold
and it's a million times better than
gold because of two ideas one
it is it is engineered virtual gold
which means it is all the virtues of
gold none of the liabilities of gold
right it's not centralized it has no
mass it moves at the speed of light
it's absolutely capped if god designed
virtual gold in cyberspace he would have
designed bitcoin okay
you know people that know this know that
god's name is satoshi right so
so that's one reason
but the other reason is because bitcoin
isn't just a synthetic safe haven asset
engineered to be spirit of gold bitcoin
is also
the world's first
thermodynamically sound monetary network
it it is a big tech
digital network it's facebook for money
or google for money or or like youtube
for money which means that when you act
it's a network engineered to host that
safe haven asset and it's an open
network so
every knock on bitcoin like well maybe
the transactions aren't too fast well
you know i watch binance they're pretty
fast on binance you know you're you're
going to but into bitcoin and a lot of a
lot of people's view of bitcoin is how
fast binance moves
and and so if it if you wanted to be a
payment network you plug square or
paypal into it it gets better
if you want it to be a trading network
or a finance company you plug binance
into it it gets better if you want to be
an institutional offer and you plug
grayscale or nydig into it it gets
better it's an open you want it to be
more secure you know you've got your
cold storage hardware wallets on one
extreme
you want it to be easier you know
eventually it's going to get built into
apple pay and google pay why
because apple pay and google are going
to have to respond to square and paypal
why
because
politicians destroyed the savings
account and if i take square cash
application without bitcoin it's a free
checking account and i can move money
around but when i take square cash
application and i plug in bitcoin
it's a free checking account with a
savings account that's been yielding a
hundred percent interest tax-free over
the past decade every year
so do you want a savings account that
yields a 100 interest of your paypal or
or square yeah
do 7.8 billion people want it yeah
can apple and google and facebook afford
to not offer a savings account in
cyberspace that yields a hundred percent
more than the next bank
not i mean like this is not a lot but a
little trinket right this is about
gives you
zero interest and your money your money
is worth half as much in 36 months or
it's going up and doubling every year
so
why is bitcoin a million times better
than gold because you can engineer it
into
a mobile app into an exchange into any
piece of software and it's on an open
protocol
so that that idea of an open monetary
network
where where virtual gold moves at the
speed of light and eventually
finds its way into amazon and google and
facebook and apple and you know and
square and and then there's this little
war right like square's going to be
paypal so they need one more button you
know and apple's going to like put in
one more button and who's going to win
the market right i mean it's you guys
know it's a very brutal market in
exchanges right it's what's the next
feature you're going to add
nobody is going to engineer another
feature into gold right
old is going to be the same thing it has
been
you know the last innovation was like a
london good delivery bar with 400
ounces
stamped or whatever okay
that's your best innovation how do you
make how do you engineer better and the
point is you can't any more than you can
improve polaroid pictures than a shoe
box and you're adding it can't make them
better
yeah i think i think michael says
something that's really really
interesting there um i think what uh
what michael described there is
partially um what binance card does
today which allows you to spend crypto
directly from your crypto savings
account and it actually works with
google pay and apple pay but not in all
or
not in all locations now so we will
definitely absolutely work on to uh to
to to to increase the coverage of that
but there's something else that michael
you mentioned that that's really
interesting i want to pick your brand a
little bit which is you mentioned
pension funds and sovereign sovereign
funds right so now we have
individuals investing in crypto public
companies now investing in crypto when
do you think the pension funds and
sovereign funds are going to are going
to jump in and what process is going to
require them to come into to do this
because eventually they will have to
they will they will have to they'll have
to abandon ship and hold some bitcoin
right
i i wouldn't be surprised if we don't
start to read about
pension funds and sovereign wealth funds
investing in in bitcoin next year and in
the next 12 months
um
look this is
god's gift right this is the perfect
instrument for someone that needs long
duration
so when i look at anything i look out a
hundred years cz and then i look out 30
years i look out 10 years
you know and if you need if you need to
leave wealth
to
your your grandchildren in 30 years
how are you gonna do it and if you
needed to leave it to your great great
grandchildren and a hundred years how
are you gonna do it and and you cycle
through you're like well real estate's
gonna get taxed away and maybe the
regime will fail and you can't carry
your real estate from one place to
another place
companies are getting taxed on income
tax employment tax tariffs
etc and they've got corporate risk and
they've got massive competition you
can't be sure any company will be in a
hundred years
you know then then you've got bonds well
every bond is unless it's growing faster
than the money supply it's diluting so
you're going to lose most of your bond
then you've got gold and you know gold
miners are gonna print it you know two
three percent a year and then it's
corruptable and you can counterfeit it
and the dir and the pro you know they're
derivatives and they're not backed one
for one they're fractional derivatives
so
so you're on this mad dash how do i find
something that i can hold forever
and a lot of a lot of times you know
individuals that are trading they're
thinking what forever is 30 days right
like three days
you know like three months
three years like no who thinks past
three years
well pension funds by by charter they
have to think 30 years
they have to think 50 years they have to
think you know a hundred years a durable
thing so
find me the best long duration store of
value in the world and
and the answer is
every single monetary network the fiat
networks bond networks stock networks
real estate networks they're not closed
systems you can create more of them
which means that they have a leak they
bleed energy two percent a year three
percent a year one percent a year seven
percent a year
well
bitcoin is the one thing that's a closed
system you can't create more than 21
million coins
you might slightly decrease the amount
but they're never going to be more than
that
and the definition of a closed system is
is you can't put mass in
all you can do is put energy in
and energy
is
monetary energy
right it's money so as as monetary
energy flows into bitcoin it sits like a
like in the network like a monetary
battery
this is a battery that will hold the
charge for 100 years
that's the big idea no one's
the institutions are just now starting
to wake up to this idea that
if you put your energy into a real
electric battery it drains two percent a
month you're going to lose 24 of your
electricity in a year you put it into a
gold battery you lose 3 a year
you put it into bitcoin you're not
losing any
energy
that makes it so superior for every
pension fund every everyone looking for
a long duration
that once that message gets out
they're gonna stampede to it it's just a
matter of education and them getting
comfortable
and then solving all the on-ramp issues
you know and making it easy for them
that's our job yeah yeah education
well we do a lot of it and we want to do
more of it i think but we need all of
these really compelling narratives and
bringing them to as many people as
possible
and on that topic cz you've talked a lot
about how
bitcoin can act as an ideal hedge
against devaluing currencies
this is becoming even more topical
during this really strange 2020 clovid
year that we've all been in
has your view changed or has your view
reinforced based on what you've seen
government action throughout 2020
oh yeah i mean my views definitely
reinforced um so yeah i think basically
i've come to the i've come to this view
a few a couple years ago and then um
what's happening in 2020 is just
eyes opening like i didn't think it
would happen this fast
but having covid having the pademic
economic uh
shutdowns
and then government printing money like
crazy really really demonstrated that
this concept of
some money right so bitcoin is a
deflationary people lose it here and
there so it doesn't increase it slowly
decreases over time
and then it is yep and then like earlier
this year in march uh in april people
says why did bitcoin drop uh together
with uh
traditional fiat instruments stocks and
people are questioning is it the store
value or not but now look it's very very
clear right it is a very good store
value and um so i think um uh yeah i
think what uh what's really interesting
is michael does have the long-term
version the long-term mindset whereas
people who are trading actively um they
have a very short mindset and when you
look at things on a shorter horizon yes
it is volatile maybe less volatile than
tesla or even apple but it is still very
relatively volatile in the short term in
on the short time frames but when you
when you when you look at a longer time
frame bitcoin has just jumped like a few
times in history and i think will
continue to jump um in the long run so
yeah all of my views are super super
strongly and for uh reinforced this year
so i'm i just
well i don't have any fiat so i couldn't
buy bitcoin i couldn't buy more
cryptocurrency so
so my assets are already all crypto but
yeah i'm not
i don't even think about selling
in terms of selling it anymore it's just
it's asset i hold it's asset i spend
when i when i need to spend it i swipe
my binance card or whatever and um i i'm
this is the asset i hold i'm using it to
buy stuff i'm not i'm not selling this
stuff into fiat like why would i do that
right so uh yeah so that that's kind of
my view i think which
is very much in line with uh uh what
michael tweeted a few days ago
you have to buy everything into bitcoin
you only want to buy you only want to
buy the with the money that you want to
keep yeah
yeah absolutely so just just for the
record cesar you said something
interesting there
you do not hold any fiat currency at
this moment in time
no i i i hold like a couple thousand
dollars ish um so basically just
just there are parts of our lives which
we still have to spend fiat so i only
convert when i have to spend so i don't
i don't hold any meaningful amount at
all
in vr currencies josh i think the
metaphor is it used to be a checking
account in a savings account and your
savings account uh
paid you five percent interest or six
and money didn't keep devaluing and and
the checking account didn't pay you an
interest you could write check and pay
bills in it
and then along came this banking
innovation that you could actually write
checks against your savings account so
everybody put all their money in the
savings account because who doesn't want
to get interest on their money
and then of course the next innovation
is banks took the interest rate of
savings account to zero
right and then the next innovation is
they took they started making the money
worth 10 or 15 percent less every year
so when cz keeps all his money in crypto
it's the same as saying well do you want
to store your money in something like
bitcoin that's gone up a hundred percent
on average per year
for the last decade or do you want to
keep it in something which is going to
go up zero percent per year
and so when someone says well i
allocated two percent of my portfolio to
bitcoin and 98 of my portfolio to other
things i think
well you're going to buy a basket of
fiat instruments that are going to be
debased at 10 to 15 a year while you
have a small percentage of things
that are going to go up in value it it
doesn't make any sense that you would
you would people go well i'm managing
risk
well you're 100 guaranteed to lose half
your money in 36 months if you invest in
cash instruments so how are you managing
risk to guarantee that you're losing
half your money yeah that's what they're
called
management of decline yeah manage
decline
no they're guaranteed to decline they
don't want any risk of it not declining
yeah exactly wow that's a new pro that's
a new product we should we should market
that yeah um so michael you're you're a
bull you're a bitcoin bull you've even
had people writing songs about you i'm
not gonna ask you what your view of that
song is um but just a thumbs up or a
thumbs down we'll do finale
i think that the big the big advantage
of bitcoin is it's a swarm of cyber
hornets and they're doing things to help
the ecosystem all the time right whether
you know about it or not
and i just love the creativity of the
hive mind right this creature that's
just massively
parallel
processing innovating and researching
and developing ideas to see what's going
to work and if it'll help then it gets
elevated through the system to the good
of everybody and and i like that
creativity it's great
brilliant love the metaphor
do you have any other interest then
i'm not saying holdings but i mean just
interest philosophically practical
interest in other crypto assets or any
other protocols out there
you know my interest in crypto i i look
at crypto as creating life in cyber
space
and so
you write the protocol is the dna
and you're releasing a life form
and and bitcoin is like a base level
life form it's almost like the allergy
which is the base plankton level of all
life on earth right it's it's
a plant life
and then you can create other forms of
life that you can release
life that
life that might do things that bitcoin
doesn't do right i mean we all know that
bitcoin doesn't do everything it doesn't
do as much privacy as you would want it
doesn't do as much smart contracts as
you would want it doesn't do
as as fast as transactions as you would
want these are all different life forms
now why do you want a life form in in
cyberspace or a crypto
if you're in search of immortal
sovereignty
right if you need something to transcend
a government a country or a company
not not everything needs to by the way i
i love binance as a digital exchange and
i don't need it to transcend you cz or
transcend but i think it's
i mean
i if if i want to give all my money to
my great great great great grandchildren
i'm more likely to do it in bitcoin
than do it then leave it on the binance
exchange and you could figure out why
right but at the same time
i think that the world needs to have a
mixture of cryptos a mixture of digital
assets you know there's a place for all
these things and
i think that um
that uh the real key is you you know
when you're playing god
in cyberspace
you kind of got to get the genetic dna
protocol just right before you and then
you release it
and then you let it grow and it fills
its ecosystem and
and what we've got is the cambrian
explosion of of crypto life forms
and some are going to live
and some are not going to live
and the market is like this darwinian
natural selection process
right and uh you know we'll see what
happens it's fascinating
yeah survival of the fittest
i think so really yeah i i i like i
share an almost identical view as
michael um on this topic um yeah i mean
there's there are um there are many
bitcoin is the most decentralized uh
based platform um it is the is the king
of all the other cryptocurrencies there
are other innovations which many people
are doing in this ecosystem and which we
are participating
and um yeah and it's good it's good to
have this uh uh ecosystems of life forms
uh here but um the majority of them will
not stay forever and but the one percent
one will grow to be much bigger so um
yeah i i i share that with you very very
strongly
fantastic
go ahead
so i was just going to draw this section
to a close um and we're going to move
into what we're calling the quick fire
questions some are crypto related some
have absolutely nothing to do with
crypto so i hope you've prepared
yourselves um we're going to ask some
hard talk here nothing too spicy or
controversial so don't be scared but we
will be asking some good questions um cz
i'm going to start with you
when did you
first start looking at bitcoin seriously
can you think of the month
or even the year of course but can you
think of the month when you thought
right this is something i'm going to get
involved with
i first heard about in july july 2017
2013 and by october it was the first
time i bought bitcoin and um and by
december i knew i was full i was all-in
i was selling my house
quitting my job and or or for bitcoin so
uh 2013 was what was end of 2013 was
that was the time for me
and when you sold your house on a scale
of 1 to 10 10 being terrified one being
completely zen how terrified were you
when you sold it for bitcoin
um no i i stole my house into fiat which
took me six months and i saw the price
uh uh uh uh going up and down so i was
very anxious not not so much terrified i
was just very anxious to get it done as
soon as soon as possible
and then um
it was actually really after i i bought
in i was a little bit terrified because
the price dropped very quickly so
so uh and it stayed there for about two
years so i bought in around 600 brought
to you by 200 stayed there for for quite
a while for like a year and a half um so
it was a little bit mentally stressful
but my lifestyle didn't get impacted
that much i live a pretty pretty simple
lifestyle even today so um yeah so that
wasn't
it was
a little bit mentally stressful but
wasn't that bad
brilliant and michael for you when you
decided to go all in on bitcoin can you
pinpoint maybe the month and the year
when this happened and then you thought
right i'm gonna become this champion of
this digital asset
april this year
[Laughter]
march march was a wake-up call
you know
april was uh was a quest for the truth
you know to rethink everything that i
believed about macroeconomics
and investment and and the world and
and by the end of april you know as we
moved into may it was pretty clear to me
that that this was the future
and how did you get there when you say
the quest for truth were you speaking to
people were you reading what was that
process like yeah
you know uh you can learn anything on
youtube it was
on the internet and youtube it was it
was a lot of watching
youtube videos you know by all the great
andreas and i i watched the peter schiff
eric voorhees debates and
and i watched pomp's videos and then i
sent a lot of time scrolling around
finance academy and and then i
read all the papers by parker lewis and
dj boyla potty and then i read the
bitcoin
standard by seifidin i listened to more
podcasts than probably one should and
and after i made it through
all of that stuff and then i started
browsing a little crypto twitter
then i came to a conclusion
yeah so michael i remember like the one
year in like half a year one year in for
me was also my most vocal uh people
think i'm vocal now but i was much more
vocal back then like promoting bitcoin i
really loved
but i think michael also has a a
personality where uh once he understood
bitcoin once he got into it he
he wrapped his head around it very
tightly and then and he's pushing really
really hard i remember that stage for me
as well i still do today but not as
aggressively
but yeah
those are very fun times yeah
awesome okay second question uh cz
who do you admire
um i admire a lot of people actually um
actually i just read uh michael sellers
book uh on the mobile wave
and when i was reading the as i was just
reading this a couple days ago i was
like well that's you know that reads
more like a documentary now but you at
the time was written none of the things
happened in the book actually happened
so um i think so uh so i i do read it i
do listen quite a lot these days uh for
books so i i respect a lot of the
authors a lot of entrepreneurs i think
elon musk's probably some somebody i
really admire as well he's like he has
true audacity and
and hardcore push so um yeah there are
other there are other guys uh
there's a lot of guys so i don't really
have a particular one um yeah
great okay same question to you michael
john d rockefeller i i think you should
i would recommend anybody read titan
read the history of rockefeller
i mean he lived to 99 in three quarters
and uh and he kind of wrote the book on
on creating an energy network i mean the
beauty of bitcoin is bitcoin is uh is
the first great crypto monetary network
in the history of the world and it's a
it's a profound achievement
because it's going to decrease the cost
of moving money by a factor of a
thousand or something it's an elemental
force
what what standard oil was was imposing
a standard way to extract energy and
deliver it all through the world and
they reduced the cost of energy by a
factor of a thousand and it was critical
to the 20th century
and
everything you can do in business and
everything you should be thinking about
as an engineer in order to change the
world with technology rockefeller
struggled with those things and
succeeded
and it's just an extraordinary story if
you look at at what what they did the
impact on the world
and then what he did with that money
brilliant
okay
uh what do you like to do cz when you're
not working
um i actually just swim a little bit and
then just listen to books um and well i
do socialize with colleagues as well
yeah
brilliant okay mike
yeah michael how about you
i spend time on the water i like to go
yachting i move around i find water i i
proceed to the watery part of the world
and i find beautiful places
that sounds absolutely lovely good
especially good having uh having a boat
during these covered times so you can
escape the lockdown
right okay guys so we're going to move
into the third section of today's
fireside
the community we have so many questions
and i have no idea how we're going to
cover all of them but we we will do our
absolute best to cover as many as we can
so please do bear with us and thank you
for sending uh all of the questions
so far so i'm going to bring some up
here um
so a question from
philos hippos nice name uh thanks for
joining us philos um does a store of
value like bitcoin necessarily have to
be decentralized what if government
comes up with a centralized fixed
usd euro or cny token would this be a
threat to bitcoin interesting um do you
want to take that michael
sure
i mean i think that the whole point is
if you want to store a value it needs to
transcend any company and any government
so that no individual can
can change the rules and inflate it away
so
i don't see any anything issued by a
company or issued by a government to be
competitive for it to be truly property
in cyberspace it has to be owned by no
one controllable by no one so that no
one even with a gun to their head could
change the consensus
as long as any one person group company
or government has any control or power
over it
it's not it's not an elemental force in
cyberspace
it's not
nobody can force you to change the laws
of gravity and the laws of
thermodynamics if you step off a cliff
you're going to die it doesn't matter
whether you run a country you're the
richest man in the world you're going to
die and so for this to be a store of
value it needs to be a store of energy
store of energy means respect the laws
of thermodynamics you can't allow any
company any government to meddle with
the laws of thermodynamics and and hence
it's got to be decentralized it's got to
be outside the control of any human
being for it to be thermodynamically and
mathematically sound
yeah and also like when you when you
depend on a central party either bank or
government or
um the the guys were in that the guys
who are in that institution changes over
time and peop the guys who have power
wants more power and their power and
influence their power will grow over
time they will have they'll have control
over and they will change the rules um
so only something that's mathematically
insured and physically insured
it is going to be a true store value so
i don't yeah i don't think that
that can be issued by a single entity
makes sense okay
so we've got a question here from alex
hi alex do you think the d5 space will
challenge traditional finance over the
next five years and that's for you susie
yeah absolutely um i think
they will i think we've only just seen
the tip of the iceberg probably i think
that's going to be a lot more innovation
in the d5 space um and today none of
them are super big to be honest they've
grown quite quite a lot in the last year
um but we're i think we're just kind of
looking at the tip of the iceberg right
now so i think binance.com in the
centralized exchange could be very well
challenged as well and but i think
before that is truly challenged a lot of
the traditional businesses or financial
institutions will be challenged a little
bit more so we'll see what happens uh
but i i i fully think that the set the
future is decentralized and we also have
multiple experiments in that realm and
hopefully one of them or one of a few of
them will will be successful
brilliant
so question from wilfred michael hi
michael
can you tell us if other tech ceos have
contacted you since you started
investing in bitcoin
i do hear from
from a lot of interesting ceos and high
net worth individuals and
and they all want to understand what's
going on it's it's really raised the
awareness of bitcoin quite a bit this uh
by this action
and uh
i i can't tell you what they're gonna do
i'm not allowed to talk about that i can
tell you that
the amount of interest and awareness has
increased by orders of magnitude since
we made our announcement and i and i'm
i'm happy to see that awareness growing
i think
i i think that bitcoin is the solution
to 7.8 billion people's problems they
just don't know it yet
right
right yeah yeah and michael if i can
i'll take this brief moment to say uh on
behalf of the people who uh at least my
fans on twitter or people who in this
industry we really really appreciate
what you did um to make this awareness
much much higher among
especially the institutions and other um
sort of traditional
uh
funds companies et cetera so i think you
really brought you really helped broad
bring bitcoin crypto industry to the
next level
um it's to be very honest it's not
completely you but it definitely helped
a big chunk so we really appreciate it
well thank you i like i would say i'm
standing on the shoulders of giants
i waited till after march i'm a late
bloomer and all the hard work had been
done
by the og's by the exchanges by the
writers it's they're the ones that did
the work i just had a very big problem
and it was the solution and i kind of
put the problem and the solution
together i i think that that deciding to
get in this business after march of this
year is pretty much the most
straightforward
decision
it's
we just happened to be the first you
know year one of making a
straightforward decision deciding to get
into this business before march of this
year i would say is visionary and
courageous
uh michael i think i think in five years
people will say the same thing five
years later so
yeah
okay uh another question coming in from
murphy alex or alex murphy um sorry if
i'm butchering your name uh whales and
sharks dominate the bitcoin market so is
there a place for a small trader like me
cz what do you think
um i think well basically uh in any
trading market there are um the larger
funds do have somewhat uh uh advantages
um just as in life um so they they are
able to invest in better tools uh
they're able to hire larger teams
they've more sophisticated strategies et
cetera
i think
as far as trade active trading goes i
think we do want to ask yourself if you
are a good active trader if you if
you're a good active trader then yes you
can continue to trade if you're not a
good active trader i actually don't
recommend people to become day traders
just because they're now entering into
crypto that doesn't make sense if you're
not an active trader in the traditional
financial space you should not suddenly
become an active trader in the crypto
space
and if this is something that you want
to learn uh in the crypto space use very
limit you use very small portions of
your funds to do that so don't risk very
large amounts so i'm actually i usually
advise people not to become active
traders um but
i encourage people a lot more what
michael is doing which is buy and hold
long term uh if you buy the whole long
term it's a it's a much much easier
thing to handle so uh that would be my
advice for
anyone who's asking this type of
questions yes they the larger
institutional guys do have a lot of
tools that you may or may not have and
uh trading is not for everyone um yeah
but uh
but as a asset fund management is a
portfolio management is for everyone
everyone has to do it you have to manage
your financials so learn about that that
does not mean active trading that
usually means buying a home
makes sense okay
michael we've got a question here from
the bakery swap team
and they want to know what your thoughts
are around
corporate investments that don't include
bitcoin as a way to protect capital in
the long term so i think they're getting
here at are there any defy assets or
crypto tokens that are of a more defined
nature that could at some point in the
future be part of the thinking around
diversifying corporate assets and
treasury assets
i think um
the most important thing we can do
to attract corporate assets is to
provide them
with uh
with a safe haven long duration
extremely simple understandable
value proposition so bitcoin is going to
be the gateway
to to bring any corporate treasury into
the crypto industry there there if
you're a corporation
you're going to want to see something
that has not changed ideally for a
decade
five years if you if you introduce
something in five years later it's
exactly the same and doing exactly the
same thing then people start to think i
can put a lot of weight on that so so i
think you're you're building the
foundation from there and the right way
to think about it is get the
corporations
to buy uh to buy bitcoin and then once
they bought bitcoin
they're going to look at other op
alternatives or other options as the
industry grows and if they find
something that suits their needs they
may pursue it but but i think that the
killer application for corporations is
store of value
and store of value just means i just
want to take my treasury and not lose
purchasing power
i i think that most companies they're
not look corporation corporate
treasuries they're not looking for
functionality in the form of smart
contracts they're not looking for
privacy right corporations can't have
privacy it's all especially a public
company by definition i think
so they're not looking for functionality
they're not looking for d5 they're not
looking for privacy what they're looking
for is store of value and and what
you're competing against is short
duration sovereign debt
they're either holding cash or sovereign
debt they're not even going to hold gold
by the way right most companies won't
buy gold so
you know your lift is you have to
convince corporations that rather than
hold a five-year
debt instrument from the us government
or the eu they should hold
a crypto asset and they're going to want
the safest
most widely adopted crypto asset and if
if a hundred other
billion dollar institutions own that
asset
they will consider it
as a potential allocation right but
that's where we are in this life cycle
we need to we need to just keep working
that that'll be going on for five years
ten years probably
brilliant okay
final question for you um
michael you've got some interesting
developments we understand around an
initiative based on bitcoin's security
and integrity is that something you'd
like to tell us about today
look i i think that um it's really
important that we focus
upon making large institutions
comfortable that bitcoin is the most
secure
safe haven long duration asset one thing
they love to see is that the industry is
is doing everything it can
to avoid introducing bugs into bitcoin
and to protect it against
hacker attacks or the like and so
security is
very close to my heart
um
mit dci i think is is a great
organization they've done really great
work on bitcoin core
and they're spinning up a security
initiative and i'm working actively to
support that security initiative right
now and i think
you'll you'll hear more things on that
subject uh as we go into january i
suspect
um
very interesting very very interesting
um we will keep our keep our eyes peeled
i think you're all mute there cz by the
way um
okay interesting very interesting
we are all ears in all eyes so we look
forward to hearing more
very good well um cz michael we've drawn
to the end of today's fireside session
thank you so much to you both for
joining us it's been a real pleasure
kicking off the first of many upcoming
finance fireside chats we hope to have
you both back very very soon um and we
want to continue the conversation we've
only covered probably half of the ground
that we wanted to cover today but we've
had a really fantastic time doing it so
thanks to you both thanks to the
community for joining us along this ride
and if you have any questions that we
weren't able to cover with either cz or
michael do tweet them uh they are active
on twitter at all hours of the day so do
feel free to tweet them after the show
if you've got any follow-ups but thank
you very much again chaps
yeah michael thank you so much for for
joining this and um um yeah i'll come
back with you offline when we can chat
more
awful awesome thank you nice nice to be
with both of you today
thank you thanks michael thanks easy