The Nature of Energy with Michael Saylor (WiM314)
Robert Breedlove · 2023-05-17 · 2h 38m · View on YouTube →
and this is kind of a conundrum it's the
society that is best for your mental
health your physical health and your
economic health is one full of checks
and balances with decentralized power
lots of 50 states with control of the
money 50 states that have the ability to
say no right the more decentralized the
Power uh the more peaceful the society
is and the more productive the society
is
unfortunately the society that tends to
win the wars vote both be able to start
the wars and be able to win the wars
tends to be the most centralized Society
it's generally the least healthy
physically serves you bad food right
it's you know you're most likely to get
drafted and and uh be maimed or killed
in a conflict so it's physically
unhealthy it's economically unhealthy
you know it's most mentally unhealthy
because you're being forced to go kill
people
so
That's The Human Condition right it's a
bit of a conundrum but it all comes back
to Power and energy
and uh
you you can't ignore the energy you
can't ignore the machines that channel
the energy because if you ignore it uh
then those machines will be used against
you right
hey everybody Welcome to the what is
money show I am thrilled to have you
here joining me on my mission to help
shine light on the production of money
now if this is your first time listening
to the what is money show I strongly
recommend that you go back to episodes
one through nine first
which lays a lot of the groundwork for
many of the concepts that we explore on
the show these first line episodes are
my series with Michael Saylor and
thousands of people have told me that
this is the best podcast series they've
ever heard hands down and that it was
instrumental to their understanding of
money in Bitcoin
so if you're looking to start a deep
dive into the nature of money I don't
think there's any place better that you
can start other than episode one of this
show now a little bit about this show
and how it makes money what is my show
is 100 sponsor based so all of our
revenues are derived from direct
sponsorships and I strive to be very
selective about the sponsors that I work
with specific typically only using
sponsors that I use personally and also
choosing sponsors that have values which
are well aligned to the values expressed
on this show such as Freedom education
self-sovereignty
Etc so what I'm going to do now is a few
ad reads right at the top of the show
and I'll do a few more ad reads in the
middle and I hope you'll take the time
to listen to them as again these are
hand selected sponsors and I think
you'll like what they have to offer
today's podcast is brought to you by in
Wolf's clothing wolf is the first
startup accelerator dedicated
exclusively to the Bitcoin lightning
Network
four times per year wolf brings teams
from around the world to New York City
to work with like-minded entrepreneurs
pushing the boundaries of what's
possible with Bitcoin and lightning
the program is designed to help early
stage companies achieve product Market
fit develop their brand secure early
stage funding and grow businesses that
help fuel the global adoption of Bitcoin
so go to
wolfnyc.com to learn more about the
program or apply again that's wolfnyc
w-o-l-f-n-y-c.com
Michael Saylor welcome back to the what
is money show thanks for having me
Robert happy to see you here in person
in Miami Beach I'm happy to see you as
well we are right on the eve of Bitcoin
2023 which is a massive event uh Lots
going on this week lots of talks lots of
events
um and you of course are a very special
guest as you were the first guests on
the show
and this is the first time we've done
this in person actually so this is a
very special episode
and
one of the things that I think you
popularized for a lot of people or one
of the connections conceptual
connections you made for me and many
other people
was this connection between money and
energy
and when I brought you on the show and
asked you originally you know what is
money and you started descript to
describe it as one of the highest if not
the highest form of energy that humans
can Channel
um it crystallized a lot of things for
me and just connected money into kind of
physics and engineering and there's a
whole nother perspective
on money
and it it naturally kind of begs this
deeper question I guess which is what is
the actual nature of energy itself
and I'd shared this with you before but
I'd read this book called
interdependence
that described energy as the quantity
that remains constant across all
physical transformations
so whereas I had conceived of it as
something that like flows and moves and
transforms it was really just saying
that it's just this description of
reality that we've applied that the one
thing that doesn't change across
Transformations is energy so
what I would like to ask you and the
theme of the show of being about deep
questions is
Michael what is energy what is the the
nature of energy and I guess a little
more broadly how is it related to power
and the development of human
civilization
that's a great question Robert
um
I I went to MIT and and my primary
academic influence was Aeronautical
Engineering and an Aeronautical
Engineering you study thermodynamics and
you study Energy Systems and and you
study machines and machines or
mechanisms to channel energy in order to
convert potential energy to kinetic
energy or to heat energy
or the like so
I'd never really thought about energy or
power in the context of money
or economics or politics or even history
probably until I encountered Bitcoin and
especially until you kind of
you catalyzed me to think this way by
asking the question what is money
so if you yeah believe it or not there
are plenty of people that make it into
their middle age or or their seniority
and they never ask the question what is
money and if you don't ask the question
what is money then
you never really start to question
political energy economic energy or
economic or political machines from an
engineer's point of view
so I think I was fortunate of an
engineer's background and then to stop
take a clean sheet of paper and consider
the question
what is money and when you start asking
that question it brings you back to just
the fundamentals of what is energy
and um you know as you know I think
Einstein pointed out very famously
energy it can matter can neither be dis
created or destroyed energy can be
neither created or destroyed energy is
matter matter is energy E equals m c
squared it's a very famous equation but
very profound now you know it is a lay
person
if you've ever watched a bonfire you're
watching wood which is material get
thrown into a reaction and you're seeing
forms of energy
um come out of that bonfire you see
light which is one form of energy and
you see you feel heat another form of
energy and of course you see a
transmutation of the material and you
started out with wood and you end up
with charcoal or something that looks
different eventually senders
our universe is full of examples of that
right sunlight striking the Earth and
somehow you end up with a green tree or
algae
and that somehow morphs into bacteria
that morphs into insects and then worms
and then you've got Birds I got birds in
my yard every day and they're eating the
worms and and uh running from the Hawks
you know and there's an entire food
chain or energy chain
from the top to the bottom now if we if
we just think of energy is as uh the
universal
the universal source of of life of
substance
period
I want to say in the universe but the
point is it's the universal source and
and energy is such a fundamental term
like the universal source of energy is
energy you almost feel silly to say it
um there's a certain amount of energy in
the universe there's a certain amount of
energy in the solar system
for the most part there's a certain
amount of energy striking the Earth and
power of course is the rate of energy
output or or energy conversion if you
will
in the in the world of engineering if we
have a constant Energy System where the
energy is neither entering the system
nor leaving the system we call that an
adiabatic system no energy lapse and in
uh in the field of thermodynamics very
oftentimes your posed questions how do I
solve this problem and and what is your
forecaster or what is likely to happen
given an adiabatic system
and uh the way you say the reason you
say that is because if you actually
allow for energy to enter the system or
to leave the system all of the
engineering Solutions are no longer
valid for example
if Miami Beach it you know is uh
if you if you visit Miami Beach on a
clear day and the sun is shining us 80
degrees and there's not a cloud in the
sky
and everything is normal quote unquote
you can probably forecast a happy day on
the beach and you can probably forecast
you know what will happen in the
restaurants the hotels the the average
traffic level
um the health the mental health the
physical health of the people you can
probably forecast the motion of the
parrots I have a flock of parrots that
come to my house every day about five
o'clock we call it parrot o'clock and
they all squawk and have a big party so
you can forecast all those things
and you probably won't be off by plus or
minus two percent
but
if I add some energy to the system
like a tidal wave
50 feet high ing the beach now you
realize that all these other models are
all broken right you can't you know none
of your math none of your physics none
of your history is relevant because you
have introduced excess energy into the
system a hurricane
Miami Beach is a very different
experience during a hurricane if you
look at photos of Miami Beach during a
number of hurricanes right different
stuff happens so that's an example of
introducing a lot of energy and changing
the balance of power the opposite would
be sucking the energy out of the system
what happens when the temperature gets
to 30 degrees in Miami Beach
you probably won't see people running
around happy on the beach and bathing
suits playing volleyball right you
probably won't see as many people
right you you won't see the same
commercial patterns in the restaurants
and the bars you won't see the same
traffic patterns right so so energy
matters but but
um once you come to terms with this
Engineers know it intuitively that's why
every engineering problem given to an
engineering student starts with the
phrase assuming an adiabatic system
how do you design an airfoil how do you
know what will be the power output or or
the output of this engine what will
happen in this circumstance
that's a pretty good pretty good
discipline for an engineer the problem
with Engineers is
oftentimes they are channel to only
consider the consequences of their
engineering training as it applies to
machines or buildings or or traditional
engineered systems
that is
don't apply the
mathematical tools or The Logical tools
you learned in engineering to politics
or banking
or war or
um or money creation
or the culture
right or to art
right just stay out of those domains and
you know you would just arm away at a
way and say it's not applicable but
when you ask the question what is money
and you're an engineer and you're
watching the money die when you're
watching a system fail
whether it's the Weimar Republic system
or whether it's Venezuela or whether
it's Nigeria or whether it's Africa or
whether it's Argentina or if you're
watching these slow failure
of the US dollar
a slow motion train wreck then you
actually have to come up with a a
physical logical mathematical
interpretation
and so here here I think it's
interesting to apply energy Theory again
and you start to you start to ask the
question well what is energy outside of
you know a narrowly defined uh machine
well so we understand with machines like
the outboard motor on
um a decent boat
you know a powerful one big one would be
300 horsepower
and that's a power rating now
um if you think about the manned machine
system what happens when you put a human
being together with a system right let's
not talk about the motor anymore let's
talk about people
with the machines and expand from there
well the typical human being uh in a one
hour workout
could probably exert a tenth of a
horsepower
well it makes sense right like 10 people
if there's a tug of war between a horse
and people there's probably 10 people on
one side there's a horse on the other
side a tenth of a horsepower
so now you know you start to ask the
question how much power can you exert
um and uh and how fast well
10 people makes a horse
a Roman tribeam or quadrine might have
anywhere from 200 to 300 rowers if you
get really efficient okay you've got 30
horsepower okay so the outboard motor
a crappy one a small one is 30 to 70
horsepower the little one little fishing
boat bass fisherman boat about equal to
300 human beings so you can see the Arc
of humanity and civilization is from uh
from uh having a tenth of a horsepower
by the way that's a healthy person right
an unhealthy person has a 30th of a
horsepower so now now you want to
understand
uh why do why do the Mongols conquer the
steps
well a bunch of soldiers on horse are
have 10 times as much power as foot
soldiers right why did the Europeans
have an advantage when they showed up in
the New World versus the Indian tribes
the Europeans had mastered horses the
Indians had not a lot more power 10x
more power
when you um
when you start to apply that to other
types of systems
and uh you know and I'll give you a few
well um
a nine millimeter handgun can generate
uh 500 kilowatts for a short burst okay
and um
um how much is that well a megawatt is
uh
1341 horsepower
right so you're talking about something
like 600 horsepower for a fraction of a
second coming out of a handgun right you
see why you would be more powerful with
the handgun
a 30 odd 6 Springfield round
will generate 4
000 kilowatts
for a short period of time
four thousand kilowatts you know um so
you
you start to think about how much power
that is it's
um four megawatts
it's five
thousand horsepower right wow it's in
one shot one kick well I'm gonna what if
I kick you with the force of 5 000
horses right you can see why uh why the
uh the soldier with the the pistol beats
the soldier with the um spear
right and um you know if you look at at
energy uh exerted let's take energy
a boxing punch if it's well thrown by a
really good boxer
would be 500 joules of energy
a handgun will also generate 500 joules
of energy but the difference of course
is the 500 joules of energy from the
handgun is very focused behind a
metallic bullet so the same energy in
maybe 1 100th of the space will punch a
hole through you plus
the average person can pull the trigger
six times
but the average person can't punch you
as hard as you know Muhammad Ali
six times right it's much much harder so
um you can see why the gun beats the
punch uh that rifle shot generates 3 800
joules
and of course you can deliver a lot more
energy in a concentrated form but also
from a much greater distance
[Music]
um an A10 has a um
you know it has a a Gau eight Avenger
Gatling gun
capable of generating uh
13 000 kilowatts of power while it's
operating doesn't operate long operates
about 20 or 30 seconds but another way
to say it is um every single round is
200 000 joules and it spits out uh 1174
of those around so so if if you unload
on some hostile population with an A-10
you spit out 234 million joules in about
30 seconds well 810 aircraft yeah it's
an attack aircraft so you see human
beings got
pretty powerful at figuring out how to
project power yeah right and and how to
channel energy
um a mark 84 bomb standard bomb uh is
1.87 gigajoules
1.87 billion joules when they dropped
that bomb little boy uh the atomic bomb
dropped on Hiroshima 63 Terra joules 63
trillion
Jewels no remember back to 500 Jewels
for the punch
you see so so who's more powerful right
uh the guy the general with 10 000
soldiers
you know or the the guy with the Gatling
gun uh bows and Spears 100 to 200 joules
of energy that you're delivering so so
the history of humanity in a and
military conflicts is determined by who
can channel the most energy and it's
pretty clear
that when you start to build hierarchies
of energy and hierarchies of power right
the the rate at which you deliver the
power
or deliver the energy over time then you
can see who are the winners who are The
Losers
you know I got very interested in it and
just general energy comparisons and
power comparisons especially when I
started studying Bitcoin mining
because Bitcoin miner let's say you want
to generate one exahash
of digital power Bitcoin mining is
digital power right it's not analog
power it's digital power Shaw 256 power
for one particular purpose and that one
purpose is uh
is cyber security right
so I want to build a wall of digital
energy to protect my data protect my
message
protect my money
so that One X Ash with modern miners
like s19s in that range is 30 megawatts
of power that's what I have to have to
put into that and that 30 megawatts of
power will generate a thousand to 1200
BTC a thousand Bitcoin a year if you run
that on a Network that has about 350
extra hash in the year 2023 right now
so that that's a that's an interesting
measure
right I mean the commercial value of
that is something in the range of 30
million dollars right a thousand times
thirty thousand right now so that gives
you a sense of Bitcoin mining and
digital power now what else has 30
megawatts
a global Express
uh InterContinental corporate jet
uh Global Express XRS has 34 megawatts
of power when it's a crew speed so it'll
cruise for about 13 hours and during
that 13 hours it's generating 34
megawatts of power moving at Mach spot
eight five
pretty magical that's it but there's
only it's only got like a 14-hour
duration right
an F-35 fighter jet
um when it gets to like Mach 2 when it's
scrambled uh a hundred and two megawatts
full energy but it can't it can't do
that long
right but it goes supersonic that's how
much power it takes 102 megawatts
an aircraft carrier
has a nuclear power plant or two perhaps
200 megawatts
but the difference uh the difference
with a nuclear-powered aircraft carriers
that's 200 megawatts that's continuously
being generated for the 20 years for the
30 years that the power plant is in
commission as opposed to 100 megawatts
generated off of jet fuel for some
number of minutes while an F-35 is
running supersonic right so you but you
see what what um
power is required and what it means and
of course
how did human beings figure out how to
how to Channel or generate 200 megawatts
of power continuously
for years
with no fuel
right that that's nuclear power Atomic
power those are nuclear power plants
that are doing that and you just realize
just how dense nuclear fuel is and just
how efficient it is compared to jet fuel
you know you in order to generate 30
megawatts of energy with um
a diesel power plant a diesel generator
you need 59
130 metric tons of diesel fuel wow right
59 000 Metron that's 443
000 barrels
of oil okay that'll cost you 41 million
dollars at 700 a ton
it works out to almost 16 cents a
kilowatt hour okay
that's a lot of energy right now imagine
replacing
imagine generating 7x that much
and being able to do it consistently
and um what you see is the passage of um
of human civilization
is this non-stop set of steps uh to find
a way to gather more energy
and uh to store more energy and then the
construction of machines to channel the
right at my at my alma mater at MIT we
study how to design Global expresses no
mean feat to channel 30 megawatts of
power at 48 000 feet when it's 80
degrees outside right flying through the
rain when you have to carry a liquid
fuel with you right and and hold it up
right but um
you know a very interesting
other exercise is um
what if you want to generate the energy
with water
you know
um a small hydroelectric power plant can
generate
between 1 and 10 megawatts
um but the Three Gorges Dam in China is
the world's largest Hydro hydroelectric
power station
had a capacity to generate twenty two
thousand five hundred megawatts of power
the uh the entire Bitcoin network runs
on 10 to 15 gigawatts of power wow okay
but imagine a large-scale hydroelectric
dam is generating anywhere from a
thousand to two thousand megawatts of
Power by converting that water into
electricity
right now and what you realize is
there are there are extraordinarily
efficient ways to generate power nuclear
power is just an extraordinary way to
generate uh Power and and energy and
harness energy
um hydroelectric is also pretty
extraordinary
um using fossil fuels like diesel or
gasoline they're flexible uh not not
nearly so impressive as 22 gigawatts off
of one Dam but but then the challenge is
I have um I have Infinite Energy coming
off that Dam but how do I put it
five miles up in the air
into an aircraft
you know I have too much energy some
places but I can't get it to the other
place
and then I have not enough energy right
my Global Express is using jet fuel
because that's what you can put up 45
000 feet and haul around in an airframe
and we haven't quite figured out the
pocket nuclear reactor that would do
that job and there's no battery that
will hold the electrical power that
comes off a hydroelectric Dam
hmm so
so uh as I as I take that in context and
I I come back to the passage of time and
the development of civilization
there seems to be this Non-Stop
trend
for
the most powerful
it's kind of it's such a tautology right
the most powerful or the most powerful
right right physically powerful or the
most political right those that actually
uh gather energy channel the energy in
order to direct the power move the power
around are then able to expand and those
civilizations flourish and they Dominate
and then the less powerful less
energetic less energy energy efficient
and less energy aware they get displaced
so examples
in pre-revolutionary war America you had
the English colonists
and they they came to the Eastern uh the
eastern coast and they engaged in
agriculture and Manufacturing
so aggro you know you're you're growing
tobacco you're growing wheat you're
growing hops you're growing cotton rye
and you're and at some point they
started smelting and creating iron
and Manufacturing Goods machinery and uh
and you know converting raw materials
like sugar
and molasses into rum and higher forms
of products so at one point
there were 20 times as many colonists in
the English colonies as there were in uh
the French colonies the French came up
the Mississippi River from New Orleans
and they came down the St Lawrence
Seaway and they engaged in fur trapping
or fur trading especially trading with
the Indians and and with Furs well
that's not nearly so labor intensive or
Manpower intensive so the colonists had
one
0.5 million people you know on the
British part of uh of North America and
then the French had 75 000.
so when the political struggle came
the uh the British the English colonists
just had a lot more manpower
and uh you know Manpower doesn't tell
the entire story because uh you know
when the Europeans came they had horses
and they had guns and they had steel and
so in that situation you could have had
less Manpower but you had more power
because you had them you had the Techno
technical power and and Machinery your
systems were more powerful so the
Indians were continually being displaced
because they didn't have manufacturing
um and they they didn't have
um the ability to project uh that power
with Weaponry but even when you would
like weaponry and uh the French and the
British both had comparable
military technology you know it's it's
almost insurmountable you know for you
to defeat a culture that has 20 x as
many people as you have
and it's very interesting there because
you know if you're hunter-gatherers
uh and you study hunter-gatherer
Societies in the p and a paleo diet what
you realize is it's it doesn't support
as many people
so uh a given uh amount of land a
hundred square miles will support
one-tenth or 120th as many people if you
engage in sort of a hunter-gatherer
Society if you if you want large
population density you have to engage in
agriculture and you plant wheat and
grain products and that's what the
Egyptians did and interestingly enough
you know if you study paleo Theory you
roll the clock back a hundred thousand
years if people lived off of a paleo
diet they had good teeth
right
um but when you go forward to 5 000
years ago after agriculture was
introduced into Egypt you find people
2000 BC that have rotting teeth
their teeth are destroyed why because
they're eating too much starch and sugar
right and uh and wheat so
if you want to live a long time right if
your goal is to stretch your life
expectancy into your 80s or your 90s you
want to avoid sugars starches alcohols
you probably want to eat a paleo diet
organic
Etc and um
I think there's enough body of knowledge
to suggest right like eating meat
10x to 20x more expensive than eating
boxed cereal products if for for a given
amount of 3000 calories I can generate
the calories with with grain products
and Breads and the like much Biscuit the
Romans actually had biscuit factories
and they manufactured biscuits so that
they could feed their armies while
marching okay so you know no way can you
haul all fresh meat for an army of 20
000 soldiers so
so there's a certain healthy diet it's
10x to 20x more expensive
than the cheap diet the cheap diet
though gives you 10x as many people per
square mile and so it turns out that the
society that Embraces Agriculture and
lowers its nutritional standards and and
basically normalizes you eat biscuits
every day
it's the society that can field an army
of twenty thousand or fifty thousand
and whatever the weapon is Spears or
guns are like right that's the army that
wins
right so can you do that your entire
life well I mean we know that at some
point you know 50s 60s 70s who suffer
from metabolic diseases but you can do
it in your teens and 20s
so what's the average age of these
armies right well I think you know the
average age was 20 30. the average you
know the average life expectancy of a
colonist in 1776 like 30 something the
average age of elizabethan's
in their mid-30s right the average age
of a Marine
today
19
the average age of someone on an
aircraft carrier 20 21 I mean these are
all college students so so even though
thousands of years have passed
Wars are fought by the Young
if you had a culture let a low energy
culture
like hunter-gatherers like Native
American Indians low energy culture they
didn't have the wheel
they didn't have the horse they didn't
have factories they had a little bit of
Agriculture probably but but it wasn't
yeah
if you if you look at Roman ruins you
will find that there are Roman Mills
that actually uh were used to grind
grain and bake bread and they would have
a series of 20 water wheels and if you
calculate their harnessing hundreds of
kilowatts of power to turn those wheels
and maybe megawatts of power to turn
those wheels back two thousand years ago
to manufacture bread the Romans raised
the level of Agriculture to a high
standard they were very efficient
whereas you know when you're engaged in
that in a hunter-gatherer type Society
or a native Society whether it's
aboriginals in Australia or the northern
American Indians or or the various
Societies in South America you realize
they just weren't channeling as much
energy right and because they weren't
channeling as much energy
uh they they can't generate the
population density and they're also not
going to be able to create the Munitions
necessary so they get displaced in short
order but then
but then you have to ask the question
yeah and there's the other issue right
the biological issue right clearly
smallpox and germs wiped out 90 or 95
percent of of Native Americans they
never really got him a chance to fight
having said all that even when things
equalize
if you have the same
biological resistance to germs and if
you have the same exact weapons then
there are other concentrators of power
that become very interesting
agriculture is clearly a concentrator of
uh because it it concentrates
nutritional energy and eventually
concentrates Manpower
uh another manufacturing is another
concentrator of power
right if you have all of the uh Iron
Works and all the Munitions factories in
your part of the country during the
Civil War you probably won the war and
if if you don't have the manufacturing
facilities to manufacture the handguns
the rifles the Canon
the ships right you lose control of the
sea you lose control of the land
when we when we advance to you know air
War you lose control of the airspace so
so manufacturing is a really important
another interesting concentrator of
power is banking
you think about it you think okay so why
were the British so influential like how
do I concentrate power and you have done
a very interesting series
of um a podcast on this subject the
concentration of power in the monetary
systems and and banking is an integral
part of the Fiat monetary system it you
know in many cases the Fiat system can't
function without the banks so
when I set up a bank even if I'm A
Primitive Goldsmith and I take whatever
a hundred pounds of gold and I issue 100
pounds of gold notes
well I've concentrated power in in my
facility and in my organization and when
I issue 200 pounds of gold notes and 400
pounds of gold notes or 800 pounds of
gold notes
right we know that the money is
effective you know we know there's a
cantillion effect and and it becomes
less effective you know as it gets
distributed but uh the society that
actually invents fractional Reserve
banking
and is able to print the money has more
paper money gives you power if you never
invented it
right all things equal if you never
invented it and your enemy did invent it
then they can use it to weaken you
um it's funny how it pops up over and
over again for example
before the Revolutionary War there were
there were some very
aggressive uh Governors and they had a
Will To Power you know and so like the
Massachusetts governor wanted to conquer
the French and you know take over the
Saint Lawrence freeway well they want to
launch the campaign
they try two things one thing is they
want is conscript all of the colonists
to go fight the war and Moses didn't
want to be conscripted
right and the SEC and when they couldn't
figure that out they have to pay them
so they actually print up paper money
and they actually issue a lot of paper
money which are debt obligations against
the future tax revenues of the colony of
Massachusetts and they use that to hire
the army they send them off to fight the
war
so it turns out that that the money
printing is another way to concentrate
the power
and of course you know what was the
banking center in that time period
London and so you so you can see
there are at least three ways to
concentrate power
agriculture manufacturing and Banking
and then you get to a fourth way and
this is very interesting again studying
the history of the colonies
um one Colony Virginia wants to declared
war on the French and they want to take
over the Ohio Valley and you know and
they want to take over Fort Duquesne and
and they want to move west so
they first try to conscript their own
citizens and the citizens fight back
you know then they actually raise money
and and they have to fight with their
own assembly and there's a back and
forth over how much money then they go
to the other colonies and they want the
other colonies to actually enlist and
send soldiers and the other colonies you
know New York doesn't want to send
soldiers to fight Virginia's War right
and uh but but what's the point the
point is that New York has an opinion
and Rhode Island has an opinion and
Massachusetts and Pennsylvania have
opinions and they have their own uh
assemblies and so the power is
decentralized
uh in uh in the pre-revolutionary War uh
uh America and the decentralized nature
of all the various governmental entities
meant that I couldn't as governor of
Virginia just to clear war on the French
and go and go conscript 100
000 colonists to go fight that war
I had to negotiate
and uh sometimes the negotiation was
send some soldiers other times the
negotiators would send me some money
sometimes the answer was pound sand
you're not getting anything
and so of course what did the um
what did the authoritarians do well they
lobbied to actually Create A Confederacy
and combine all of the colonies under
one government so that they could uh
they could Channel more power more
energy to a particular centralized
objective generally declaring war on
somebody the French generally sometimes
the Spanish right whoever had the
property that I didn't have right
but but what's fascinating about uh
studying this history and if you're
interested in the history I recommend to
anybody uh read conceived in Liberty by
Murray rothbard very notable Austrian
Economist and he writes a very detailed
history of of the colonies
before the Revolutionary War
from the point of view of
an Austrian economist
and he
he actually
takes you through this step by step and
after you listen to the history
then you realize that that fourth way to
channel power is political and it's by
constructing a centralized political
Authority
you know that political Authority might
be the king
but it but it might be channeled through
agencies
uh it might be through a Confederacy
when there isn't that Central political
Authority you tend to have
um more laws a fair in the absence of uh
of a central Authority
right you will have um
you'll have a healthier economy right
the the society will be economically
healthier and the society generally is
is mentally healthier and physically
healthier right right in times of Peace
people are able to do what they want to
do the trade relationships form such
that you
you allocate production efficiently the
overall economy grows faster and is much
larger in the standard of living is
higher
people's mental health is much better
their physical health is better 20
percent of the able-bodied men in
Massachusetts colony died because of
that Adventure you know North to fight
with the French
in this time period right and uh and so
it's like you're going to get drafted
you're either going to get cajoled into
joining the military or you're going to
get drafted and or you're going to get
in you know
basically conscripted
they're even press gangs you know the
British would come in with a ship in the
port a bunch of British Sailors would go
AWOL and so they would just uh walk on
the docks they would find a bunch of
able-bodied men and they would Shanghai
them you're now a British sailor whether
you like it or not
it's like there's you know it wasn't
even the government it was just the
local what was it you said a long time
ago that you may not be interested in
war but war is interested in you
yeah yeah
the history is just a long story of war
after war after war after war and
there's always someone that comes along
that has a new idea for another War
and and generally the war is is fought
to take to take property that someone
else has that you want
take their land take something generally
take their land
thank you
when you uh when you look at all of
these factors
you know you start to realize that
say no right and or even municipalities
right the more decentralized the Power
uh the more peaceful the society is and
the more productive the society is
because it's always uh it's always
imposing regulations
um and uh
people or you're being killed or or
30 percent of all the able-bodied men
you know in the society are drafted and
now what happens to all the factories
and all the farms and all the families
when
you know the people are drafted and what
happens when half of them don't come
back
and the other half come back you know
mentally tortured from The Experience
they had to go through
can't ignore the machines to channel the
energy because if you ignore it uh then
those machines will be used against you
right right so so the challenges is how
do I find that right balance
yeah that's quite the sweeping view of
history there
now I'd like to tell you about our
sponsor the gold investment letter the
gold investment letter helps
sophisticated investors navigate Capital
markets and maximize their profits in
trading Gold Silver and Mining stocks
the gold investment letter seeks out the
most undervalued companies and
identifies special situations in the
mining sector and then provides in-depth
analysis on both their financial
positions and future prospects
the gold investment letter explores many
complex domains such as investor
psychology portfolio management and
macroeconomic Trends all with the goal
of making you a better investor
the gold investment letter offers a free
version and a paid premium version and I
strongly recommend you at least sign up
for the free version because after
having read a few of these issues I can
promise you it is a treasure Trove of
good information you can sign up for the
free newsletter today at Gold investment
letter.com
sponsor icoin technology icoin has just
released a Sleek new hardware wallet
looks like a mini iPhone a little touch
screen and camera on it the device has
no Wi-fi no Cellular Connection no GPS
it's a strictly physically cold Hardware
wallet like I said it's got a high-res
three inch touchscreen it's got a camera
for air gapping the wallet it's got
optional Bluetooth compatibility and
it's a really a brand new UI ux
experience for Hardware wallet making it
very accessible easy to use not
intimidating
and as we always talk about on this show
the only way you can truly own your
Bitcoin is by having it in self-custody
so you need a device like icoin wallet
to truly own your Bitcoin
go to
icointechnology.com today and use promo
code
bitcoin23 for 30 off of this new Sleek
Hardware wallet
sponsor crowd health
crowdhealth is a Bitcoin enabled
alternative to Legacy Health Insurance
now let's face it Legacy health
insurance is an absolute scam nobody can
explain this better than the legendary
Comedian Chris Rock
I give a company some money in case
happens
now and don't happen should I not
get my money back
so with crowd Health instead of just
paying premiums that you'll never see
again you can hold part of this pool of
savings in dollars and in Bitcoin
through crowd health
and when you have a health event you can
draw against this pool of communal
savings
so go to join crowdhealth.com
Breedlove to learn more or sign up now
I'd like to tell you about our sponsor
Wasabi wallet with Wasabi wallet you can
receive send and store Bitcoin privately
in wasabi wallet your transaction
history and Wallet balance are
completely hidden
Wasabi wallet is easy to use all of its
privacy features are built in by default
and it works with any amount of Bitcoin
Wasabi users can make coin join
transactions together with BTC pay
server users or trezor Suite users
for BTC pay server users they can make
payments directly inside of a coin join
and for trezor Suite users you can make
coin joins directly on a hardware wallet
these features result in the fee savings
and security improvements for both sets
of users
so go to Wasabi wallet.io today to
download the state-of-the-art Bitcoin
privacy wallet I'm struck by you know
you mentioned the concentration of power
through those different mechanisms like
you said agriculture manufacturing
and government and government yeah there
is Lord Acton's Infamous dictum that
power corrupts and absolute power crops
absolutely
so I'm wondering to the extent that that
we can prevent the concentration of
power in those ways which some of those
things we don't want to prevent we don't
want to prevent Manufacturing
we might want to prevent Central Banking
we might want to prevent centralization
overall
but some of these things seem to be
beneficial but we're there's some kind
of balancing act here where we're trying
to harness more power but in a
decentralized way such that it doesn't
breed so much corruption perhaps
yeah it seems like um
the vectors of Vice are concentrated
around Banking and government
manufacturing uh better things for
Better Living
and and creating more food and or just
more of everything people want is
probably neither a bad or a good thing
it's probably on the margin a good thing
creating creating more of everything
that human beings desire especially if
everyone's doing it right it's
decentralized I mean the challenge is
is really on the on the banking and on
the government side I guess on the
banking side if you if you looked at
civilization and said well half of our
problems are all related to money I mean
money is money is economic energy so so
when the banking gets corrupted then
then the energy is and the energy
balance is distorted through money and
that means that
that means that some a politician
a politician uh
that wants to fight a trillion dollar
war that doesn't have a trillion dollars
can now actually create a bank borrow
the trillion dollars from the bank and
fight the war
without anybody paying for the war so so
banking banking and monetary networks
are enabling factors for corruption and
that's half the problem I think but it's
only half the problem the other half the
problem is governance and that's just
having the power to to impose
regulations and when you read if you
read enough history it gets to be
comical but when you see it in
historical context and then you realize
that it's no different today but for
example in in history and the history of
pre of colonial America
there was a monopoly on baking in New
York one family got the Immunology you
could grow grain but you weren't allowed
to bake it it was it was against the law
to bake bread because only one company
in one family could bake bread and they
got the Monopoly on baking bread you had
to buy it from them and of course they
paid a kickback
a fee to the governor and they kept that
Monopoly and of course what happens next
is people say screw that I'm going to
bake my own bread so the government then
has to have Customs inspectors and they
kick your door in to see whether you're
illegally baking something you know and
so I and so I'm the governor I get paid
a small amount of money but I want to
get rich so what do I do I grant you the
Monopoly on baking bread and then the
next thing I do is is I notice maybe
there's a hundred thousand acres over
there that someone might live on but
they're Indians and so I just go ahead
and I and I find the next Rich family
and I give them a land grant of a
hundred thousand of those Acres
you know and and of course they give me
some patronage
and then you've got the Hudson river
right why is New York New York because
New York is at the mouth of the Hudson
River it's one of the of the world's
great natural harbors and the Hudson
river is this highway right into the
into the center of North America
and if you've ever cruised up the Hudson
River it's like a mile wide it's really
deep it's straight as can be uh the only
time it even bends is at West Point
that's why West Point was a fortress and
that's why West Point the academy is
there because that's the one defensible
point up and down the Hudson River but
otherwise it's it's almost like a
perfectly sculpted Highway
if you lived in a world where you had to
haul stuff on a barge and think about
you know hauling a hundred thousand tons
of stuff on your back on your donkey or
your horse versus a barge right you
clearly want to move it via water
okay so what do you do if you're the
governor of New York well there's a tax
on going up and down the Hudson River
okay can you imagine like even today if
you went up and down the Hudson River
and someone stopped you some sorry sir
you have to pay me money
but they did and of course think about
it why wouldn't they it's like we'll put
a fort at one side and you have a ship
and you have stuff in the ship pay us
money to go from New York to Albany
like I mean I yeah I know that God
created the Hudson River but I'm here
now I'm cashing in so there's a so
there's a tariff on that well then of
course there has to be monopolies on
everything else right there was a hat
Act
okay and and pre-revolutionary War
America hat act okay you might ask what
is the haddock well people are making
hats too cheaply
we have to constrain the supply of hats
okay so the rule is you're not allowed
to make a hat unless you've been a
printed a hat making Apprentice for
seven years
and a hat maker can only have two
Apprentice
and of course a negro cannot be a hat
making Apprentice
and then after you've gone through this
arduous and you can't import hats from
the French
or foreigners no Spanish odds no French
shots
um and that way the hats are kind of
expensive and you don't undermine our
market for hats
well eventually you know it turns out
that the free market is very efficient
at doing things for example uh
the colonists could grow hops cheaper in
the new world and ship it all the way
back to Scotland or Ireland
then the British could grow hops in
Britain so of course the answer of the
British merchants was the Hops act we're
going to make it illegal for colonists
to sell hops in Britain because you know
it's going into you know or alcohol
right and we can't have them undermining
the local domestic farmers
okay so of course the price of
everything triples
right every single layer of government
it's it's there's one layer of taxes one
layer of tariffs stuff starts working
and it works too well there were rules
there were laws that prevented colonists
in Maryland from Trading with colonists
in Virginia
because that under they wanted the the
product shipped all the way back to
England
in an English ship they want to put a
tariff on them and then ship them back
and so a lot of the struggles were over
the Navigation Acts and the Navigation
Acts told you you couldn't buy anything
from from the French or the Dutch or the
Spanish you couldn't
ship things between colonies you had to
pay a tariff
Non-Stop
rules creating monopolies
on everything like there were rules on
you know buttons you know who could
actually what kind of buttons you could
put on your jacket There are rules on
who could manufacture what and ship it
and every single colony in a different
set of rules and the rules were all
generally constructed to enrich the
ruler
and the more powerful the rulers got uh
the more onerous the rules got to be and
generally they're just entrenching one
rich family but to the detriment of
everybody else
yeah you you come away concluding to a
certain degree uh
pre-revolutionary War America was
successful despite itself just because
there was so much distance involved and
so much chaos that a lot of the rules
weren't uh enforced effectively
and and why do people go west they just
kept going to get away from the rulers
right you know I was like the colonists
thumbed their nose at the rules coming
out of London and the people that lived
inland thumbed their nose at the rules
coming out of New York or or Boston
and there's continual squirmishing
but you can you can see
The Arc of history is we're arcing from
very decentralized
where rules can't be enforced to like a
weak federal government
After the revolution
to a stronger federal government
right when we get to Andrew Jackson and
he's fighting against the Bank of
America he doesn't want a central bank
in the United States he goes to war with
them but and he wins the war he
eliminates uh the central bank but at
the cost of strengthening the presidency
right so you see the Dilemma which is
the president is virtuous in his
resistance to the banking Branch so he
weakens the bankers and the financiers
strengthens the money but the only way
to weaken the bank is to strengthen the
government right because he used the
power of the government to fight the
bank and So eventually that power of
that presidency
becomes its own Vice its own its own
problem and of course this continued up
and we we have the example of the Civil
War right which is the the federal
government is asserting its power over
states rights and coming out of the
Civil War the state's rights uh states
were much weaker than before the Civil
and you know then you get to the you
know the formation of the Federal
Reserve and the Jekyll Island you know
incidents and
you know if you go and you look income
tax in America it was there was no
income tax right and then all of a
sudden there's a one percent income tax
on the average person and a six percent
Surat tax and then by World War One you
know it's a 75 tax and then in World War
II it's a 95 income tax
you just have you know you have uh a
progression of the increase in banking
the strengthening of banking you have
conscription
for a large part of the century where
people are conscripted in the military
you have
um a weakening of the currency
and you have this progression uh the
strengthening of the executive branch
such that the executive branch starts to
routinely
uh trample over constitutional rights
it's debatable whether the constant
you're ever had your constitutional
rights we can go back and forth over
them right the Constitution isn't is a
piece of paper it's an ideal and it's an
aspiration
you know but when Roosevelt seized your
goal that was not constitutional and if
you were a Japanese-American intern
during World War II doesn't feel very
constitutional to me and when the
government's censoring the Press not
constitutional in the default on silver
certificates not very constitutional and
when you're not allowed to show up at
church you know to worship during covid
doesn't sound very constitutional right
what what is the theme Here
if we bring it back to energy and power
right the theme is a hundred thousand
years ago there's a limited amount of
power Manpower
you know fist swords speards and and the
Arc of human history is we keep finding
ways to generate more energy
to channel more energy with technology
and then the political
organizations keep getting more
effective and they're made more
effective with the Technologies right
railroads and Telegraph and telephones
they all make political organizations
larger they make they make commercial
organizations larger yeah the creation
of the modern federal government of the
United States
is an is a is an organization of
unprecedented power in the history of
the world
so is every other government
so are the banks right we consider the
reach of a modern big four Bank in the
U.S right incredible unprecedented
so are the big tech companies
so are the big Pharma companies
so are the big retail companies so are
the big logistics companies we have we
have much more powerful entities
than we ever had but but you know here's
the issue right which is
one insane person with a bomb
can do a lot more damage than one insane
person with a knife
one insane person with a hundred bombs a
thousand bombs a million bombs could do
more damage so so if we look at the
pyramid the power pyramid
the source of instability in our world a
source of toxicity the source of anxiety
you have an entity that can control an
aspect of the life of a billion people
and at the top of the entity is a board
of directors
it might be the Federal Reserve
committee or the head of the Federal
Reserve it might be uh the Apple
corporation or Google corporation or
Facebook or any Corporation Twitter any
big tech company
there's a handful you know of officers
and directors there's five officers
and oftentimes five directors that have
most of the power
so you're talking about a dozen people
or less
and one person in particular the chief
executive
that has extraordinary power
and if you consider
the power that Genghis Khan had or
Julius Caesar had 2 000 years ago
you know it pales in comparison to the
power that you have it
today if you have the power to devalue
the currency of billions of people by 20
percent
in a matter of months
without any check on that
right you might be draining or diverting
10 trillion dollars worth of economic
and that's one source of power um
yeah yeah and and a big tech company
they have the power to literally
restrict you from using a word right
what in the history of the world
when in the history of the world Could
you actually rip an entire word of the
English language
I can rip hundreds of words out of the
okay you know I can literally suppress
the existence of a piece of information
there are things you can't say there are
things you can't think there are things
you can't convey
and so that's extraordinary power and
unprecedented power
I you know I think
I think if we follow this Arc
what were the wars of the 20th century
they uh there was a while where land
power right when we when we went into
World War one right they thought that
would be determined you know by armies
and there is you know the Magno line and
there's there's all of the the trenches
and tanks and the like
and air power didn't really play into it
that heavily see Power a little bit
right the
the axes tried to choke off uh the UK
and they almost succeeded so see Power a
little bit arm land power a lot and by
the time we got to World War II uh the
axis the focus of the fight had shifted
first to air power and a lot of sea
power a lot of air power it really was a
fight all around the world
um and then by the end of the war it
tipped to a nuclear power
but I mean I guess the war was settled
based upon sea power and air power in
Europe but it was settled you know for
once and for all based on nuclear power
right and
so you're fighting those Wars you're
thinking about sea power about air power
then you know the next 50 years it's a
lot of squirmishing around nuclear power
and how you'll deliver that and Star
Wars was uh you know an anti-ballistic
missile defense system and then you had
nuclear subs and you had nuclear-powered
aircraft carriers and there was a lot of
that
but now we get into 21st century
and it's becoming increasingly clear
that in the 21st century uh the wars
will be determined
by
by drones in the air
drones on the land and drones in the
water
so I take one of those robot dogs and I
put a gun or a bomb on it
and it's it's it's cute when it's it's
Barky it's scary when there's one gun
and it and you see the video where you
see that the that the robot dog can
shoot a target from 100 meters away
and then it's horrifying when you see 10
000 of those robot dogs getting
manufactured in a manufacturing center
and they're spitting out a thousand a
week
and as many as you want right
and then you start thinking about well
what am I gonna do when one of those
robot dogs comes sashaying down the
strip in my restaurant with a gun and a
bomb and you think what am I going to do
in this hundred of them and what I'm
going to do when there's a hundred
thousand of them
and then you start thinking about you
know all the submarines and all the
ships and the whatever but you know why
wouldn't you just create an unmanned
submarine and put a bomb in it either
conventional or nuclear and
you won't just create one why don't you
create a hundred a thousand a hundred
thousand
Torpedoes that you know have a range of
thousands you play this game right you
can just put a 10 000 Torpedoes with a
range of 100 miles on a ship and just
like dump them in international waters
um we now have GPS encircling the Earth
and if you've seen the starlink
satellite system starlink is now
encirculating the Earth you have high
high bandwidth internet and and very
very precise GPS so
those drones can find their way to any
spot you know plus or minus 12 inches
in the water
the robot dogs can find any spot on land
and then of course the air drones you
know it's like you you think about the
F-35 and you think about all these this
this Air Force but that's really the
Armament ammunitions of the 20th century
you know the next War won't be fought
with pilots and it won't be you know why
would you create a 50 million dollar
aircraft that's limited to nine G's with
the pilot that took 25 years to train
and millions of dollars to train
why wouldn't you actually just create a
hundred thousand switchblade drones that
cost a couple thousand dollars each
right manufacture ten thousand of them
you have an army I just spit out 500 of
those or a thousand and and they just
find every truck every Humvee every tank
every tent every cluster of more than 10
people because why would you bother to
attack one person when you could get a
hundred right and it's a swarm yeah
and you just send the entire swarm you
know
I've used the phrase you remember
Bitcoin is a swarm of cyber Hornets
okay the most terrifying thing right is
not one creature attacking you it's not
an army it's not a Navy
it's not an Air Force it's not a fighter
and a jet the most terrifying thing is a
swarm
of
bionic Hornets
it's pretty clear they're coming
and it's not you know what do you do you
just put whatever munition or weapon of
your choice on the thing and what you
need you just need to know where you are
but you know the Silicon for figuring
that out is getting better you know and
you need some intelligence well maybe
you need starlink and right now in
Ukraine there are flying drones and
fighting Wars with Starling but it's
it's pretty clear if you look at chat
GPT and if you look at where we're
headed they're going to download those
AI models into silicon and there'll be a
point at which you'll just burn a custom
Asic
and instead of a custom Asic for Bitcoin
mining which is a cyber defense system
you'll just burn a bunch of custom A6 to
think
and sometime over the next few years
we're crossing the chasm if not already
where
where the brains and the drones
will be smarter than the brains and the
cockpit
it's not that hard to kill something
right that like we're we're you know you
look at Boston Dynamics that have shown
all these videos of um
you know of of robot workers in a
factory and here's a robot that does
backflips and here's a robot that's
going to like pick up packages and store
them and okay now we want a robot to
bake bread and clean our dishes and talk
to us that's hard
okay
but creating a robot that has 10 000
rounds and saying cross that line on the
map and kill everything on the other
side
scary that's not hard
right I'm going to program in 100
components what do you need to do I just
need you to get there and then turn the
on switch
can I ask you something about this so
this vision of human history that you've
laid out
a lot of fighting a lot of Wars a lot of
this pendulum swing to centralization of
political power but then it seems like
technology
comes along and somehow re-decentralizes
us
um you know I guess the United States is
a great experiment in that regard a
constitutional republic so we had more
of a decentralized
governance system
people fighting over property right
people fighting over stuff people
fighting over the power to write the
rules of property or the right to tax
the property or whatever it is people
fighting over wealth I guess you might
sum it up as yeah
is I mean this seems like a very
darwinian picture where it's it's
animals fighting over territory
effectively
is that what you're is that how you see
it that we we've we've kind of created
these systems of property to fight over
territory and and if so if property and
territoriality are related what does
that mean for something like Bitcoin
Bitcoin being this unbreakable or
difficult to break form of property how
does that change this equation in this
game I mean it does seem like if you
read enough history
just me if you read enough history you
just see tens of thousands or hundreds
of thousands of battles and Wars just
fought over property
someone wants to take something from
somebody else and
after they finish taking it
then whoever the ruler is starts starts
redistributing the property amongst
their subjects generally in a corrupt
fashion
and someone's fighting to not not be
abused and it's just a never-ending
struggle of the more powerful dominating
the less powerful
with no end in sight
um the tools change
the the significance of
of the 21st century Warfare is this
right it's it's not going to be about
Manpower right it's you don't need a
million people to fight a war you don't
need any of the conventional systems to
fight a war the wars are going to be
fought with custom silicon
manufactured devices machines
like it's it's not that I just
aren't impressed with you as a soldier
but it's just
it's just like I want you to be a
soldier about as much as I want 300
beefy dudes rowing my tri-ream instead
of having a thousand horsepower as on
the back of my tender right right it's
it's just you have become singularly
unimpressive to me as you know as a
human participant in this battle yeah
we're not gonna We're not gonna fight
that way we're going to actually
manufacture drones machines
Munitions are going to matter engines
are going to matter power sources are
going to matter
and then uh control of the airspace
control of control of space outer space
and control of cyberspace is now going
to matter so all of human conflict all
of the rational human conflict right
intelligent
humans with a Will To Power
will shift their focus
to outer space cyberspace space
and that there will be unintelligent
irrational you know examples of
governments leaders
organizations they will cling to the
20th century they're the ones that CL
that that field that cavalries during
World War One they're the ones that want
to fight with machine guns when the
bombs are falling they're the ones who
built the mag in our line they're the
ones that will want to build a hundred
very expensive ships or build the next
human-powered fighter aircraft right we
need the fighters protect the bombers
and we need the bombers because they fly
slower because we don't want the humans
get hurt and we need you know ejection
apparatus protect the human beings and
we need you know flight training schools
right no you don't need any of that
right it all just goes away
so when when
um Humanity shifts
to this new form of warfare Call It
cybernetic Warfare then there's going to
be a physical question and there's going
to be a cyber question the physical
question is going to be can you
manufacture those devices
like when there's
5 000 drones swarming over Washington DC
do they have the physical apparatus to
stop them shut them down interdict them
or shoot them down right scramble them
and then the second question is going to
be
can you defend uh
after you defend your airspace
can you defend your outer space because
someone's going to start shooting down
the satellites right or or jamming them
right if I'm using satellites for
bandwidth or GPS can I Jam them so so to
the extent that matters then can you
protect that and then the third question
the most important question I believe
and this is where Bitcoin comes in is
can you actually secure your cyber space
who controls cyberspace
can can your enemy dominate it so for
example right now if I ran a
nation-state hostile to the West
I might very well generate millions and
millions tens of millions of
fake
accounts on YouTube Twitter Facebook the
like and I would run them with computer
programs and and now with AI
and I would make them very articulate
charismatic people
and I would use them to distort reality
I would whenever something happens that
causes Americans to want to fight with
each other the credit Civil War
if I wanted uh one half of the Democrats
to hate the Republicans I would actually
launch the bot Army to create that Civil
and I would get state to fight with
State I would get brother to fight with
brother I would get people in the north
to fight with the people in the South I
would get all the races to fight with
each other and I would just launch
non-stop never-ending toxicity
and so much so that people didn't know
the difference between reality and not
because the truth is
there really isn't one reality
there isn't you know the problem with
with the truth and this this will take
us to a subject of stories right
when I tell you the story of the
colonists that showed up in the new
world and I tell it in English from the
point of view of the anguish I discount
the French but I also discount the
American Indians but the American
Indians aren't one Indian
there's thousands of Indian tribes and
sub-tribes and they fought with each
other right and so the Spaniards fought
with with who knows how many tribes in
in South America and the like the
Indians fought with each other the
colonists fought with each other there's
never ending set of fights and there's
always a story of well a bunch of these
people came and murdered us and so we
went to war to protect our rights but
they always leave out the part where
while someone from our village went and
murdered them first
or they came and they attacked us
because we had actually you know seized
and enslaved you know half of their
Village and shipped them off to the West
Indies they leave out that part right
and so
when you start reading the history
like Murray rothbard's his book is like
250 chapters
it just goes on and on and on
and it's and none of it was taught to
you when you were in high school none of
it when you start reading the history
what you find is there are thousands and
thousands and thousands and thousands of
chapters of History it's all true you
know and or whatever you call truth
let's just say for the benefit let's
give everybody a benefit of a doubt it's
all true you want to hear the story of
of how you know
whites enslaved Africans
in uh pre-revolutionary War America
there's ten thousand stories of them but
you can also hear ten thousand stories
of whites being enslaved in Africa on
the Barbary Coast but you can also hear
the story of ten thousand you know
Bostonian Puritans being enslaved by
British
on ships
and dying right
um hundreds of thousands of chapters of
horrific truth
I can get you to believe and I can get
you to feel anything simply by
filtering out
ten thousand chapters of horrific Truth
where you're the good guy and they're
the bad guys
whatever it is
just a question of how do I weight it
yeah so
the issue with um with cyberspace is I
can I can create any perception if I
control cyberspace
and I can block any other perception
and I can amplify a third
right so I can introduce a thought into
your head I can amplify a thought that's
there and make it 100 x is painful
I can um
you know a reality that you're aware of
such that you act irrationally I can do
all of those things if I can control the
information systems
when you when you uh
think about the wars of the 21st century
and beyond
um you're going to have to dominate
cyberspace or protect your cyberspace
and you know in one way
you know something as simple as on
Twitter what if I just eliminated all of
the bots on Twitter you know in my
experience 95 percent of the toxicity is
generated by non-people
has traditionally been on Twitter and
when they eliminated the Bots 95 percent
of the uncivil toxic behavior that made
everybody enraged just went away it was
never any it was never people
90 you know you hated people that
disagreed with you but 95 percent of
that hate was actually fueled by Bots
not by those people so
so uh partly you get rid of that and you
start to cure the mental health of the
civilization but uh there's another part
to this which is if I want to pass a
then you have to figure out how are you
going to avoid a denial of service
attack how do you avoid someone flooding
or jamming the Cyber frequencies in
order to prevent you from controlling
whatever your army of robots
right what happens when someone decides
to hack the controller right the real
risk is someone if you have concentrated
if you've concentrated uh the power of
10 000 robot dogs
well who's controlling the 10 000 robots
three admins
one admin
okay what happens if I hack the admin
and I get root privileges and now I
control the ten thousand robot dogs
right maybe they're not attacking the
enemy maybe they're attacking the
Creator or maybe the enemy is is the one
that hacked your army this is um
you know a fiction sometimes uh imitates
reality or vice versa but you know if
you watch Battlestar Galactica that's
how the entire Series starts
right human beings come up with a a
defense system
and then uh the cylons hack it and they
just turn it off and then they turn it
against the humans right and so you have
to actually ask the question how am I
going to secure my cyberspace
and I
I think that that um one answer an
important answer is uh proof of work
right and and uh the Cyber defense
system which is Bitcoin if you think of
Bitcoin is just money you're thinking
too small
I yes it's money and it's truthful money
but the reason Bitcoin is the hardest
money in the history of the world is
because it has integrity
not because it's a a computer system
that uses energy
um it's it's a it's a system that was
engineered
um to have integrity and to be
thermodynamically sound uh to actually
manifest scarcity and that Integrity can
be used for the root application of
money and banking if you will especially
money
and money and monetary transfer but
there's a lot of other things you can do
with it
um and and the other things have to do
with integrity and veracity and we call
it the truth machine not just a money
machine
so uh for example
uh on Twitter an AI
could generate 10 million uh fake
Michael Saylor accounts
could generate a million an hour
or if and and maybe I could try to block
them all as fast as I could but actually
there are legitimate other people named
Michael Saylor
you know the people named Michael Saylor
I'm just one of the Michael Sailors
you could generate a hundred million
other accounts that aren't with my name
but just are interesting people
now
should they get to participate in
society
how do you stop that
well I mean there's there's two things
you want to do one you know the Noster
idea is uh I use uh I publish my public
key and I have a private key and I use
my private key to sign my message
sort of good
but it doesn't solve the problem because
the AI can still generate a hundred
million Noster people right
right because it's not and and here you
see the the issue is non-conservative
non-conservation of energy
I can generate a million accounts a
billion accounts a trillion accounts I'm
just running the computer and if
anything what the ai's done is the AI
has shown that it can actually do what
anything you can do it can do better and
it can do a million times faster
so no amount of information can serve as
proof of humanity the AIS read
everything that's been written by every
human that's ever written it and what
and that means the AI can give you a
hundred thousand Page biography of why
it's more trustworthy than you Robert
you can fill out a 20-page form
it can fill out a 20 Page form every 10
milliseconds
you're not winning right you're not
going to win this battle so
how are you going to actually
defeat that or even put a check on it
and the simple answer is I don't just
generate the public private key
combination I generated in conjunction
with the Bitcoin transaction on the base
layer
which might cost a dollar which might
cost fifteen dollars right
this weekend sometimes people are paying
thirty dollars some amount of money it
doesn't really matter whether it's a
dollar or a hundred dollars right what
matters is I paid money
and it took time in that particular case
you could create a cyber passport I'm
going to call it an orange check
a digital identity your digital identity
is cryptographically secured
the digital identity of Robert Breedlove
might be secured by a single private key
with the public key that's made it to it
the digital identity of microstrategy
might be secured by three of five
multi-sig
and the digital identity of you know a
city might be secured by the city
council which is a you know five of
seven or seven of you know fill in the
blank right four of seven right don't
hold me to all the different multi-sig
configurations but you can go with
multi-signature to sign a message from
an organization or maybe a family you
have three of five that secures your
family
and identifies it so now I am
I create this identity
I burn it into the Bitcoin blockchain
now I digitally sign my accounts
like right now you can get a message
from Michael Saylor on what's up
but it's not me and there's no method
for me to verify
there there is a method by the way for
you to verify on Twitter
you know it cost eight dollars a month
for a blue check it cost a thousand
dollars a month for a gold check it
costs a thousand dollars a month plus
fifty dollars a month for every officer
of the corporation verified with the
gold check not cheap
not cheap but also
um not open and not portable
so regardless of what do you think
that's a great idea
the problem is I can't take the gold
check and use it on YouTube and use it
on Instagram and use it on WhatsApp and
Telegram and office 365.
there are um there's a a cryptographic
certification in um in EX in Office 365
and the Microsoft email system gives you
a blue check if you have the certificate
on your Hardware devices
but it doesn't cross the other email
platforms
and so and sometimes it actually is
blocked by other email platforms so what
you have today is you have a bunch of
proprietary
certifications that are unwieldy
expensive non-egalitarian and they're
not open they're not programmable
they're not verifiable
you have a bunch of cyber systems that
are either in not secure they're fragile
or or they're toxic some of them are
just outright toxic you can point to
them and say there's garbage on them
others are are centrally managed and
they're fragile because you know maybe
the big tech company is it does a good
job of squeezing people they think are
scammers off their platform but they
also squeeze people that just have a
different opinion from the power
structure or the executive team and they
don't distinguish between those two so
they're very they're very fragile in
that regard and when they squeeze you
off their platform you lose your
identity forever in that space
you can imagine if you use an iPhone and
Apple just exes your account
on the day you wake up and you find out
that your account has been deleted right
it's it's a problematic thing you have
there's no court order
there's no due process
right and in that regard
the big Tech networks are more powerful
than nation states
to society
so I I think
um I think in this world the real
question is
if you run a family a corporation if
you're an individual or if you're a
governmental entity
how do you prove the veracity of your uh
your utterance right how do you sign
your message how do you assign your
contracts
how do you assign your accounts
and how do you verify when there's a
hundred million other accounts which
claim to be you that are actually look
more like you than you look like you the
AI version of you
like on a if you go on vacation for two
weeks and the AI just it just learns on
all of your former videos the AI will
look at all your former videos look at
the news of today generate the podcast
and it'll look like what Robert
Breedlove would have done
but Robert breedlove's not there to
contest it
and and and so
you know if it's used for good
I don't know maybe but it was used for
mischief
a bit more disturbing but what if it's
used for malice
and and the only answer is you need
somehow to cryptographically be able to
secure something but there needs to be
some thermodynamic security to it
such that you know
if I can guess your password a million
times in a row and you've got one of
those four digit pens right then I'll
crack it
you need to actually say well you only
get three guesses right
it's friction in the real world right
you can't move a billion trillion miles
an hour in the real world because you
will burn up right not to mention the
fact it violates all sorts of laws of
physics there needs to be a real world
sound barrier or light barrier else
the universe doesn't work
and um the same is true in cyberspace
there have to be physical cost enclosed
you know in in imposed in cyberspace
against malefactors
the greatest system
for doing that is Bitcoin Bitcoin can be
described in this regard as uh the most
powerful Cyber Network it is a digital
power Network and a Bitcoin miner is a
digital Power Center
and the unit of measure the greatest
unit of measure of digital power in the
history of the world is the exahash
right now one extra hash it'll cost you
30 megawatts of analog power in the form
of electricity
modulated through
10 000 s19
mining rigs right that are custom
silicon and if you can if you can put
those two things together you can
generate digital power and if you've got
digital power
you can
Shield something you can hide behind it
that is a wall of encrypted energy
350 exahash high so the question is what
will you put behind it
like the the obvious thing to put behind
it is your identity
the other another thing is a
tamper-proof document or or a hash
I create a lot I create a will
and it's going to convey a billion
dollars in 25 years
the current way you do it is you
inscribe it on 30 sheets of paper two
people sign in ink one notary shows up
and they look at two forms of government
ID they stamp a little stamp on the
thing
and then some clerk that works for a
lawyer puts it into a vault if you're
lucky a filing cabinet if you're less
lucky
they might scan it
if the scan ever gets released if the
PDF file is is ever cracked or hacked
um you know anybody with an iPhone can
counterfeit your entire will change any
word they want
like it it takes like a 200 ink printer
you know and uh and an iPhone and you
could counterfeit or tamper with that
document if you're smart enough to
destroy the original then no one will
know the difference right
it's amazing so anti-counterfeit
technology not just for money but also
for importantly for anything but but
like you know we think about the any
things right in that particular case you
might very well burn the document you
know as a transaction and if you didn't
want to burn the entire document you
might burn the hash
maybe you know you hash the document and
you burn the hash and digitally sign the
hash so that 25 years from now when the
when someone says this is the document
you hash it and you can see that it was
tampered with doesn't you know doesn't
match so
so any kind of contract any kind of
title any kind of deed maybe especially
if it needs to be a mutable tamper-proof
but the place where it gets interesting
is cyber security systems
like how many how many people have
control of the Enterprise domain of
Omega Corporation
you know if I wanted to actually
um infiltrate A bank's computer network
or big tech computer network
right I
I joke I say like I think I know how the
world will end you'll you'll wake up one
morning and you'll get a notification
from Apple or Google saying there's a
routine security update
download now or it'll already be
downloaded for you
you know some AI will get control of
that routine security update inject the
Trojan Horse and 30 days later
everybody's iPhone screen simultaneously
blanks
or if you want to make it melodramatic
or or
you just hijack 100
000 iPhones of the hundred thousand most
powerful people in the world you just
start to like redirect transactions or
messages
maybe they don't even know
and so the question really is
so who's securing the security update
right right
and and what does it take
and a lot of times corporate security is
well this person or these three people
of super user privileges but you know
you almost can't afford for any any
person of super user you have to have
all sorts of checks and balances and and
you have to have some combination of
multi-signature multi-factor
but then again if the multi-signature
multi-factor is based upon one
proprietary corporate system then isn't
that the weak link right so what you
want is a multi-sat multi-signature
multi-factor system that's open and
transparent and what is the greatest of
those systems in the world
Bitcoin of course right the Bitcoin has
figured out how to do multi-six right
they figured it out and what is a
yeah so signing devices and and
multi-sig on an open network that's
transparent
with world-class cryptography right
that's the solution to trust and
integrity and so the killer apps you
know are control of your cyber systems
and control of cyberspace
to keep people from hacking the system
whether it's the banking system or the
it's at some point right if I hack the
Air Force system can't I make every
drone fall out of the sky if not now
eventually because we're getting to a
point where the humans in the middle are
the weak link if there's ten thousand
humans and they think at human speed and
I can replace them with a computer that
thinks a million times faster than the
human I I can't afford to put people in
the cockpits I can't afford to put
people in the Humvee or in the tank or
in the ship anymore it's too expensive
too slow too fragile and so when I
replace it the issue is how are you
going to secure the thing you replace it
with and how do you decentralize that
and if there's an example of a system
where everybody thought about
decentralization obsessively for the
past
40 years
right Bitcoin right the culmination of
40 Years of thinking about cryptography
and decentralization and you know and
power and energy
and Bitcoin today in its current
manifestation it's the greatest example
of a of a stable
Cyber Network that's defended by digital
it's the greatest example and the
greatest success
but we're only reaching we're now
reaching a point where
where the future of humanity
the future of how we fight our Wars the
future of how we think the future of how
we Bank the future of how we communicate
the future of of how we contract and how
we trade all of those things are going
to be determined in cyberspace
For Better or For Worse
and and most corporations nation states
they're either defenseless
or they're very fragile and and they
have these fragile untested structures
that have never been attacked or if we
want to take a slightly more pessimistic
view you could say Western Civilization
has been getting torn apart because all
of its cyber systems are toxic and
fragile and dysfunctional right now
and there are probably a hundred of 100
examples you know over the past four
years to eight years where you've seen a
breakdown of many of these uh
conventional
cyber systems
because they don't have
um they don't have
um economically sound ethically sound
cryptographically sound cyber security
built into them
they you know for the longest time it
was too easy I think Twitter had 500 000
fake accounts A Day created
it's 500 000 attacks a day right there
hundreds of thousands of attacks a day
on innocent people and they're working
right they work in YouTube the scammers
work there's not a week that goes by I
don't get a message from someone saying
I was contacted by you with the trading
opportunity or a Bitcoin offer or
whatever right if you look at every
messaging system all the email systems
all the all the shared bulletin board
systems all the social network systems
they are currently corrupt and toxic and
they struggle with this problem and the
solution
the solution to the problem
is in of itself a problem remember I
told you the Andrew Jackson story he
defeated the bank by empowering the
presidency and the result of that was
the Civil War among other things
you know millions and millions of people
are going to die because of because of
the empowered executive branch in order
to defeat an empowered Financial Branch
um well when when a big tech company
implements censorship to block the
scammers
they also Implement and they Implement
censorship to block the nation states
that are so-called hostile they end up
implementing censorship to block the
domestic actors and the truth as well or
or anybody and as you can see right the
definition of the truth is hard to put
your finger on
it turns out that that there are 10 000
versions of the American
experience that are all truthful and if
you tell it from the point of view of
one Indian tribe another Indian tribe
the Hispanics the African-Americans the
French the span you know the ethnic
Spaniards the Brits it's a different
truth right and
you know you they could all be right and
at the same time you come to a totally
different conclusion depending upon
which uh which narrative stream you
choose to lock onto now I'd like to tell
you about our sponsor Bitcoin conference
2023
this three-day event will be held May
18th through 20th in Miami Beach uh this
is going to be the biggest event of the
year as it always is in the past two
years Miami have simply been amazing day
one's industry day days two and three
are going to be open to general
admission and I'd say this is a great
place to go and network with bitcoiners
or even look for a job just a really
all-around great experience
is a fantastic speaker lineup including
Michael Saylor Zoltan pozar Lynn Alden
Alex gladstein many others and last year
we did a 10 million SATs giveaway for
this event and we're going to do it
again this year
so to get discounted tickets and enter
for a chance to win 10 million SATs go
to B dot TC slash conference and use
code Breedlove now I'd like to tell you
about our sponsor casa Casa makes it
simple to buy and secure your Bitcoin
without wondering whether you're doing
it right
specifically Casa provides a multi-key
custody solution which is by far the
most secure way to custody your Bitcoin
now when I talk about Bitcoin being
theft proof money or inviable private
property a multi-key custody model is
exactly what I am talking about
using multiple Keys lets you maintain
full control of your Bitcoin while also
giving you redundancy in case you lose
one of the keys it's also the best way
to secure your Bitcoin for inheritance
planning purposes
keys.kasa that's c-a-s-a today to sign
up and use discount code read love
can I ask you do you because this is a
we've taken the thesis or the value
proposition of Bitcoin and expanded it
out Beyond money is this something you
see nation states or militaries adopting
by necessity then Bitcoin to control
root access to this futuristic
warfighting equipment
I do actually I think the Smart Ones
will figure it out sooner
you know I mean Jason Lowry is you know
I spent a lot of time working on this
and and and working to communicate this
message uh in a number of different ways
and it's a challenging message to
deliver but
you know just like
this nation rejected uh air power
like we rejected air power and and we
thought it wasn't a military
significance and he quotes a general
from World War one that said the
airplane is an interesting toy but it
has nothing to do with war fighting and
obviously by World War II as you said
air power was What mattered so you will
find examples of uh of a
a military complex that will reject the
new thing while they cling to the last
but then the war comes along
like like drones where I'm from the Air
Force I'm a commissioned officer in the
Air Force right uh and um I remember you
know being in the Air Force learning to
fly in the air force if someone said oh
Pilots are all obsolete you know we're
going to replace everybody with drones
that's you know anathema
you know you don't like that right you
know you will fight that if if the if
the Air Force is run by pilots right you
drag your heels
but then you know and so for a while the
I think the Drone mission was absorbed
by the CIA and I don't know where it is
today I'm not up to speed on on the the
modern uh Mission responsibilities and
the and the dod but
but you can see that when someone else
starting starts shooting missiles out of
the sky via a drone to fulfill the
mission and they get 100 Missions and
they knock them all down and you're
still waiting for the one mission that
you fly with humans
you know like the Top Gun 2 mission yeah
you know like the entire movies about
you know it's a mission that humans need
to fly but you know you listen to the
movie and you and if you think about it
from a technologist's point of view the
movie's not good because in the first 60
seconds you say oh yeah we should have
sent a drone
right but but if we just send a drone
the mission is a success and the movie
only lasts about 60 seconds and there's
there's no human beings there's no
Jennifer Connelly hooking up with Tom
Cruise you know and there's no heroic
moment and you know and there's no
tear-jerking you know situation and you
don't need the aircraft carrier and you
don't need the you don't need the Naval
Base you don't need the pilots you don't
need Top Gun you don't need the planes
you don't need the rescue you don't need
the heroics you don't need the cue the
good music at the end you don't need the
motorcycle and the guy riding into you
know into the sunset you know with the
beautiful girl
everything doesn't end happily ever
after
they just send one inanimate robot drone
it shoots one missile drops one bomb end
of story
human organizations they don't like that
story right and and that's the same that
human Bankers don't want to deal with
the thought that maybe the bank is
obsolete and you go to a conference of
financial advisors and there's 27 000
financial advisors okay an entire
industry of ten thousand companies and
you stand up and you go well you know um
it looks like
97 of all your money managers got beat
by the index
and over a long in a period of time 99
so if we simply obliterate the entire
banking industry and all the financial
advisors and all the money markets and
all the mutual funds and all the ETFs
and and you just bought Bitcoin dca'd
you beat them all and you do it with
.01 of the cost
you know no one's all done enthusiastic
about that future it takes a long time
for you to deconstruct that so I think
with regard to
um these military systems and these
defense systems it takes a while to for
the uh military-industrial complex to
modernize itself and what you'll
probably find is you'll see some leaders
in some parts of the world the ones that
have everything to gain nothing to lose
right who fights the Cyber war first
right right like who's busy in
cyberspace you hear about the North
Koreans busy in cyberspace if I don't
have the Brute Force right I use
asymmetric Warfare so you'll find the
smaller nation states that have the most
to gain the least to lose they'll use
asymmetric Warfare
and then over time there'll be a big war
and someone will lose a lot and then
they'll realize that you know the
machine guns don't work anymore and the
barbed wire doesn't work anymore and the
open cockpit doesn't work anymore you
know in these conventional bombs they
don't work quite so well we need laser
guided bombs right and there's there's
this acceleration
I think that um you'll also see
you'll see adoption accelerated by
commercial applications for example a
very simple commercial application is
just the orange check right like do you
want to pay you know uh fifteen thousand
dollars a year to be authenticated just
on Twitter but on no other platform for
your corporation
like or would you rather pay twenty
dollars once in your life
or ten dollars I mean probably if you
put in a Bitcoin orange check
transaction and you're willing to wait a
week I mean can't you like bid you know
one tenth 120th 10 satoshi's of ebite
there was a while when you could bid one
Satoshi do it for a quarter or something
right but you know you probably would do
that and then you would have it on the
open system and then you could take it
and carry it across every other platform
but there I mean there was an idea
called a pretty good privacy pgp
and it was like cryptography for
everybody
it's like you can have your own public
private key and you can encrypt anything
you want so
I I think that um we're going to come
back to that that kind of idea which is
sailor's gonna burn his orange check
into the Bitcoin blockchain uh you know
and I'm gonna publish that maybe to my
Twitter and maybe to a few other things
but I'm also going to use it to
digitally sign some documents and and uh
and hash them you know and and uh seal
them if you will
as that happens it'll spread across all
the social media platforms and all the
corporate platforms and the reason it'll
happen
is because of this onslaught of AI Bots
such that
just not nobody once people start to do
it it should spread virally because why
would you trust
anyone that's not orange check verified
right you know you know what happens if
I could do it you know I would say if
you ever get a message from me that's
not orange checked it's not me right and
as it starts to spread because it's open
permissionless and ethical
you know everybody can adopt it the
problem with closed protocols right
whether it's deck net or token ring or
something like that is the proprietary
and all of the verification protocols in
the world today are proprietary Apple's
blue check doesn't carry through to
Google's blue check right if you want an
example the most extreme example you
can't even you know use an Android phone
authenticated against an iPhone right so
there's a problem
it's a problem for everybody
commercially and this is a solution it's
going to be a problem for every
corporation right corporations have to
deal with this issue of cyber hacking
and denial of service attacks and how do
they secure their relationships with
their customers their Partners their
employees
ultimately is you got the same
multi-factor multi-signature situation
and then next we'll go to Municipal
entities and political entities like how
does the police chief
okay sure the police Chiefs got a gray
check or a black check account on
Twitter well what about every other
Communication channel and you remember
what happened the Uproar when Elon you
know took away a lot of those checks
it's just chaos
you know like there ought to be an open
standard for authentication and digital
seals uh for any kind of official
communication I think military military
will come in time and they will come uh
to this realization when they realize
this thing
which is remember how I said it takes uh
30 megawatts of electricity to generate
an AXA hash
and it takes 10 to 15 gigawatts of
electricity uh to generate 350 extra
hash well you know that Dam might give
you 10 gigawatts of power but the
problem is the dam on itself doesn't
work you also have to put it together
with millions and millions of mining
Rigs and that will take you years and
years and years of manufacturing
so you want to attack this system if you
want to stop the message from being
processed
that I'm passing from me to you
you know and any encrypted message I
want to send you a message I put it on
the blockchain well you're going to have
to come up with not 350 extra hash
you're going to come have to come up
with
3500 extra hash and if you have 3 500
extra hash now you've got 90 the 51
attack doesn't mean anything 51 attack
just means that the message takes 20
minutes instead of 10 minutes maybe
right what you know when you actually
put 3 500x a hash out there you've got
to come up with you know 150 gigawatts
of power and now you need a hundred
million of those mining rigs
and the world can't manufacture that
they're all bought right okay okay
that's kind of like saying I need to buy
the next 20 years of production of all
the aircraft in the world
well you know good luck with that how
are you going to do that without anybody
knowing that you did that right and you
kind of have to do it immediately
without people knowing
Bitcoin represents the most secure
system
systems that are based upon
human intellect
right can be cracked by the AIS
the AIS will crack all of the things
that are based upon proof of humanity
because they're more Human Than You Are
in order to actually secure the system
it's got to be defended by raw power by
energy they can't take energy and and
you could think of a Bitcoin miner like
if you use the offensive term you know
you could say it's a machine gun in
cyberspace but I know that that triggers
all of the Maxis right and all the
Libertarians who don't like the idea
it's an offensive weapon so a better a
better articulation of it is it's a
it's it's the cybernetic fence
you know it's the wall in cyberspace
that you can hide behind or you can
stand behind right it's a cyber Dome
right it's not a system to inflict
uh inflict destruction
and and
and death and Mayhem on your enemy it's
a system to defend your own cyberspace
perfectly preserve information in a
force field or something like that that
can't be Rewritten I want if if I have a
hundred million identities and I want to
protect the identities if I have a
hundred million documents and I want to
protect the documents if I have 100
million systems and I want to protect
access to the systems
it's a cyber defense system once upon a
time there there's an Iron Dome the idea
is it's it's a missile defense system it
shoots things down that are coming at
it's you know anti-aircraft system
yeah so if you think of Bitcoin as a
cyber defense system that's really
critical because you recall
you know in our previous series we
talked about what made America great
you know and superhero Theory right you
know and I said superhero theory is you
want to be indestructible Invincible
right if you're Invincible you can
figure out the rest of the stuff you
don't have to be the fastest the most
beautiful you don't need the the
electric lightning bolt shooting out of
your fingertips you don't need all the
cool magic you just need to be
Invincible because you're Invincible you
can just you know strap an atomic bomb
on your waist walk into the building you
know leisurely have a cup of coffee and
set off the bomb and then walk out of
the
city right you're going to win and every
other idea everybody has is not going to
work so invincibility is the ultimate
superpower you know if you combine it
immortality right the big eyes
invincible
indestructible Immortal right right
that's the thing everything else you can
learn or you can strap on right
and Bitcoin represents invincible
immortal
and in America
America's big Advantage was hiding
behind three thousand miles of the
Atlantic Ocean and hiding behind six
thousand miles the Pacific Ocean with a
tundra to the north
and with a desert to the South
and that meant that you could have an
army of of 250 000 men you know fully
armed in France
you're not going to be able to deliver
more than five percent of that Force to
the U.S it's going to take you three
months and then they're probably going
to starve to death you know as they try
to live off the land and a third of them
are going to die of disease and so the
ability for you to punch is you know
you're ameliorated your force is
attenuated by a factor of 50. when
you're trying to work from that distance
right the the deciding battles on the
American frontier were fought by 2500
or 10 800 you know thousands tens of
thousands right and so America always
had the luxury in World War One World
War II Etc of being able to manufacture
infinite munition Shuffle everything
around and ship it somewhere else and
then drop the bombs on somebody else
yeah and in Poland they never had that
luxury you know in Russia they didn't
have that luxury and uh it's it's a
pretty big deal
that distance and the same holds through
in cyberspace if you are going to fight
a cyber War the first thing that has to
happen is all your iPhones can't go
blank on the first day of the war
you know and all your systems can't stop
working but there's something worse than
all your systems stop working
it's all your systems start working
against you that's autoimmune disease
right it's like when your body attacks
and we've seen that you know you know
you see it physically and you see it
politically you know if someone manages
to plant a mole in the middle of your
system and they just simply turn all the
weapons on their own population
so so that's cyber defense mechanism has
to be based on on some cryptographically
secure
digital Energy System
and if I look at all the systems right
the only one that's that's truly you
know acknowledged to be successful and
secure is Bitcoin nobody prefers the
second best in security I can't so
that's why there's no second about I
would like to name the second best but I
cannot I can name those second best
right like 350
if you're going to compare cyber
security systems you have to ask the
question how much energy will it take to
break it
okay well I mean if you take all the big
tech companies and all the big Banks I
actually think simply compromising
anywhere from one to ten people breaks
it
Pro you know if I flip half of the board
of directors or two or three of the
officers I broke it right right and at
some point you can always Trace these
things down to all I got to do is
compromise or spoof or fish
some number of dozen two dozen people
and you know if you have those two dozen
people you want to keep their identities
quite private
there's a lot of ways to get to them
right you can blackmail them you can
issue a court order you can put them in
jail it's like you could say well I'm
you know I'm not going to be coerced
well if you're in jail and the
government orders you you will be
coerced because the argument is well the
person that you're supposed to you know
the thing you're supposed to do is in
the interest of the state but the
problem is every single country has
their own State and they think the other
states and their so right so everybody's
being coerced by everybody all the time
right and that's just if they do it you
know legally they can also do it
politically but they can also do it in a
criminal fashion
right so that and you can just do it in
a corrupted fashion or you can just be
incompetent a lot of ways to compromise
those systems so
you don't really want a cyber system
that's based upon uh human uh virtue
right you have to assume
yeah you have to assume that at some
point the human and the loop will fail
and if and if you dismiss all those
ideas just imagine what you know how old
people in your family react when they
get a call a video call from you and
you're a voice that looks like you that
just you know urgently needs something
because your iPhone was stolen right or
maybe it's from your iPhone
what are they going to do if it's you
calling from your iPhone on a video call
to make a request you don't think that
they're going to actually believe you
right right I you know I I think it
ought to be disturbing uh so
now we come to the issue of
um a true digital power Network
Bitcoin secured by digital power it's
energy over time
x a hash is that measure of power it is
a hash rate right a hash rate and the
only way to generate the hash is analog
converted to electricity
combined with uh Computing capability
computing power right in the form of how
fast can you generate a Shaw 256 hash
right right those two things that
creates digital power if you take the A6
away it's not digital power it's power
it's analog power but analog power as we
pointed out isn't that impressive right
I mean would you rather have the power
of a rifle or the power of the dam well
you know if the rifle is pointed at your
chest the dam doesn't do you any good
right right it all comes down to a
specific ability to generate a specific
type of power you could have control of
every hydroelectric facility in the
world if you can't digitize the energy
it's not going to defend your cyber
system so so Bitcoin is digital power
it's 350X a hash
that that equates approximately to 20
billion dollars worth of computer
equipment that has been purchased that's
running on the network something like 10
to 20 probably 20 billion of capital
investment uh on the compute side
and then you can value the energy you
know at various levels right if it's if
it's five cents a kilowatt hour you're
getting to five six five six billion
dollars a year at 10 cents a kilowatt
hour you're getting to 10 billion
dollars a year of electricity
that's what it takes to run the network
but that's not what it takes to attack
the network
right if if if I'm a nation state and I
wanted to block every message or
intercept every message on the network
for the next six hours
I need to win the next 60 blocks
and if I'm going to win the next 60
blocks statistically that means I need
98 percent
of the hash rate and that means I need
to bring online 50x to 100x right
if I want 99 I need to bring on 3
500 x a hash of computer power
completely impossible
problem with that is if I hijacked all
of the Google Amazon and Microsoft
computer power I could maybe bring on
five exahash
because of the Silicon ratchet because
that Asic is 2 000 times more efficient
than commodity compute so commodity
compute power is at the bottom of an
energy well it's like I built a wall
That's 2 000 feet high
and your node you uh rented from Amazon
is one foot a one foot step
you need to now get 2000 x higher than
that you see yeah and so
and so just like the logic of creating a
literal wall
I'm creating a wall of encrypted energy
and you're not going to be able to use
three things that every nation state has
nation states have commodity money
they can print 100 billion dollars of
money some of them not all of them some
of them they have commodity electricity
one third of the electricity is wasted
or energy is wasted right they could
divert that entire Dam which is two 20
gigawatts or divert gigawatts they've
got commodity electricity and commodity
energy and they've got commodity compute
all the iPhones in the world all of the
AWS nodes and the more commodity compute
but a truly secure system isn't based on
commodity money
that's why proof of stake doesn't work
Robert
because I can buy 20 billion dollars of
your token
by printing commodity money and so if
you're secured by 10 billion dollars of
your token and it trades I can come up
with another 10 billion 100 billion of
commodity money especially I can print
it for a few hours or a day yeah right
this is the space and time security
layer you talked about our prior
episodes right so commodity money can't
be used to attack a proof of work
Network like Bitcoin but it can be used
to attack a proof of stake Network it
can also be used to attack a centralized
Network any kind of proprietary Network
you just you just coerce bribe you know
incentivize the result you want
commodity energy can't be used to attack
the network either because it has to be
modulated through the the Asic miners
so you would need
two thousand times as much energy
that's all the energy on Earth doesn't
work you need three Earths if you had
enough compute power and you don't but
if you did if you if you could if you
had infinite money to uh to rent
infinite AWS CPU nodes then you need
three and a half Earths
but you're not getting that and of
course finally commodity compute power
there's not enough of it
just don't have enough of it on Earth
you take it all it's not enough
so the only way to attack the network is
to actually play the same game over long
periods of time you have to actually
create Bitcoin Asics that are
progressively more efficient which is to
cooperate that's an arms race yeah and
it's an arms race that takes you a
decade it's like we're in it if you want
to spend a decade and billions and
billions of dollars in order to try to
enter you can
um you won't sneak in it won't be cheap
it won't be stealthy
right it's uh and and there's no cheat
code you can't repurpose anything else
it's just like when I you know when I
have a nuclear weapon you can't
repurpose a yacht
or a bow and arrow or a machine gun to
pretend it's a nuclear weapon right
there's only one way to play the game
you know you have to commit to that and
delivering that and uh and you either do
or you don't and we'll probably know
because it's hard to keep that secret
yeah and even getting into the game
you're incentivized to play by the rules
of the game right it's actually in your
best interest to mine the Bitcoin rather
than try to attack the network I'm I'm
struck here by this no private actor can
afford to subsidize it so anybody any
private or corporate actor has to mine
Bitcoin and support the network
if you're a hostile nation state and you
wanted to attack Bitcoin I guess in
theory you could print tens of billions
of dollars in order to develop minors in
order to create mining centers to attack
Bitcoin but we would be basically
debating that on Twitter for four to
eight years and then at some point
someone might decide to adopt a shop 512
protocol brick all of the Asics and
migrate right yeah but you have many
many years to figure that out it's like
the enemy will be at the gates for a
decade and sometime between year two and
year eight we will have decided what to
do but of course what governments
do you know that would want to spend a
decade you know failing to attack
something it's much more likely that
you'll just flip everybody in that
government to support Bitcoin by the
time they finish that right right right
right right right and they'll just
come on board right because the truth is
every if you're
take your the United States the United
States had what four billion dollars of
Bitcoin like how much Bitcoin that had
50 000 no people say they've got more
Bitcoin than microstrategy so let's so
let's say that that the United States
has 10 billion dollars of Bitcoin
they could sell it
for 10 billion dollars
any intelligent bureaucrat if they just
wanted to make another 20 billion
dollars risk-free
for the United States of America all
they have to do
is draft a one paragraph press release
saying we have it and we've decided
we're going to keep it we're going to
hold
you would have to do
and you would go from having 10 billion
dollars of Bitcoin to having 30 billion
dollars of Bitcoin right just one
paragraph press release and you make 20
billion dollars risk-free
and any any bureaucrat that thought well
I just like to have a hundred billion
dollars
you know for the taxpayers
they would simply buy another few
billion dollars
then they put out that two paragraph
press release we're keeping what we have
and from time to time we're going to buy
more like last week
and then you would have a hundred
billion
Okay so
just make a list of every country on
Earth and then you ask yourself the
question how many of them would rather
have a hundred billion dollars risk-free
then spend
20 bought spend a hundred billion over
the next 10 years attacking Bitcoin to
destroy it
well yeah
you're down to a very short list right
and so yeah Bitcoin is just the most
well thought through cyber security
and I think it's worthwhile dwelling on
this issue of power and energy and
security because of course all physical
energy all physical security has to come
from uh military power you know has to
come from Power if you don't have power
right you're the 998th Indian tribe that
got you know pushed off their land and
people don't even write books about you
lamenting how you were mistreated
right they only write the books about
the top 300 Indian tribes that were
mistreated when you get far enough down
in the totem pole right there's 10 000
tribes that got squeezed out of Europe
by Romans and the Gauls and fill in the
blank over the past 20 000 years and we
don't lament them we only lament the
famous ones so if you don't have a lot
of power right there's no hope for you
as we go forward
you can see
our war shift from Land power to Sea
power to air power to space power to
cyber power
if you hope to have economic health
Mental Health
physical health
political health
you're gonna have to control your
cyberspace
and it doesn't matter whether you're
Robert Breedlove simply controlling the
cyberspace your identity online
I launched ten thousand fake Robert
breedloves I can destroy you if you
can't stop it
right they're scammers you have to
control your space a family has to
control their space Twitter has to
control its cyberspace lest you know a
billion toxic Bots corrupt everything
and um so does every company so does
every bank so does every government
so does every politician
so I think we're we're early
we're early and in the first 14 years
people started to recognize Bitcoin as a
great monetary Network and the greatest
hardest money Humanity ever created but
the only reason we could create the hard
is because of the Integrity of the
network they solved the problem of
digital integrity
how do you create a truth machine first
they had to solve the double spend
problem they had to solve the problem
how do I know it's it's truthful and
then they had to solve the Integrity
problem how do I keep
the money on the network for a hundred
years
and since they solved the problem of
Truth and integrity
the killer app they put on is money
and now we're entering a new era and
money will always be half
it'll be half right but the other half
you know is is how do you defend
your reputation how do you defend your
commercial interest how do you defend
your political interest
how do you offend your how do you defend
your corporation your nation your family
whatever it might be and um and that is
a problem that Bitcoin is
um extremely well suited
to serve
and and as we saw last week you know
it's an entire you know
big uh brouhaha over inscriptions and
ordinals and all these things right
brc20 tokens it's like
it's just one of hundreds and hundreds
of applications or it's gonna it's a set
of applications that come before
hundreds of applications that maybe will
come before thousands of applications
and many will fail I mean there'll be a
lot you know like do I endorse you know
Bitcoin for speculating and unregistered
Securities no
can someone do it yes right you know
like
do I endorse you know digital art I'm
not going to give you a recommendation
on digital I wouldn't give you a
recommendation to buy a Picasso right
now I like Picasso if you said should I
buy Picasso and you know as a store of
value well it depends on the price like
you know that's a totally different
thing so there are a lot of things that
people do I wouldn't endorse but
do I like the idea of art yeah
do I like the idea of digital signatures
um do I am I um
am I uh optimistic about the potential
for uh sealing and authenticating and
verifying systems and documents and
transactions other than Bitcoin on the
Bitcoin blockchain yes I am
because the status quo
in in the current systems is just so
awful
and I'm reminded
I'm reminded
for thousands of years people have
struggled with the issue of how do I
authenticate and brand something right
and the example I used is go to the
JPMorgan library in Manhattan and go
visit it and you'll see he's got a 2500
year old
Ivory seal collection and in their works
of Arts they're they're small roller
seals they're carved out of Ivory and
there's a there's an image and relief on
them it might be Antelope it might be a
hunting scene it might be some other
scene and they were set they were on a
roller and their use was people had
ledgers
and they had ledgers of money and
official communication
and to make it immutable
they cooked the they baked the clay
and then to seal it to auth to
authenticate it to show its official
they rolled the roller over the clay and
then they baked it and so you could look
at the scene at the bottom and that's
the public key right which you can
decrypt with your eyes
that's your I've seen that brand before
it's a brand it's a key
it's hard to create
because you need this cylindrical roller
and it's hard to create the private key
the roller is the private key and it's
very very difficult and there's only one
of them the public key is easy to
authenticate this is like public key
private key cryptography it was it was
used you know by the Assyrians it was
used by the Greeks it was used by the
Romans they they date to 500 BC and
Beyond the Egyptians had them right so
we're not the first people to figure out
public private key cryptography we're
not the person to realize that it's
important to authenticate an official
document
you know we're not the first uh
immutable Ledger
we're the best
right you know at some point though you
wanted a mutable Ledger it's like either
it's parchment and wax seals or it's
clay tablets and a clay seal and and
that was the basis of Commerce and Trust
in politics in the ancient world
today in some ways we've gone backwards
right just like a digital way like when
I signed that contract I just do the
scribble and it's an awful signature
it's not a good I don't even do this
right I don't even do an impress imprint
or a stamp
so in some ways you've gone backwards
and and I I think that the world needs
to fix that
especially if you want to live in a high
velocity world I I still
you know I shudder to say this on the
podcast but I will in the interest of
public good
I still have certain Bankers that call
me to authenticate
wire transfers of large sums of money
and they say I got I gotta start with a
security question what's your date of
birth
and you know you can Google Michael
Saylor and you don't even have to click
to get my date of birth
it serves up my data that would only be
on like a billion documents that's you
know that's the the the security seal
question right no you know in their
defense there's a lot of other layers
right right like my phone my voice and a
lot of other questions they might ask me
that I won't mention on this call for
other reasons but
but uh if if there's a message here the
message is the world needs digital
signatures the world needs modern
cryptography the world needs
multi-signature authentication the world
needs multi-factor authentication where
the factors are physical tokens and
physical instruments the world needs an
open protocol and the world needs
something verifiable maybe maybe
verifiably indestructible and immutable
for the next hundred or thousands of
and there's only one thing in the world
that looks like that
and that's Bitcoin and there is no
second best thing
beautifully said I
just one last thought here I want to be
respectful of your time but we're
expanding the scope of the Bitcoin
thesis from just a monetary property
protocol
to something more like an authentication
certification protocol
and as you said earlier the problem was
getting the human out of the loop on
that right that was kind of the single
point of failure so in many ways what
are you describing is something like an
alternative to what government has
provided us historically because they've
been the property protocol provider the
monetary protocol provider they certify
legal documents they authenticate
identity
and now you're saying there's this
alternative system that can serve up a
lot of those services that we
traditionally needed from the
dematerialization of notary networks the
dematerialization of of Licensing
networks of of titling networks of
passport Networks
of all of all commercial verification
Networks
right all of those things right Bitcoin
becomes becomes the foundation of
cyberspace it becomes it becomes
um the ultimate
digital network if you need it if you
need a network that will defend the
integrity
of Commerce on the internet
and and serve as as a worldwide truth
powered by digital power right the most
powerful Cyber Network in the world
the most powerful will be the most
reliable
the most truthful the most resilient the
most indestructible the most immortal
and it's just getting more powerful
and if you want to build something you
know with integrity
in cyberspace you're going to want to
build on that Foundation everything else
is fragile
and corruptable
and so I think the early bitcoiners they
grasp that as the foundation for sound
but you know if you fix the money in the
world you didn't fix the world
as long as there's one person that can
can script 10 million people or launch
an army of 10 million robots you know on
someone else they disagree with you
still have problems in the world so half
of the problems in the world may be
fixed with sound financial Foundation
but the other half of the problems in
the world have to be fixed with uh with
a mechanism to deliver truth and
uh into the political sphere and the
commercial sphere
coins are dressing both yeah Bitcoin is
the solution to both that's incredible
Michael
I've kept you way too long
it's been a good talk it's been a great
talk interesting thank you so much for
doing this
do you want to let people know where
they can find you on the internet in
case they need to look up your birthday
for anything
sure oh Google knows my birthday
I feel feel free to send me something in
Orange on my birthday if you like orange
is the color
and uh if you want to follow me on
Twitter uh at sailor s-a-y-l-o-r
and um if you're interested in Bitcoin
hope.com h-o-p-e Bitcoin is Hope just
remember that I post a lot of stuff on
hope.com
and uh if you're interested in free
education uh the Sailor Academy offers
free education we've offered it to
millions of students and it's at
sailor.org
saylor.org it's all free worldwide lots
of good Bitcoin courses lots of good
Computing courses you can learn computer
science or physics or whatever you like
lots of we've got some courses on
monetary history
we've got courses by safety Dean on on
Austrian economics
we even got courses on uh how to develop
on bitcoin or just how to develop with
other computer languages so so those are
the three most useful resources and I
guess I should thank everybody for uh
sitting with the two of us this
afternoon through a romp through energy
and power and the future always a
fascinating Journey with you thank you
for everything that you do
thanks Mike
hmm