The Virtues of Strong Money | The Saylor Series | Episode 7 (WiM007)
WiM Media · 2020-12-30 · 1h 31m · View on YouTube →
they're dominating because they're able
to
deliver Force
faster harder stronger smarter
so if we ask the question what is money
money is the highest form of energy that
human beings can Channel
[Music]
Bitcoin is channeling human Ingenuity
into making it better
and and every commodity is channeling
human energy into making it worse the
low brow or the the
historic colloquial term is total right
hold on for dear life and just total or
save whatever and the highbrow term
would be adopt as a treasury Reserve
essay
[Music]
hey guys so as you've learned uh by
watching the what is money show Bitcoin
is the single most important asset you
can own the world today
and so this begs the question which I'm
often asked how does one build their
Bitcoin position
and the strategy really is simple I
suggest first you decide on an initial
portfolio percentage allocation and a
Target portfolio percentage allocation
go ahead and establish the initial
position with a one-time buy and then
start dollar cost averaging towards your
target portfolio percentage and you can
also complement this by buying bitcoin
price tips to further increase that
position and reduce your cost basis and
finally I suggest to everyone to take
custody of their Bitcoin to move all of
their Bitcoin into self-sovereign
custody because again Bitcoin left on
Exchange is not Bitcoin it's a Bitcoin
IOU
and for those of you living in the U.S
there's no better choice than Swan
Bitcoin to do all of the above so Swan
lets you set up automatic recurring buys
for Bitcoin also lets you facilitate
one-time buys for buying price dips and
finally they let you do set up automatic
recurring withdrawals into Cold Storage
which is a really big deal
and all of this they provide at the
lowest fees in the business uh
approximately 0.99 per year for weekly
buys of 50 or more which is about 60 I'm
sorry 70 to 80 percent less than
coinbase by comparison
and the best part Swan is a Bitcoin
focused Education First company uh they
they publish great content on their Swan
signal live podcast uh they publish a
lot of content in their newsletter and
website and their their team is just the
absolute dream team of Bitcoin uh I
would say check out their roster it's
growing every day but but it's a super
impressive group of individuals
and so with that I would highly
recommend you check out swanbitcoin.com
backslash Breedlove you get ten dollars
and free Bitcoin for signing up
um and it lets you stack SATs with
myself and the rest of uh the swan team
as we continue the fight to restore
Freedom truth and virtue in the world
through Bitcoin all right thanks
all right guys we are back with sailor
series episode seven and today we're
going to be diving even deeper into
Bitcoin Theory and as always if you guys
haven't seen episodes one through six
that led us to this point I highly
suggest you go and check those out
um they they build a lot of foundation
that we draw upon continually as we
progress further into the series
So today we're going to discuss Bitcoin
as a monetary missile which if you
remember from episode one uh missiles
were one of the the quintessential Stone
Age Technologies so we're going to draw
analogies to that
we're also going to talk about Bitcoin
as the creature that never sleeps uh
akin to the great Kraken itself
um and why this makes it a superior form
of money uh we'll also look at the
effects of humans intervening in complex
systems and what that does
um two complex systems and the
consequences that it generates
and then finally we'll look at the some
of the reasons why Bitcoin may actually
be the sole sound store value for the
21st century uh we'll compare it to
Alternatives and draw
um reasons why it is superior across a
number of dimensions then we're going to
get into the the televian concept of via
negativa and how it relates to Bitcoin
in technology more generally finally
we get into a really interesting aspect
of Bitcoin
um not often discussed and that is the
we we look at the fanaticism of Bitcoin
maximalists as an asset as a a value
creator for this asset class itself
um and that leads us naturally into the
discussion of Bitcoin as a religion so
I'm going to go deep again today and
really excited for this one so let's
Dive In Bitcoin is a monetary technology
that we're able to deliver with much
more Force
force and the physics definition being
mass times acceleration or mass also
being equal to energy so we're able to
channel this energy in a very targeted
and specified format at a very high
speed and recalibrate almost
instantaneously to always optimize our
yield right wasn't it doesn't it sound
like a cruise missile yeah
or projectile weapon
right
and we're back we're back to the issue
of what happened to the guys without the
guns
when the guys with the gun showed up
right into the guys without the
airplanes when the guys with the
airplanes showed up
sir you're holding The High Ground the
proverbial High Ground behind the wall
of encrypted energy but you can also
send these Financial or uh I guess call
them Financial weapons in a way
out in a very targeted fashion based on
what the Market's signaling right what's
the demand for for loans or what have
you
um
yeah
yeah in theory right isn't a crypto Bank
the smartest fastest strongest Financial
entity in the world
right
right because it's going to be working
while everybody's sleeping
just like
just like YouTube and Facebook and apple
networks they're working while you're
sleeping 24 7 365.
and to a certain extent you see that
metaphorically if you just look at uh
you know a crypto exchange and you look
at the trading of Bitcoin and it's
working while you're sleeping if you try
to watch it you get exhausted
right all all traditional assets are
constructed to trade from 9 30 in the in
the morning till four in the evening
because human beings needed to watch
over them and that's about the maximum
you know endurance of a human being and
uh Bitcoin you know when you go when you
go beyond that right you're going from
like 35 hours a week
to 168 hours a week it's five times as
much people think oh it's a little bit
more it's not a little bit more
right it's it's 5x the bandwidth just
the trading and then when you consider
that it's trading
it's trading every hour in every
currency pair everywhere yeah everywhere
on on a host of exchanges this is um
extremely high bandwidth
price Discovery transparency
right the highest bandwidth price
Discovery the highest bandwidth Market
of any security
of any asset ever right I mean I mean
Bitcoin really is the perfected asset or
at least the Apex asset in uh the
financial jungle because it's the
creature that never sleeps
that's an octopus that's working
everywhere all the time I mean that the
you know the metaphor of Kraken it's a
pretty good metaphor yeah really because
it's always going and it's never
stopping
and remember
back to our previous discussion I was
saying in Jurassic Park you know and the
guy picks a fight with the little
dinosaur and then he realized there's a
hundred of those little dinosaurs
and they don't sleep
and when you pick a fight with the Swarm
and the Swarm doesn't sleep and you
sleep you realize you're gonna lose
you're you're doomed
there's that point when you realize
you're doomed because
you can't keep up with a software
creature with a million heads that is
continuously working everywhere all the
time and here's the thing you know the
thing that's working that's dominating
the market in Bitcoin all the time
it's the strongest version of the
creature in that domain not the weakest
right right
the weak parts of the herd get called
out they're being deprived of their
Capital they're being squeezed out you
know and you see it with like the mount
gox disaster you know anything that
doesn't quite work and so this asset
class is a living asset class and its
strength comes from the fact that
that uh it's being developed
it's not um it's not constrained by uh
the lowest common denominator it's
strengthened by the highest common
denominator right if there's somebody in
the world if there's if there's an
exchange in the world that can actually
do this better faster stronger and it
comes on to the Bitcoin Network
they will set the price right right and
even if you're just huddling if you're
just sitting there holding an asset
let's say I'm holding a hundred million
dollars in Bitcoin and I'm wishing it
would go up in value and then let's say
there's a million gazillion laws in the
United States that prevent people from
Trading index Futures on bitcoin
but somebody in Malta is able to do it
or somebody in Singapore is able to
launch that exchange so Singapore
launches an exchange that matches
billions of dollars of forward index
buyers or option buyers to billions of
dollars of call buyers and that attracts
tens of billions of dollars of capital
in the market because it solves the
yield curve problem let's say
hypothetically somebody on a centralized
or decentralized exchange or lightning
that resolves a yoker problem if I could
give you eight percent risk free
yield on 10-year money presumably you
can take 100 billion dollars and you can
take that money and you can short
Fiat
short the dollar go along the Bitcoin
squeeze the eight percent yield on 100
billion dollars make yourself eight
billion dollars a year
if you can figure out how to do that in
Singapore
you set up in Singapore you do it in
Singapore what happens to the price of
Bitcoin
goes up
what happened to the hodler sitting in
Schenectady New York that never did
anything that didn't touch it that
doesn't know about it that doesn't
understand it with their little one
Bitcoin has been strengthened
the network is getting stronger based on
the highest common denominator anybody
in the world that with a better idea
that plugs in the network is lifting
everybody
and that's totally different
than a conventional centralized
traditional structure where one
regulator might create one set of rules
that can strain and hobble
yeah right thank you buddy the asymmetry
has been inverted right from the Great
Wall of China or if there's one failure
at any point the whole thing's
compromised but now it's you inverted
that asymmetry such that if there's one
benefit it benefits everyone
and that's what it's like when you got a
swarm if if the herd is attacked by a
predator and one of the creatures
figures out how to kill the predator
couldn't figure it out die the ones that
do figure out live they procreate pretty
soon they can all kill the Predator
right they all have got immunity
right that's herd immunity whatever that
might be
and um and that's the beauty of Bitcoin
you know I I had this uh I had this
tweet because you know I put it out
there I said
you know Lions get tired of
using the antelope
Lions complain to the ranger the ranger
hobbles the antelope
Lions get fat dumb and happy Antelope
all die
Lions all die
range of blames on the weather
right
and that is a metaphor for a lot of
stuff
but generally it's it's a metaphor for
how you uh how you destroy a crypto
Network
by trying to make transaction fees lower
it's like someone complained about
transaction fees so we try to change
everything to drive the transaction fees
down because somehow it's abomination in
the eyes of God that people get charged
for transactions
the antelope ran too fast not fairs
brought them down the transaction fees
were too high not fair make them lower
we'll hobble them for you okay it's also
a metaphor for interest rates
interest rates are too high I can't
afford a loan make them go down
it's also a metaphor for competition my
competitor goes too fast they're making
it too difficult slow them down make the
foreigners stop that make somebody do
something right it's it's somebody
trying to regulate or manage something
because they think it's a problem
but at the end of the day
you're messing with Mother Nature right
you're in a war with nature it's not
going to end well at the end of the day
Lazy Lion should die
and slow Antelope get eaten
and fast strong healthy Antelope
procreate and fast strong healthy Lions
feed and the Lions get better and the
antelope get better and they live in an
ecosystem and if you remove the predator
you know all sorts of crazy bad things
happen you know these are off the
balance
this goes
all the way back to your original point
that there's no fair fight in the world
right and that when human intervention
tries to make that fight more fair
the intervention into a complex system
throws off all these unintended
consequences and I think that is one of
the things that's gotten us into the
situation we're in today with low and
negative interest rates right we've
constantly trying to introduce an
economic analgesic to paper over the
business cycle or paper over losses
um and we're just we've distorted the
natural price Discovery function of the
market and so now we're in this we're in
these totally asinine times with uh you
know stock market at all-time high and
40 million people unemployed so I think
the and this is one of taleb's main
themes is human beings have to strive to
not intervene with Mother Nature like if
Mother Nature has been doing executing a
certain strategy for a long time we have
to assume that it's being done for a
reason no matter what science tells us
you know it interest rate is the time
value of money but if but if interest
rate is the time value of money it's the
time value of energy
and if it's the time value of energy
interest rate
is the value of time and and maybe if we
come back to thermodynamics the rule of
thermodynamics is time cannot go
backwards
entropy is it time must move forward
try to drive interest rates to zero or
negative is a war on time
you're trying to make time go backwards
you're trying to make water flow uphill
you're trying to reverse gravity you're
trying to reverse the laws of
thermodynamics
it's it's me saying to you Robert you
know will you give me everything that
you own
give it to me
you go without I'm going to keep it
and when you die
I'm going to give a third of it back to
your heirs
right and and so
the only way you would do that is if you
thought the future of your life had
negative value
right like if you knew you were going to
be a Serial Ax Murderer killer and you
knew it in advance and you thought you
know I should be deprived of the future
of my life because I'm really a
liability to
Humanity Maybe
but if you actually thought that the
future had any value
you couldn't make that trade right no
rational person would say I'm going to
give you everything I have in return for
half of it back when I'm dead right it's
so moronic right it's just insane and so
when I'm trying to drive the interest
rate
to zero or negative
I'm actually trying to reverse time and
make it run backwards I'm first trying
to stop it and I'm trying to make it run
backwards I'm trying to reverse entropy
I'm trying to put the genie back in the
bottle
thermodynamics the laws of physics the
laws of humanity they all say it can't
be done
right and and only something you know
catastrophic will ensue let me ask you
so this is interesting we have a legacy
Financial system that's trying to grind
against or move countervailing to the
laws of thermodynamics or the
thermodynamic Arrow of time and here we
have this new system introduced in the
form of Bitcoin that more that nearly
perfectly mirrors the laws of
thermodynamics it aligns itself with the
arrow of time and the thermodynamic
Arrow of time
it seems almost serendipitous that
Bitcoin is released at this time when
the system is starting to come apart in
this decade do you think this is almost
like an autoimmune response by the the
global human hive mind
[Music]
because
you know look at what Satoshi put in the
Genesis block
right
you know it's pretty clear
that Satoshi was uh was troubled
right was was inspired
at you know antagonized irritated
enough right to do this humans solve
problems right and and so if I if I
introduce a pathogen into you your body
right your body reacts living creatures
react to protect themselves
so if someone is sensitive
sensitive to a given issue and Satoshi
was sensitive to financial integrity
right and obviously he had some decent
sensitivity and awareness of Austrian
economics and and The Perils of
inflation and and the
um moral hazard of Bank bailout so that
was a sensitive
individual that tapped into a bunch of
other sensitive nodes individuals who
shared that
and it's almost like uh I picked I I
pricked you with a needle and I
introduced this little pathogen and then
you swallow that and there was some
inflammation and the inflammation you
know grew and festered and some
antibodies built an organism built and
the organism got bigger and it got
bigger and it got bigger and then it got
fed if
if we had zero inflation of if the U.S
dollar monetary Supply in expanded by
zero percent for the past decade
how much passion would there be in the
Bitcoin Community compared to the amount
of passion there is today
be much less
so so it's a we're back to this issue
but it's a great technology
and um
yeah it's inevitable what you know we're
back to this issue of of Zoom was
inevitable
you know uh
YouTube was inevitable
virtual uh virtual business models were
Bitcoin was inevitable but it sure did
get accelerated by certain things that
happened Bitcoin had 10 years of um of I
would say a seven percent forcing
function with the dollar and it got
Goose a bit harder in with Argentina and
and other developing world countries
you know the anxiety of Syria and the
anxiety of Iraq and the anxiety in
Africa and the anxiety in South America
and the like so those stressors and the
issues that that boosted and the
currency Wars pushed a bit harder
and then I think the pandemic crisis let
it on fire I could say Robert like
there's no way I'm talking to you if
there's no pandemic that's right like
like uh so but I I don't
I don't think for a second that Bitcoin
wouldn't be successful without me and
and I don't think that it's anybody
going to stop it but I do think there's
an avalanche of of uh energy
of individuals and corporations that got
inspired and and driven you know uh into
this ecosystem because of the pandemic
doctor you know again back to war wars
caused Paradigm shifts
and this year
there's a currency War
and and that's a war on money as a store
of value right and and that war on money
as a store of value creates massive
dislocations in the bond market and the
equity market and there are consequences
to everything
and uh and ultimately Bitcoin is a
platform
an anti-fragile fragile but scalable
serving as a store of value
and so the best possible circumstance
would be if the entire world plunged
into a war where a value is dissipating
in every currency everywhere at a rapid
rate
and I think that describes what we have
today I think it's exactly correct and
it's almost as if the Mongols breached
the Great Wall of China right the
Mongols being
um central banks that are basically
robbing value from currency and it's
it's giving people more of an impetus to
evaluate Alternatives and to for those
that see it to retreat behind the wall
of encrypted energy right you have to
defend your life force your energy your
money
um from confiscation and the most
prevalent form of confiscation in the
world today is inflation
but I guess that's what makes it takes
us our next subject which is Bitcoin is
a store of value
right Bitcoin Bitcoin is is an
incredible store of value I think that's
it's primary use case so it's it's it's
it's killer killer value proposition now
and probably for the next decade and and
maybe forever but but
the entire world's looking for a store
of value right now and
you have to look across 250 trillion
dollars in assets so if if we think that
asset inflation is running north of 10
and I think it is I think it's pretty
pretty clear it is
and if you have capital
you have to choose between bonds you
know 80
trillion dollars in sovereign debt or
corporate debt or Municipal debt
or if or or mortgage-backed Securities
or you got to choose equities Tech
Equity conventional Equity or you got to
go to precious metals or you go to real
property real estate property and
when you look at all those things the
problem is half of all real estate is
impaired because of the because of the
political response to covid
uh and uh it's not likely that's going
to change in the next 10 years we've
probably got
10 years of of uh uncertainty about real
estate assets especially commercial real
estate assets
the other challenge is with real estate
is
the taxes on it it's it's liquid
immobile
and highly taxed generally real estate
is taxed annually
everywhere right it's just a question of
whether it's 20 basis points or 200
basis points right so that that makes
real estate a challenging store of value
and that takes you to bonds
and bonds bonds have worked as a store
of value when interest rates keep going
lower you can see that everybody's been
on the bond train and benefiting from it
they're screaming as loud as they can
they want negative interest rates
because they're like I just that the
secret to success is lower the interest
rates 50 basis points a year or 100
basis points a year and it's a no lose
proposition for them
but at this point it's getting kind of
ridiculous silly because when interest
rates go negative already money
everybody takes their money out of the
bank it creates Bank runs all the bank
systems break it's it's
kind of a morally bankrupt
I mean a lot of people
they don't really understand that uh
that they're being abused at two percent
instead of five percent
but pretty much everybody can figure out
that when you're being billed one
percent of the money you have abused
yeah and again if you look at money as
that insurance policy on uncertainty all
of a sudden that policy has negative
value like it does it's it's just
asinine it doesn't make any economic
sense
yeah so
that doesn't work and so what does that
take us uh it takes us to equity
we got an equity bubble it's a very
crowded trade but the real issue with
Equity is a store of value is that is
that uh the revenues get taxed the sales
tax the cash flows get taxed as income
tax
the expenses uh the co the cost
structure gets taxed as employee and
payroll tax
then then the trade gets taxed as a
tariff
then you have the existential threat or
regulatory risk of onerous regulations
you pick up the paper and see maybe
Australia is going to build Google every
time they link to a newspaper article
or and then if Google doesn't link the
newspaper articles they're going to get
fined for not linking the newspaper
articles and you know you as these
things become more powerful they become
regulated utilities and and politicians
start to think that they can and should
be regulated and you know maybe with
good cause if if there's only one
provider of information anywhere in the
country then it definitely becomes
political issue so
that's a challenge with equities
eventually
they might work for two three four years
but but they're valued as a multiple
cash flows
so if all of the liquidity in the
civilization gets squeezed out of debt
right when interest gets to zero the
government the government and the FED
owns all the debt okay they bought me
out
now I got to put it in something else so
I jump on Equity so now equity's double
but now the pdes double or triple and
the revenue multiples triple
if uh what's the value of an equity the
value of equity should in theory be you
know the tangible assets on the balance
sheet plus the sum of the discounted
cash flows
and so you people are using equities as
store of value today
right in fact you can make the argument
that equities are the most popular store
of value for for the majority you know
with the Robin Hood trading they're all
buying Apple Amazon Facebook NASDAQ
spiders everybody even though
even though nobody thinks revenues are
going up this year nobody thinks
earnings are going up this year but
Equity value is a double this year right
yeah well that means that they're
getting riskier
so if you contrast Bitcoin to equity the
problem is
if if the price of an equity goes up by
a factor of 10 you've got more risk
because it's delaminating from its
underlying cash flows and its
fundamentals because it it is a
centralized regulated entity and the
only way that the cash flows are going
to grow uh into that value is they keep
raising the price and if they're
Monopoly and they raise the price The
Regulators will react if they don't
raise the price they can't grow into the
multiple
and uh and so you're kind of a chicken
in the egg thing right at the price and
if there's any competition and their
cash flows deteriorate eventually you're
trading at 200
to you know to one or or 200 P to E
H and uh and then any degree of
disappointment causes massive volatility
right
um they don't
uh how are they different than Bitcoin
well bitcoin's value proposition is the
liquidity it is the store of value that
is it it's if you're going to function
as money you want to be a single-celled
organism this simple like the algae of
the Eagles the base layer of the
ecosystem is plankton or or bacteria or
single cells you don't want to be a
vertebrate
and and these companies are vertebrates
where the brain and a backbone and that
means for example
WeChat or or Tick Tock it has a
headquarters and if it's in the wrong
country it gets its head chopped off
right you know and you know apple and
Facebook they're subject to a certain
Court a certain country's jurisdiction
so that means they're foreign or
somewhere else they're vertebrates if
you're a vertebrate
I can kill you with a needle right like
a human being I can figure out how to
kill right there's a heart I take a
needle I poke there you're gone and very
fragile hard to do that with a swarm of
hornets
hard to do that with all the plankton in
the ocean
it's very difficult to deal with it with
a an amorphous decentralized
invertebrate of some sort so if you want
to store a value
you don't want a company that's valued
based upon the ability to engineer hyper
complicated products that have to keep
getting upgraded you want something
which is simple
they can just keep being simple what
that this is again where some of the
crypto enthusiasts they keep wanting to
Tinker with a you know a better
blockchain a better crypto a better they
you know they never saw an upgrade they
didn't like so they just want to keep
revving it every year this is like it's
the iPhone version 37. right there's a
fundamental difference which is if
there's a bug an iPhone version 37
everybody in the world's heart doesn't
stop right I think this this analogy
you're using with with the Simplicity of
plankton
right being the base layer for the
ecosystem is apt
because and I
um I want to say Plankton makes up the
majority of the biomass on the planet by
like a pretty substantial margin because
it's so simple and it's so efficient at
converting solar energy into bio
biological energy right and then it feed
it is the base layer for this
multiplicity of layered ecosystem that
we have in the world and another thing I
think is interesting is you make a great
point that equities are becoming more
risky as the increase in price because
they're they're delaminating from their
valuation fundamentals as you said and
bitcoin's the opposite right actually
the more valuable Bitcoin is the more
secure its Network the greater the
liquidity
um the more resistant it is to attack so
it's it's a very interesting counter
trade to to equities as a store of value
and of course if you have an individual
entity with an individual headquarters
and a CEO as it gets bigger it becomes a
bigger Target mm-hmm
but maybe maybe everybody in your home
country loves you but what about
everybody in every other country right
does you know so
you don't want to head
and you don't want to be a Target
and you don't want to be valued based on
cash flows if you're going to be money
like what it's they're the right but
they're the right creature to be uh
building a device or maybe creating an
exchange or creating an application
because there
I want um I want the software to run a
billion times faster and so it's okay to
have one company write software
right the question is I wanted to run a
billion times faster but do I need it to
last for a thousand years
and the answer is I can throw my phone
away and Western Civilization will not
end if I lose my phone or if you screw
up my phone right it will not end if I
put all the energy in western
civilization or that's prejudicial if I
put all the energy into civilization
or of civilization into a network a
crypto Network
I can't afford for someone to like ship
a buggy release
so so and again what people forget is
if I put a billion dollars in the
Bitcoin
on January 1st 2021 and I don't touch it
for a hundred years
the thing is working
it's you know truly insanely great
technology
is um is uh
okay we're back to Nicholas taleb is
haunting our thoughts via negativa right
ah yes God by taking away
insanely great technology is when it
does a thing without you doing a thing
right but you know a junior technologist
they create gadgets I have um an app I
have a mobile application
it has 150 features and 150 buttons and
if you click and there's a billion
different things it can do depending
upon the combination of the buttons and
the features you click on okay that's
one thing how about another mobile app
you download the mobile app and
everywhere you walk on earth it kills
all your enemies and and gives you
infinite food and water and protection
and plays whatever music you wanted to
hear around you without you touching it
hands-free
right
you know if I walk around and someone
walks behind me and they do everything I
want you know before I ask them to do it
without me opening my mouth isn't that a
heck of a lot better
than a gadgety thing with features yeah
it's higher utility right yeah I think
it's saying exubery the Design's not
done it's not a perfect design until
there's nothing left to remove and so if
I told you
take all your money put into Bitcoin
and then you'll be rich and happy and
prosperous for all of eternity without
doing a single transaction
that's a lot better idea right that's a
great point I think you need more
features and more gadgety things I just
need it to always work right right right
and just one of these is vapor around me
you're right absolutely I just to give
the listeners uh a little bit of context
on Via negativa for those who haven't uh
read to lab
is canonical examples in his book The
Black Swan where you can see as many
white swans as you want
but you can never prove by virtue of
that evidence that all swans are white
but with a single sighting of a Black
Swan you have disproven that all swans
are white so the the moral of the the
story is that disconfirmation is more
rigorous than confirmation
right and I think that's getting to your
point here is that
[Music]
it's
getting stronger by taking away right
your your factual base on what you're
building your premise and strategy in
the world is strengthened by by
disconfirmation more so than it is
confirmation
all right and I'll give you another
example that
we see all the time with Google you go
into Google uh you you ask the wrong
question
and misspell it and it gives you the
right answer
that's that's a truly Great Piece of
software you asked the wrong question
and it gives you the right answer
because it knows what question you
should ask it knows how you should have
spelled it and it said we're going to
answer this question for you instead
because the odds that you really wanted
to know you know uh this question
answered is 99 million to one the odds
that you really were asking a unique
question that seems foolish and
misspelling a popular name while you're
asking that's one in a billion so if you
really wanted to ask the wrong question
the wrong way you tried twice
but 99.999 of the time
they give you the right answer to the
wrong question
and uh and
they do it because they build like this
uh very false tolerant Common Sense
rational interface
and uh
so that back to the store of value right
Bitcoin is
it's an ideal store of value because
thank you
it's
got it's got the ability to convey
your energy
not across 10 000 miles but across 10
000 days
30 years in the future
100 years in the future most people when
they're investing in assets they're
taking this very short-term view of like
the next month the next year the next
two years and I find that if if you're
looking at a three-year time frame
everything is very very noisy and
complicated and there's all these
debates
but if you were going to end the debates
go at 100 years
I just take a hundred million dollars
and go through the exercise of giving it
to someone your your heirs heirs air in
a hundred years
and then all of a sudden all of the all
this noise drops away can I put it in
real estate no it'll be taxed out of
existence at 100 years can I put it in
Gold no 98 of it'll be gone if 100 isn't
gone in 100 years because it'll be mine
today can I put it in Fiat no it's going
to be inflated to death can I can I
invest it in a company no name one
company that's around today that was
around 100 years ago that hasn't been
diluted recapitalized
Etc
can I put it in a stock index
well you're trusting a human being to
rebalance the index
you know over and over again what stock
index do you trust for the next hundred
years and by the way it's it's got
counterparty risk at the nation-state
level
Nation might not be there and uh
90 didn't make it so
what are you left with
and and the truth is when you when you
just do that thought experiment it's
pretty obvious
you put it in uh
you would put it in a crypto Network and
a decentralized proof of work network if
the adherence the maximalist
were fanatic zealots about protecting
the Integrity of the network against
meddlers who would screw it up
if if the network is supported by those
with a religious conviction to the
network
such that you could imagine a hundred
years from now there will still be
people protecting the network
but the phrase is keepers of the flame
right every great religion every great
institution has keepers of the flame and
there must be passion do you believe in
your religion do you do you believe
strong enough that you'll flee
persecution to to continue to practice
it right the United States was built on
the foundation the separation of of
church and state and it's a it's a
pretty important and interesting
metaphor people came here because they
could practice their religion
that's why they came here and they came
here because their religion was uh above
their government
they were not they would not sacrifice
whatever it is they believed in
if you look at every institution that
lasts more than 100 years name them
Harvard University Cambridge Oxford
the Catholic Church
Islamic sex certain the Jewish faith
but there's not that many it's like
there's churches or religious sects and
then there's some educational
institutions and I and I see the
educational institutions being shaken at
their core this year right I mean
literally you could have said for 500
years you know
Ivy Leagues Elite universities there are
stalwart institutions
they have lost a huge amount of
credibility this year when you send all
your all of your students home and you
close the campus and people are studying
virtually people's affiliation to the to
the bricks and mortar of the institution
has been dramatically weakened and
unless they morph into a virtual
Institution
the virtual institutions by the way have
dramatically strengthened right like
your affiliation with YouTube
and Facebook and Apple TV
and Bitcoin
has dramatically strengthened and square
cash if it's virtual and your
affiliation with the bricks and mortar
physical uh institution that has been
weakened and those that will survive
have dematerialized and virtualized
right and they and they they've learned
uh they've learned how to project their
ethos
in cyberspace
so yeah back to store value
you need people
human beings Flesh and Blood people that
are going to uh that are going to keep
the flame and the flame a Bitcoin is the
node and the mining rig
it's like imagine we're getting into
Bitcoin as religion or as Faith now but
imagine uh
a thousand years ago I want to keep a
religion alive I have an altar in my
home I have a check every wealthy person
had a chapel in their home
and if you look at religions right you
go to the Far East uh there are altars
and Buddhist Shinto other Fates
so the idea of an altar or a shrine
or
um a cathedral or a church these are
structures where people go to worship
and the worshiping is the feeding of the
flame and oftentimes during the
worshiping they're tithing and they're
channeling 10 percent of their money
as energy
into these religions in order to keep
them relevant
if you look at science if you look at
fantasy fiction
and fantasy where they have gods
the the strength of the God is a
function of the devoutness of the
worshipers of the followers
such and such was worshiped as the god
of the god of the forest and they are
worshiped as the god of the forest and
all of their adherents all their
acolytes are feeding energy to the god
of the force and when they're no longer
worshiped
their energy goes away
right
if you uh if you lose your faithful if
they won't feed you
with the fire of Truth with the energy
that you need the your efficacy Falls
and you die and so how do you feed a
fire right if it's a physical fire you
have to throw wood on the fire how do
you feed a religion you have to tithe
you have to you know the Catholic Church
any church you have to give it money and
maybe you have to give it your life
service
Onward Christian Soldiers I will fight
for the cause I will donate to the cause
that's how you feed
a religious Institution
how do you feed a crypto Network
you got to spin up
facilities of encrypted energy
that adhere to the protocol
every time a minor comes on board it's
feeding the fire every time a node comes
on board that's going to it's going to
certify and validate it's it's uh
protecting right it's creating one more
chain in the in the fall tolerance
structure
and um
that's why a smaller crypto a a crypto
that's a technical experiment
it's an application
isn't the good store of value because if
the people are willing to a fork it if
they want to Fork it and abandon it in
order to in order to implement a new
technology then
um
then the flame dies
and and so
it's pretty clear that uh that Bitcoin
maximalist they have a lot of the faith
and the conviction of True Believers and
any religious faith for the past 2000
years
and why wouldn't they
because um
they share the same values
their values are truth
nature natural laws laws of physics laws
of thermodynamics math Austrian
economics no such thing as a free launch
self-reliance
you know honesty fairness and technology
in advance they share those values
they um
they're taking their monetary energy and
tokenizing it on on a Bitcoin network
with Bitcoin Bitcoin is that single
shared store of value
if
if money
is energy
and energy
begets life
and and a crypto decentralized Network
gives you sovereignty
that's a path to immortality and that
means that everybody in the uh in the
Bitcoin community that believes in this
for the long term is engaged in the
pursuit of Immortal Life
and pursuit of Immortal Life
sounds like a religious Mantra I think
and absolutely and I grew up in the
southern baptist Faith so I'm I'm very
familiar with uh with the ideology of
Christianity and pursuit of immortal
life is pretty Paramount there I did as
well that's interesting
and and
um
if if Bitcoin is a store of value for a
hundred years then it is a it is a um a
technique or it is a
you know it is a technique through which
you can uh project the values through
time so if you're not if you're not
actually providing for a better life for
yourself you're providing for a better
life for your family or you're providing
uh for a better life for your loved ones
or friends or perhaps your values are
you want to support a dog park and you
want to endow the dog part for a hundred
years
or what if you want to endow a you know
environmental cost or save the seals or
save the whales or or it doesn't really
matter what the cause is
cure cancer
do this go to the Stars when I die I
want all of my wealth to be used to make
education free for everyone forever
that actually is one of my values and I
have a foundation the Sailor a
foundation which which gives away free
education to hundreds of thousands of
people
that's a value other people want to go
to outer space
if I can Channel my energy and put it
into a a network
and that Network can be used to fund and
power and endowment that will do that
thing
then um
that that Bitcoin Network or that crypto
network is going to be my mechanism for
achieving
all of my hopes and aspirations from now
to Eternity
that's an amazing point and I would even
conceive of that as a mechanism almost
of the afterlife right it's a way to
carry your will beyond your own life
and the other
the American mythologist Joseph Campbell
he described religion
um as a story that points toward the
transcendental mystery that we all
experience but cannot articulate
and it's it's so all religious
Traditions mythological Traditions are
stories pointing toward a higher truth
and I find it interesting that Bitcoin
has higher Truth uh embedded in code
right there's 21 million number is quite
literally transcendental we can't touch
it we can't change it we can't do
anything about it it's every 10 minutes
it's promulgating the most indisputable
truth that we've ever had right it's
called true Global consensus so it's
it's it's not just a metaphor I think to
call Bitcoin religious it quite actually
is religious
if you
if you worship science if you worship
the laws of physics and the laws of
thermodynamics and and and
mathematical clarity
then Bitcoins you're religious right
right
and
that that's what takes us out of the
range of
of simple asset debates if your time
Horizon is 10 years we can debate
Bitcoin this versus Apple stock that
versus Amazon versus bonds versus
whatever and when you when your time
Horizon is three years by the way it all
is just in the domain of of macro
Traders and and cute arbitragers and
everybody wants to tell you about the
Fibonacci this triangle thing and and
that's overbought and this is oversold
and
you know my head kind of explodes trying
to figure that out but the truth I just
don't care it doesn't you know being
right in the next two years strikes me
as being a bad idea because in order to
be right as a Trader in the near term I
have to turn off the part of my brain
that thinks about what's true and honest
and morally hazard
you know or Russia but you literally
have to be like I know it's stupid to go
this way but since everybody else is
going to go this way I'm going to do
something stupid now because I think I'm
less stupid but more more stupid stupid
than they are stupid it's just it's not
a way to live the market can stay
irrational longer than you can stay
solvent right
yeah and and the problem is like if I
lose by trying to act stupid then I
really was stupid and if I win acting
kind of irrational crazy then I don't
respect myself and meanwhile
you know a much simpler idea is just
figure out what's going to go up by a
factor of a hundred or a thousand and
just go stand there and wait for
entropy to take its course and wait for
Gravity to take its its effect
right and let the water flow downhill
and Let the Fire Burn
right and don't Dash around while the
fire is burning everything stand up and
watch it so
so the solution there is you move from
three years to ten years and then you
move from 10 years to 100 years and at
the Hundred Year time frame it's pretty
clear what's an asset and what's the
store of value and that's where it's
just it's just very obvious eh
Bitcoin is a store of value if
its Believers have religious conviction
in it right
it becomes very simple now
if you if you step out to a thousand
year time frame
and you say what's this thing got to be
in order to last a thousand years
it better be the worship of math and the
laws of thermodynamics and the laws of
physics and and Einstein and Newton
that might make it
and and if if we just focus upon that
and don't and don't let all this other
stuff get mired
I mean that's reasonable I mean people
people have been studying and honoring
math and algebra for 2000 years they've
been honoring calculus for 400 years
right you could say this is truly
the um
the adoption of
economics is a science right maybe it
said it's that uh critical
inflection point where economics went
from being
a political preference
to being a science and if you adopt it
as a science
then you get that then you actually get
massive advantages technically and if
you rejected
I know it's I guess it's kind of like
the guys in the Dark Ages and they could
accept calculus
or they could reject calculus right
no Bridges
yeah if you reject calculus make a
bridge see what happens how about it
there's a lot of stuff in life if if you
look back at the guy that did more than
anything probably Isaac Newton is
responsible for 90 percent of just about
everything we have around us and if you
rejected principia Mathematica because
you just thought it was inconvenient you
probably rejected 90 of everything that
we have today that we hold near and dear
and natural selection takes care of the
rest right if you reject these truths
that are uncovered you're it's the end
of your legacy in the long run
[Music]
seven with Michael Saylor here in the
Sailor series
and wow what an episode
um we have gone really deep into the
topic of Bitcoin uh and I think we we
had a really strong finish today so
it's going to run through a few of the
things we talked about you know we
started out with this concept of
Bitcoin as a monetary missile and this
took me back to episode one where we're
talking about fire missiles and
hydraulics being these these primary
Stone Age technologies that allowed
mankind to come into dominance in the
world
and I thought the analogy is very
interesting that you know using Bitcoin
we have this sort of ultimate High
Ground behind a wall of encrypted energy
but we can also accelerate our monetary
energy and deploy it
anywhere in the world you know across
any domain
um near nearly instantly
uh with virtual window frictions at all
and so not only does it give us this
advantage of asymmetric terrain but we
also get maximal force with how we
deploy that monetary energy in the the
generation of capital
um so I thought that was that was super
Ophthalmology and then we talked about
how that effectively makes Bitcoin the
highest
bandwidth
price Discovery transparency and
security asset in the world right so we
have this pure money that propagates
pure price signals so would allow for
Pure price Discovery all of that is
premised on its open source ethos which
is essentially absolute transparency and
that gives it the ultimate security so
there's a bit of a paradox there it's
like by being totally open to inspection
Bitcoin actually resists uh you know
manipulation or emulation even and that
it's
um everything about it is out in the
open so it's it's more a quality of its
Network effects its liquidity its first
mover Advantage all of these things even
actually The Disappearance of Satoshi
which we'll get into a bit later all of
these things sort of wrap this open
technology in a you know apparently
disruption proof casing
um so I thought that was a really really
powerful discussion points
and as Taylor calls Bitcoin
the creature that never sleeps right we
have this
swarm intelligence if you will that
never stops growing changing adapting
um trading you know it just it is
a fully autonomous
uh and Perpetual monetary Network
competing against these other monetary
networks that are rigidly controlled in
certain time Windows
um and you know to this point it's like
an individual organism has to sleep
but a swarm creature does not so the
Swarm creature necessarily out competes
the individual organism because it
doesn't need to sleep right it just
keeps adapting and growing uh becoming
more fit and you know as we know from
Darwin it's the most fit competitor uh
that wins out in an ecosystem
and I thought this was a great Point too
I never thought of it this way that
in a swarm
the weakest elements are actually weeded
out right they so it's constantly
sacrificing its weaker elements to
Natural Selection and thereby
strengthening The Ensemble whereas the
individual organism is subject to any
singular attack Vector if it's defense
is penetrated it the whole entity or
organism essentially is lost so in that
way centralized entities are only as
strong as their weakest link or sailor
says are constrained by their lowest
common denominator
whereas a decentralized entity like the
Swarm is going to be strengthened by its
highest common denominator right
um so and we can think about this it's
kind of like something that learns at
the edges so if one member of the Swarm
figures out how to effectively deal with
a predator or threat then it will tend
to
um reproduce
and its genes will be replicated into
the rest of the Swarm so the the entire
decentralized entity or organism is
actually learning at the edges and
incorporating those lessons into its its
whole body whereas the centralized
entity if it encounters a predator that
it doesn't know how to deal with or even
figures out how to defeat it doesn't it
doesn't spread that uh adaptivity to the
rest of its body essentially it's just
it's a one-to-one relationship versus
this one to many
um so the one to many gives it just much
more intelligence and adaptivity in the
long run
and the time respect to bitcoin it's as
a
similar's point if any Market
participant in the Bitcoin Network
figures out a way to deliver a solution
you know smarter faster stronger better
um that that will essentially that's
where the capital will flow again
because the capital is unrestricted
right it's it's not
um
it is not
siled to any particular
jurisdiction or institution individuals
have maximal sovereignty over their
Bitcoin Capital so they can move it
anywhere in the world so
in his example of say someone's setting
up
a decentralized or centralized
institution in Singapore for instance
that solved the yield curve problem so
matching lenders and borrowers of
Bitcoin in a way that establishes a
long-term yield curve for Bitcoin that
this would
you know that would create all of a
sudden this risk-free rate on bitcoin
which is the one thing that it lacks as
we've discussed in earlier episodes to
make it a truly pristine collateral that
would be competitive to say U.S
treasuries is that Bitcoin doesn't
currently have a yield
um but if you could match borrowers and
lenders you could actually create that
curve
so the point was
say this uh we create this eight percent
risk-free rate on bitcoin until your
money then all of a sudden not only have
you strengthened the
um which could be used by the way this
if you had this risk for rate on bitcoin
and you have Fiat deprecating it say two
percent a year best case then this opens
up an attack Vector on Fiat or you could
actually
um go long Bitcoin short the dollar and
squeeze uh the difference in yield this
is called speculative attack
and this hat would have the effect of
strengthening the speculative attacker
himself but it would also strengthen the
holder in uh you know Schenectady or
whatever town that doesn't know anything
about this just by virtue of uh more
price appreciation pressure being
applied to bitcoin so more energy being
drawn into the network actually benefits
all Network participants
and this is contrary to a centralized uh
entity
and if you if you flip this back to the
Great Wall of China example it's like
you've inverted that security model so
it was a Great Wall of China is just a
perimeter of Defense it doesn't adapt if
you can penetrate any point of it the
whole uh defensible area is lost right
that's actually what happened on the
Mongols penetrated the gate
uh whereas
Bitcoin is effectively this swarm
intelligence right so it's it's
any network participant that can figure
something out is benefiting the entire
network and then you've also further
capitalized or further energized those
Network participants to go out and solve
other problems on behalf of other
network participants so there's this
virtuous cycle built right into it
that's just not does not exist with any
other form of money
and
then we take a bit of a pivot and we got
into
how human intervention negatively and
adversely impacts complex systems and
say look at the example of you know the
Lions complaining that the antelope are
too fast so the hunter hobbles the
antelope
the Lions you know kill all the antelope
get lazy because they're not being close
to their limits so then after all the
end hope are eliminated the Lions starve
to death and then the hunter blames it
on the weather right uh this is a core
Concept in television and telev's books
where he says that human intervention
moves us from what he calls mediocrustan
to extremistam
um meaning essentially that the uh
non-linearity of effects goes through
the roof once we try to intervene in
natural systems because there's there
are all these Dynamic equilibria that
we're unaware of and when we offset uh
you know we try to press one lever to
cause one result there's a Cascade of
unintended consequences surrounding that
um one common example here is called the
Cobra problem Cobra problem and you can
look this up on say Wikipedia But the
gist of it is that uh I forget what
country but they they had a problem with
overpopulation of cobras so they passed
the law that said uh it offered a ransom
for every dead Cobra brought to the
government you know they give you ten
dollars or whatever it was
and this had the unintended consequence
of incentivizing people to actually
start breeding cobras and killing them
uh and then to take them into the
government and get this reward so it
actually further exacerbated the over
population problem and uh financially
compromised the local government so
that's just one example where
you know good intentions go awry and
history is just full of these
um
and to tie that back into money you know
that's what I guess you could say
the central bank or interest rate
manipulation
you know intentionality aside we could
possibly argue that it was done uh and
and with the attempt to make things
better right
um You can you can argue both sides that
let's just say for instance that
um it was done with good and wholesome
intentions to benefit the economy or
stimulate demand you know or uh keep
prices stable on employment low and
predictable and all these things uh that
still when you're talking about
suppressing interest rates to induce
money creation and borrowing
you're going to war
with the temporal and energetic
principles of thermodynamics because
again
money is like the price of money the
interest rate is the price of time right
I'm going to give you money now that
you're going to give me back later
there's a price associated with attitude
of payment it's called the interest rate
if a centralized body is artificially
suppressing that you're actually trying
to you know in Sailors always is to
reverse the flow of time you're
discounting the price of time and this
has just so many disastrous unintended
consequences around it
um which we went into you know but
you're you're pushing back against
thermodynamics which are which is the
invaluable rule set of the universe
and I would argue that actually
trying to suppress the price of time
causes us to Discount uh the value of
our own time in the time of others
actually and you can say timer energy
again
um
and it I think that is kind of the
culprit at the heart of this moral
hazard related to fiat currency is that
we're discounting time and energy which
is the intrinsic value of human beings
effectively and that's the one case by
the way where I use the term intrinsic
value because I do think humans are the
only intrinsically value you can maybe
expand that to life more generally but
um
there's no objects that have intrinsic
value value is subjective but life
itself has living beings that seems to
be kind of an absolute as that we should
we should have uh value for life
um anyways bit of a philosophical side
and
in that way we if we're looking at this
organism aspect
uh you know actually discounting the
price of life
um and we see all the moral hazard that
Central Banking has created and all the
Warfare It's funded it's as if Bitcoin
is an autoimmune response somehow from
society uh to social banking right and
you know as the other side clearly
the message in the Genesis block
solidifies that
um and he goes a little bit deeper
actually to say that Satoshi was clearly
an individual sensitive to these
um negatives socioeconomic consequences
of Central Banking
and his own sensitivity was a response
to the sensitivity of others right
people that had been marginalized or
victimized by the system throughout the
ages and
um
it's ad that you could call that like an
in form of inflammation basically the
socioeconomic superorganism and then
Satoshi was uh just the you know the
cell of the organism that figured it out
right he figured out the correct
response launched it into the world in
the right way at the right time
um so I thought that was just really
interesting that you know
there's and and we're going to quote on
them uh I talked to him about the fourth
turning he made the point I actually
read this book yet we made the point
that in these uh long quite these long
Cycles there's you know first second
third fourth turning there tends to come
a kind of pivotal
moments or innovation or something that
comes just at the right time to sort of
reverse course uh and it feels and seems
like Bitcoin is definitely becoming that
of the Modern Age
um the world is just going One Direction
on Central Banking and we needed uh some
autoimmune response that appears Bitcoin
is that so I thought that was really
fascinating
and then we we got into Bitcoin as a
store of value
and I I think made very strong arguments
um again especially when you zoom out to
kind of 100 year plus time frame that
Bitcoin is basically this sole
21st century store value right it just
is incomparable to anything else
um and this you know 2020 war on
currency and uh escalating government
overreach this is just pushed an
awareness of Bitcoin on people
um and sort of accelerated that
autoimmune response in a way and to just
kind of like compare it you know real
quick as we went through alternative
stores of value you have bonds but
they're now bumping up against the zero
bound uh and you know to say this point
like it's harder to discern you're being
taken advantage of when the natural
interest rate is two percent you're
getting or five percent you're getting
two percent but it's much easier for
Market participants to understand
they're getting screwed when they're uh
there's a negative yield right it just
it's there's there's something very
special about Crossing that zero barrier
and that's where bonds are at today so
that they're getting uh quickly
decimated as a viable store value
because there's no yield
equities they're way overvalued right
across all fundamentals and valuation
metrics where you know historic all-time
highs PE ratios and
eva.enterize Enterprise Value or sorry
multiples on ebay.org Enterprise Value
et cetera et cetera
um and that is
you know what what I would argue is
Bitcoin is a function of we've
compromised the store value function of
fiat currency so that function is now
the Market's figuring out it needs to
put assign that function to any other
asset right and equities are somewhat
reliably scarce at least
um
but this has a perverse effect in that
since
as sailor says the price of equities are
delaminating from their fundamentals
right so they're over valued uh in the
marketplace that they're actually
becoming more and more risky right so
there's this perverse effect of
the more we use in equity as a store of
value the more the less effective it is
as a store of value in the long run
which is which is really strange and
Bitcoin is the opposite of that right
Bitcoin is actually becoming more secure
as a store value as its price increases
and therefore more attractive
um and this is an economic concept
called the veblin good which we could
look up but basically there are certain
assets that actually become
uh the demand tends to increase as the
price increases which is contrary to
most other assets but I think Bitcoin
fits that category uh Commodities are
another alternative you know we
destroyed those in earlier episodes I'd
say go check that out um check those out
and then finally real estate which has
been a really popular one for the past
50 years especially in the US but
you know real estate cannot be hidden
and it's taxed every year is the easiest
thing in the world to tax because you
can't hide it and you know that is the
Dominion on which governments project
their power
um so I think that there's really high
valuations there plus uh there's no
concealability concealability so that
that um sort of compromises real estate
as a good store value
and
you know he makes the point that
to be a good store of value you really
want to have a technology that's focused
on that function right equities are you
know you're creating all kinds of other
value in the economy granted I'll be at
riskally right you have to they're
taking on risks and trying new Ventures
and figuring things out innovating
you know property would be a little more
stable but it still has other uses right
there's actually utility use there so
the point being you want a pure store
value right that's what gold effectively
was was the purest store value we had
historically and now that's what Bitcoin
is today and we could say it's it's kind
of like being a single-celled organism
right a sailor said you don't want to be
a vertebrate with all these complex
features because the additional features
open you up to more risk in the tax
surface what you want is something uh
very uni-dimensional single cell just
holds value and a trust minimized
weighing across time and space and
that's what Bitcoin is right that is the
big breakthrough
so and that led us into
via negativa which is another television
concept that I really like
and
in a way you know this is ties back to a
quote uh actually I heard let's say
they're tweeted once said quote a
designer knows he has achieved
perfection
and there's nothing left to take away
unquote
and as we discussed previously
money has five properties right
divisibility durability recognizability
portability scarcity so what did Satoshi
do
the creation of Bitcoin
the reason it's so genius and the reason
Satoshi is an artist and the reason
Bitcoin is effectively a perfected money
is because Satoshi took away all of the
indivisibility
all of the decomposability all of the
unrecognizability all of the
immovability and all of the
unpredictability from money right he
maximally removed all of these negative
aspects of money
to deliver us the you know quasi
Perfection that is Bitcoin
um and that speaks again to this
minimization of attack surface right
you've reduced all of the kind of the
features of money to stripped it down to
its Bare Bones just its bare monetary
properties and you've taken away all the
the negative aspects from those
properties so you effectively perfected
those properties
um and this speaks again to bitcoin's
resistance to disruption right so we've
we've achieved
attack surface minimization via monetary
property optimization so this is
this is via negativa right you're the
more you take away the more what what
you have left it becomes more valuable
essentially
um so I thought that was just a really
interesting way to look at it
and another way to say that is you know
we commonly hear that oh this new crypto
asset can do this or that the Bitcoin
can't do but
the the Lesser feature set of Bitcoin
is a feature itself not a bug right
because it's it's whole value prop is
survivability right it cannot be stopped
it is just perfected store value that
adheres to 21 million and no one can
shut down the network right no political
or military action can shut down the
network that is the core value prop of
Bitcoin that is what it optimizes for
um and a singer puts this again in one
of his tweets he says Bitcoin has no
country has no company and has no
competitor right so that's what makes it
so special is that it's something
it actually exists Beyond us and which
turns out to be really important
um and I would add to that too that
Bitcoin also doesn't have an oh we'll
say this Bitcoin has no identified
Creator right we know it's Satoshi but
no one knows who Satoshi is it's we
don't have this person to point toward
and the absence
of that personality the Creator actually
I would say gives Bitcoin mythological
Bedrock right which really underpins its
decentralization if we knew Satoshi and
he was in the news every day and he was
out getting drunk at the bar or
something you know and everyone knew he
had a million coins it would just opened
him up to a lot of attacks would call a
lot of things into question
um that his disappearance basically
nullified so the you know this godhead
of Bitcoin would call Satoshi I think
really
reinforces the the value proposition of
survivability and decentralization
and that gets us into what I thought was
the most interesting part of the
discussion today
and that was when sailor pointed to the
fanaticism
of Bitcoin maximalist has an asset right
as it is he uh contributing factor to
the value of the Bitcoin Network
and you know I love this the the analogy
where the Defenders of 21 million
effectively
the network participants themselves we
are the keepers of the flame right we
are the mythological keepers of the
flame
and
the point being there
to preserve an institution adequately
over time you need
uh adherence or Fanatics if you will
that are so convicted in their belief
that they're willing to flee persecution
to preserve the institution right and he
drew the analogy to people coming to the
U.S people came to the U.S largely to
practice religious freedom right people
wanted a refuge
that they could freely
um put their their spiritual preferences
above their their political above
politics effectively
um and the U.S provided that so
I thought that was super interesting
um and then to bring It Forward a bit
it's we're seeing the faith
shaken in existing institutions
worldwide right whether it's your
government Bank all these Legacy
institutions uh faith has been severely
shaken especially in the wake of covid
um which Salem made a great point it's
even like at the universities where no
one's going to campus anymore and
they're taking courses online you're
reducing
the affiliation with the brick and
mortar University and you're
strengthening the affiliation with the
digital University right so that the
institutions and companies and brands
that adapt to the digital age more
quickly will actually benefit more at
the expense of Legacy institutions
and um so that's a mega political Trend
excuse me it's underway
excuse me
and
the flame for Bitcoin if you will
is kept between the nodes the miners and
the holders
and I love this you know which are
basically preserving this dynamic
equilibrium centered on 21 million and I
love this the analogy of worshiping at
the altar where
people in the past all worshiped at the
altar
um they would actually feed the flame
even by by tithing say 10 of their their
income
um so they're funding
this religious Institution
and they're also uh preaching these
values to their contemporaries or their
kids so they're passing these values
forward in time using both money and
language which I thought was was very
interesting in ritual I would add to
that
um and so in Bitcoin World we've got
miners
energizing the fire right they're uh
adding additional energy to the network
that that is its security budget
effectively you have nodes protecting
the fire which are basically selecting
the rule set that the miners are
enforcing and then we have the holders
themselves
which are the fire the the the the
living flame
um that's centered around 21 million so
it's like this group of people uh this
social layer that's all oriented to
preserving 21 million which benefits
everyone and intertwines everyone's fate
so
and each one of those is just another
element in this you know this composite
fault tolerance structure that we call
Bitcoin so it's just radically new way
to think about it as more of a in
religious-like institution and maybe you
could even say that
um
phenot nodes Miners and holders are kind
of like the Holy Trinity
of Bitcoin right maybe maybe 21 million
is is the the god or something that
they're oriented around might be a
stretch but I thought
um I thought I'd mention it nonetheless
so
Bitcoin as a religion question comes
naturally
what are its values right and a sailor
sailor declares truth natural law
thermodynamics self-reliance honesty
fairness technology self sovereignty all
of these things
are embedded in the value systems of
true bitcoiners
um and they carry that into the world I
think in in their in their word and
their deed in their Investments
um and it you know I just can't think of
a more
robust
powerful effective well-organized group
of people in the world than than the
bitcoiners are interacted with you know
I've said it before there's nothing in
the world that makes me more bullish
from Bitcoin than Bitcoin is
um
and you know again if we if we go back
to the purpose of man or at least what
distinguishes him and makes him uh
Superior to their animals it's our
ability to channel Energy across space
and time
and I love this point so energy right
begets life
so Bitcoin as being this this tool
for immortalizing the channeling of
energy right we can Channel it across
space and time any direction we want
with essentially no loss
that 21 million or Bitcoin itself it's
actually in a way kind of the pursuit of
immortal life right we're pursuing uh a
medium that maximally preserves Energy
across space and time so it's like well
of course it's a religious institution
we're pursuing a moral life uh not the
moral life in the sense like you live
forever but
um a network or institution that lives
forever for the betterment of all and
one in which you can project your own
wills and values beyond your own life
[Music]
um
and you know the example there was
like the Sailor Foundation which is
his value
and say his own personal value system is
free education for all right he thinks
that is something that's really
important for the human race and now
with Bitcoin he has a way to
finance and project those values Beyond
his own life right he
can now do something
uh to
to fund and strengthen this institution
Beyond his own life in a way that was
not possible before Bitcoin and you
could kind of say that this is a way of
him uh you know projecting values and
willpower and intentions and preferences
into his own afterlife if you will
doesn't mean up into heaven but just
beyond his own life so I thought that
was really interesting
and then we touched on
you know again another way another
religious aspect aspect of this is that
21 million is truly Transcendent right
it is something no one can do anything
about
um and I think that speaks to its its
religious qualities in a way as well
um
and you know it had this great quote
said if you worship science the laws of
physics thermodynamics and mathematical
Clarity then Bitcoin is your religion I
thought that was beautifully said
um and
it's it points back to us again right
it's like the the strength of Bitcoin
as a store of value as money is rooted
in the faithfulness of its adherence
right of its Believers if you will so
[Music]
um
it is up to all of us to preserve the
principles embodied in those fields of
study
um and that's what Bitcoin is so
and then you know we concluded with
uh which I thought that was a great
point is perhaps economics through all
of history
was
just more of a political preference or a
very uh much more just a social science
right even in Austrian economics
there's very little use of objective
measurements because there are no
constants in Human Action effectively
but it seems like with Bitcoin we do
have this Collision we have this
Collision of
you know collect computer science and
everything underpinning that with uh the
softer social science of Economics so
maybe this is the emergence of something
really different and unique right like a
true or not a more objective economic
science you know we're still
these things like value uh supply and
demand you know supplies the objective
side demand is the subjective side these
things are still going to be they're so
still going to hold the same qualities
but the introduction of absolute
scarcity
um and a money that cannot be
monopolized and is this corruption
certainly changes the game right uh I
don't know that it will cause us to
rewrite the history books per se but we
will move more towards this engineering
like mindset I think in the in the field
of Economics so I thought that was
really really put it excuse me
uh so yeah that was it man it was
Monster episode I hope you guys enjoyed
that uh I you know
one two and three built a lot of
foundation I think four five and six
really started to to build some
Crescendo here and seven was a big peak
for me personally especially the latest
stages of this discussion uh I
definitely think we're rooting around
the bottom of the Bitcoin Rabbit Hole uh
hope you guys enjoyed this uh and I'll
see you back here soon for the next one
foreign
[Music]