Michael Saylor and Bill Barhydt. The Ultimate Crypto Interview on Money Talks!
ABRA · 2021-09-24 · 1h 00m · View on YouTube →
all right boom let's do this welcome to
money talks i'm your host bill barheitz
our goal with money talks is to make the
crypto
economy accessible
easier to understand
and maybe a little fun
so normally we focus on retail and
uh what it means to folks like us
individuals who want to invest in
bitcoin and the crypto economy today
we're going to have a little bit of a
different focus today i want to talk
more about institutional adoption
of bitcoin and crypto
and as you can see
uh in the image here uh we'll bring up
in a second here uh you know there's a
few companies that have had kind of an
outsized impact
on bitcoin in particular with their
holdings um
probably the the best known brand that's
holding bitcoin would be would be tesla
uh who made waves earlier this year when
elon musk first announced that they were
buying bitcoin but then also announced
uh that they were going to sell 10 of it
turns out that it was actually very
clever on their part because they wanted
to make sure that they could sell it
in a pinch and it was kind of a
liquidity test and they're still holding
the 90 percent that they've purchased so
far sounded like they intend to purchase
more but we haven't heard anything since
uh but by far the the largest uh
purchaser
uh and holder of uh of bitcoin as a
public company is a micro strategy
and we'll be joined in a couple of
minutes by the founder and ceo
of microstrategy michael saylor
and
let me just
give you a little bit of
background on our research on on
michael's absolute genius if you've ever
heard him speak i'm sure most of you
have if you're involved in crypto it's
kind of hard not to
uh mike's uh he's an mit
i believe aerospace engineer
uh had uh dibs on trying to become a
pilot and
ultimately uh luckily for us went into
the software business um instead and um
uh went through uh you know just a huge
boom cycle with uh microstrategy in the
90s and was one of the most prolific uh
ipos uh during that
original internet era dot com era i
remember it vividly
so uh uh there's so many things i could
tell you uh that i've read and heard
about michael but maybe we'll it's
better off we're better off just kind of
getting into it directly ourselves
so uh without further ado let me uh let
me bring michael on
to join us
good afternoon and and i believe you're
in miami welcome
and bill thanks for having me how you
doing
i'm awesome good good great thank you
yeah uh china news aside
the umpteenth ban
of of bitcoin uh at least for today uh
maybe maybe they'll bet it again today
have they ever done twice in one day i
don't know
i think it's good marketing bill
you know like if you think about it you
know you've got pronouncements you know
the the president of turkey says stuff
about bitcoin people are asking the
premier of
russia whether they'll accept bitcoin
people want to know from central bankers
what they think about bitcoin
when's the last time somebody asked the
government their opinion of apple stock
or whether you should invest in the
vanguard 500 index or whether you should
invest in gold or silver
or any other stock
or options trading or whether you should
put your money in a you know money
market nobody nobody cares about any of
those things the only thing they care
about is bitcoin bitcoin is sucking the
oxygen out of the room
and good news is good news and bad news
is good news and as long as you keep
talking about it it's
it's a good thing so now you have the
entire government in essence saying
it's just so good we're a little bit
afraid of it
and then you have people like the ray
dalia saying
yeah well what's your problem with it
well it's just so perfect that i'm sure
that somebody will want to stop it or
ban it because it's too perfect
i mean really that's the problem that
it's just too good that people are
afraid of it i think it's a good idea
you tell do you tell your marketing team
at microstrategy that that no price is
bad press
no press
i've tweeted it
okay
i think pt barnum said it once he said
all publicity is
good publicity but certainly i think for
bitcoin
i really do believe that that the more
people talk about it the better it is
you can't buy this kind of publicity
right
name one others investible asset
that is getting this news cycle
right now it's dominating the mainstream
media it's dominating television it's
dominating
everybody's concerns is there a
politician in the world
that isn't aware of it
yeah okay so here's the thing like when
i was young i saw i used to hate the
short sellers oh they're shorting my
stock
but the truth is you know uh someone
that shorts your stock has to buy it
back in the future
so
if someone talks about bitcoin and they
say they like it then that's good but if
they talk about bitcoin and they have an
issue
then there's only two things you can do
right you can either buy it or you
cannot buy it
and so if a hundred billion times people
mention it and half the time they agree
with the person that said whatever they
said okay well then they didn't buy it
but that's the status quo the other half
of the time the status quo is changing
so i think that this this is really just
elevating the brand
so so i have a whole bunch of things i
want to talk about so let's get to it
one more time the first question i got
to ask you all right
right at the top of your twitter feed
which has 1.5 million followers now i'm
going to guess it was a lot less 18
months ago
um
bitcoin is a swarm of cyber hornets
serving the goddess of wisdom feeding on
the fire of truth
exponentially growing ever smarter
faster and stronger behind a wall of
encrypted energy so now for those of us
who don't have degrees from mit can you
explain what that means sure
well so one thing i realize about
bitcoin is it's a totally decentralized
network
and um and people and companies and
entities are joining it so
i got the i got the metaphor for the
swarm of cyber hornets when i listened
to the wine of bitcoin miners
when you hear them they they you know
they they scream if you've ever been in
a bitcoin mining facility and makes you
think about a swarm of hornets
but the truth of the matter is
you know
some people thought oh it's the bitcoin
miners
well yeah there's hundreds and hundreds
if not thousands of bitcoin miners i
mean there's there's a million two
million bitcoin mining rigs out there
right so there's a there's a million
plus
hornets in the bitcoin mining world and
they're all converting
you know electrical engineering energy
into digital energy and so that's part
of it
but the other part of it is is all the
cyber hornets on twitter
they thought it meant them
right it's like all the people on
twitter talking about bitcoin and it
sort of did but it didn't exclusively
mean them
it also means that this morning when i
got up i turned on the television and
someone in china
is saying something and already 20 000
people had said something else about it
and then
anthony scaramucci is on tv and he's
talking about it on cnbc
and i thought scaramucci is a hornet
right and then i and then i heard andrew
sorkin saying
so bitcoin is visibly decentralized but
i'm not sure about the other coins
and scaramucci saying well that's what a
bitcoin maximalist would say
and i'm thinking
andrew's promoting bitcoin
scaramucci's promoting bitcoin
you know yesterday jack muller was on
cnbc talking about bitcoin
every journalist every influencer how
many ceos of bitcoin are there you're
promoting bitcoin i'm promoting bitcoin
jack dorsey's talking about bitcoin
and thousands of ceos so every company
on earth every government on earth every
bitcoin miner every bitcoin exchange
it's a swarm
creature and it's only growing stronger
because people keep joining the network
and every single one of them that joins
the network makes the network stronger
so let's let's talk for a second about
somebody who's and thanks for the
explanation let's talk for a second
about somebody who's not promoting
bitcoin i don't know if you heard on
peter schiff's uh uh sorry on uh peter
mccormick's what bitcoin did he had
peter schiff on a couple weeks ago and
uh he was debating somebody and i forget
the gentleman's name he actually was
very smart uh peter schiff didn't really
budge red cross maybe yeah that was it
great for us did you hear the interview
okay so first of all i think that peter
schiff is one of the bitcoiners he's
supporting bitcoin too all he does is
talk about bitcoin well okay boss is
another one they're all talking about
bitcoin right even when you're even when
you're
saying something negative a bitcoin
you're supporting bitcoin steve hanke is
supporting bitcoin they're all marketing
bitcoin when they when they don't market
bitcoin when they think they're hating
it they're loving it and when they're
okay but let's make it useful for those
the boomers listening who want to
respond to the gold bugs which i don't
think they did a great job of in the
podcast right
um
you know he he's he's just hasn't moved
his needle right he may be supporting it
because he talks about it but the under
the pr this discussion we just had but
but how do you respond to the gold bug
who really is entrenched and says this
is going to zero
um i mean every paradigm shift you've
got people in the old guard that they
just will never accept the new thing you
know albert einstein
who is of course one of the geniuses of
our world never accepted quantum
uncertainty
god does not play dice with the universe
sometimes people cannot be persuaded of
these things
there are people that could not be
persuaded
when the airplane was invented there are
a lot of people that had never flown an
airplane and they were unwilling to fly
in an airplane for the rest of their
life
you know some people didn't want to give
up their horses
some people don't you know
my father
my father doesn't use a computer
routinely
yeah
i think i think the first iphone my
father used was like the iphone
11 or the iphone 12. he skipped the
first 10 generations
so it's i mean people just sometimes
don't embrace new technology
yeah you know when you and i are if
we're still in this business 30 years
from now
someone's probably going to come up with
a new technology that we have a hard
time getting our hands around
that's going to be a sad day for me i'm
usually the first to buy anything if you
can't sell it so
um
so how how does
getting back to the institutional
question for a second yeah micro
strategy sells enterprise software right
right you're you're taking the profits
from that for the most part and you're
putting them into bitcoin is my simple
understanding of of what's happening and
you're also leveraging the company by
borrowing money on on
via bond issuance to also buy bitcoin is
that accurate
yeah i mean the right way to think about
us is we're like a fiat miner we're a
synthetic bitcoin miner we have a
software business that generates large
cash flows and so
we convert those cash flows into bitcoin
as we generate them
but um we also uh issue debt and we
convert the debt into bitcoin and then
sometimes we issue equity and we convert
the equity into bitcoin
so
we do all that because we think the
bitcoin is the best property in the
world and if we can raise capital
cheaply and invest in something that we
believe will be accretive to our
shareholders we do that
and i think you put up a tweet recently
or last week it said you think you're
holding over 110 000
the public number is like
114 000
more than 114 and i think outside of of
dcg which really isn't a public company
i think that makes makes microstrategy
the largest public company holder of
bitcoin today is my understanding
and does that create from an
institutional perspective issues with
you know accounting rules securities
rules um
headaches that you know
that we don't know about i mean
yeah so if you're a public company
um and you're going to acquire property
you can acquire as much property as you
want so i could buy billions and
billions of dollars worth of timberland
or land or buildings
and uh and i do that as an operating
company bitcoin is property
so there's no limit to the amount of
bitcoin you can acquire now if i were to
acquire the bitcoin in a fund
if i were to go buy gbtc or i would buy
a mutual fund i wouldn't be buying
property i'd be buying a security
and so there is a distinction between
owning property bitcoin is a commodity
equals property versus owning a security
if you own if more than 40 of your
tangible assets are securities i think
you trip the sec 40 act and then you're
a financial company and you have a whole
different set of regulatory uh
requirements so
so owning the property versus the
security was one of the
the constraints or the nuances we had to
consider
um the other nuance uh it doesn't give
us problems but it might give us other
companies problems is is the accounting
for bitcoin
as property has traditionally been and
is now uh indefinite intangible
which means that if you buy a billion
dollars of it and the price trades down
by 50 percent over the weekend and then
it trades up by a factor of 10
you could have in theory 10 billion
dollars of bitcoin but you would be
showing on your balance sheet 500
million dollars of assets
and in theory you could have a nine
billion dollar investment gain but you
would be showing a 500 million dollar
operating loss right okay so this is uh
odd
and it's confusing right um we
uh we have to provide a set of pro
formas on our p l's and our balance
sheets to explain to people what that
means and of course
since our shareholders are generally
long bitcoin and we're substantially a
bitcoin company right a large part of
our market cap is bitcoin that's not a
really a problem for us
but
it would be a problem for a company like
nike if if you're apple computer or nike
or facebook and if you had a pristine p
l and a pristine balance sheet
then uh if you were to buy a bunch of
bitcoin and it traded down you would
actually have an operating loss in the
quarter which is indistinguishable from
having lost money selling tennis shoes
or having lost money uh selling
advertisement so if you're a
conservative cfo
or a conservative board of directors you
would think you'd be afraid of the
volatility of bitcoin but to be clear
you're not afraid of the economic
volatility you're afraid of the
accounting volatility
so but that's a big issue how do we get
i'm sure you're talking to other public
companies either cfos or ceos all the
time and you don't have to disclose but
but
but how do we get them over that hump
given this what's see i mean uh maybe
it's surmountable maybe the fasb changes
the accounting rules but i don't have
any visibility into them doing that so
yeah well so that i mean that was the
news this week bill that on wednesday we
closed the window and submitting letters
to the financial account standards board
and a lot of letters got submitted i
think more than 100 by big companies by
big institutional investors by regula by
other regulators by other analysts
so we we have been uh part uh of the
vanguard leading that charge yep to put
this in front of fazbee
and uh and i'm cautiously optimistic i
think in time that'll be addressed i
mean as i don't see anybody in the
marketplace saying it isn't a good idea
to go from indefinite intangible
accounting to fair market accounting and
so i think that is that's a catalyst
over time and in the meantime i think
the most important thing is just to
educate people
i think the the work around the result
is two things
if you're a public company and you want
to protect your p l your balance sheet
you would buy bitcoin as a security by
purchasing
you could buy gbtc you could you could
buy a fund a bitcoin fund or a mutual
fund that owns bitcoin for that exposure
and that's one way to do it because then
it gets accounted for as a security with
fair value accounting the other approach
is you just buy a small amount
like i think you know square's initial
purchase was you know they bought one
percent of their balance sheet if it's a
one two three five percent that it
wouldn't be material and so
you could do that um
i think you could do the tesla approach
i mean tesla's you know obviously known
for being more decisive as a company
than many other companies
but even there
you know if you look at my tweet you
know what i said was you ought to buy 10
billion dollars of this stuff
and then buy another 10 billion dollars
you'll make a hundred billion then
you'll make a trillion dollars right
right
the michael sayler approach would be go
hard right and go for the billion you
know go go for the trillion dollars
because why why not right well you're
not a dollar cost averaging guy i guess
i'm not a dollar cost averaging guy my
view is is you have a chance uh to turn
a billion into 10 billion
and if i had a billion i could turn into
10 million i would but uh if you're a
bit more conservative
you know and you're gonna take a five
percent position or two percent position
then you wouldn't do that
i think gold you know ultimately why
wouldn't you buy the security because if
you buy the security you don't have
title to the underlying property so you
can't
you cannot move it between a hundred
thousand counterparties with no taxable
event
and i think it's useful to be able to
move a billion dollars without paying
tax on it right
it's an obvious thing for security
reasons and also you just don't want to
pay the tax when you move it from
counterparty to counterparty so
i don't think that's good but i you know
the summary is people are moving into it
bill i mean 35 40 publicly traded
companies
will have bitcoin on their balance sheet
by the end of the year and that's up
from zero
a year and a half ago so we're making
progress but we'll make much faster
progress
when the accounting gets fixed okay that
was my next question do you think that
there are fortune 100 cfos
waiting right now with their finger on
the buy button for this issue to be
resolved i've heard through back
channels that there are a lot of very
large companies that would make larger
investments it were not for the
accounting fair okay and so the
recommendation let me be clear the
number one impediment
to a publicly traded company buying
billions of dollars of bitcoin
is the accounting yeah and and the
proposal is go to a fair market model
where you can mark to market as you you
know
as you would with any other tangible and
that solves the problem and that's my
layman's explanation but that's more or
less the recommendation let's give it
give it the same if i if warren buffett
buys 10 billion dollars worth of apple
stock
you know if he was told he could only
write it down and never write it up
he probably wouldn't have bought it
right yep so just get give it a fair a
fair accounting treatment that's that's
fair value or it's comparable or at
parity with other assets that you could
buy
yep
is there a scenario
that you can think of in the next can i
make one more point though okay go ahead
it's an important point
uh bitcoin with fair value accounting
would be actually superior as an asset
on a balance sheet to owning apple stock
or owning any kind of stock because the
stock is still a security
and the security still trips that 40
limit right whereas if you own property
it would put it at parity more with like
treasury bonds i could have 100 of my
balance sheet and treasury bonds
right i couldn't have 100 of my balance
sheet in securities right or you just
become a broker dealer or an ria or
something like that as an addition to a
public company right it doesn't work for
an operating company they couldn't do
that right right okay got it is there a
scenario that you can imagine
you know even with a 0.1 percent chance
of happening where you would actually
start selling bitcoin in the next year
or two years
no
no it's a look bitcoin is a is a is the
most stable
highest
form highest value property
in the world right now right so so
trading bitcoin for something else is
trading from the apex property the best
property to an inferior property so i i
can imagine scenarios where i borrowed
against billions of dollars of bitcoin
to buy some other property that i wanted
there are other good properties right
there other there are other things right
i won't dispute that owning the stock of
a great company is not a good thing
i would just say that there's no better
thing than owning pure digital energy on
the dominant crypto asset network so
i wouldn't sell it because that implies
you're trading something for something
better while there is nothing better so
i wouldn't do that yeah and and are you
the i think you're the largest
shareholder of microstrategy still is
that i am i'm the principal shareholder
and i'm the controlling shareholder yeah
i have more than 50 percent of the
voting share and so nevertheless are
there people like on your board as a
public company that
you know are take convincing that of
what you're saying or is it more or less
obvious to everyone
we spent a lot of time getting educated
on the issue before we bought our first
bitcoin
right that was a that was an in-depth
process of education we consulted with
experts
we studied we read the books we
considered the accounting implications
we considered the legal implications we
considered the business implications we
consider the securities implications and
then you know
every every week since then we have
considered every development in the
market and how we feel about it so i i
think the the board takes this very
seriously
but you know clearly it's not like you
would buy billions of dollars of this
and then ask the question to the board
what do you think right
right this is a strategy of the company
it's disclosed in our 10k we have two
principal strategies one strategy is to
acquire and hold bitcoin right
so
so in a publicly traded company you
would have
consensus on the board before you did
something like that and that only comes
with extensive due diligence
how has that part of this disclosed
strategy affected the core product
strategy if at all of the company
it's been good um it's actually improved
the core business the best way to
understand our company is we were a 500
million dollar enterprise software
company growing zero percent a year
before we started this
and we had 500 million dollars in
treasury cash and credit
generating zero percent interest
so we were zero growth and zero interest
when we adopted the bitcoin strategy
we're now a five billion dollar
treasury that's growing at the rate of
bitcoin which traditionally was 130 but
you fell in the blank right so so a high
growth five billion dollar company and
then the 500 million dollar enterprise
software company's been growing between
10 and 13
a year on average for the last few
quarters so so we're now growing the
core business north of 10 and we're
growing the other the balance sheet
business much more aggressively now the
core business benefited because our
brand was
was enhanced by a factor of 100
employee retention was improved
recruiting got easier sales got easier
there's a halo effect morale improved
and of course we've also just been
working hard on the core business to
improve the product the products better
the services are better we digitally
transformed the way we sell and service
and deliver our value proposition so all
those things are working on our
advantage too
yeah so we before we got on i want to
this is awesome congrats i'm not sure
you would have expected that halo effect
on the core business but i'm sure you'll
take it
um and and so let's just jump in the
interest of time to to our probably our
least favorite topic which is uh
regulation so before we got on we were
we were trying to guess how often china
bans bitcoin
uh and and it seems like they're on you
know band number four million five
hundred thousand seven hundred and
thirty four
um
does this matter
you know how how should i i don't think
i don't think it matters
you know like i i was an early
shareholder of facebook i was an early
shareholder of twitter i was an early
shareholder of google
you know if you had dumped the shares of
google facebook and twitter in 2010
because you heard that china was going
to ban it it would have been
you would have lost a lot of money
yeah obscene amounts of money trillions
of dollars have been made
on technologies banned
by china
so i think that what china does is
largely irrelevant here and of course
it's kind of getting to be laughable
because like every quarter for the past
five six seven years there's been a
china banning thing
so i don't really think that's that
relevant i think with regard to bitcoin
if you wouldn't hold it for a decade you
shouldn't hold it for 10 minutes
so i i think
i i think these things aren't good for
speculators i don't think you should but
i don't think you should be a speculator
if you're a normal person i don't you
know if you're a trader maybe traders
love it or hate it i don't know but you
shouldn't be a trader you're either an
investor or you're or you're a saver if
you're a saver you're swapping a weak
currency or a weak property for a strong
property and a strong currency and
that's one way to view bitcoin
macroeconomically
moving toward the strong apex property
and if you're a technologist
you're buying the dominant digital
monetary network
with this view that one year one day
eight billion people will be swapping
energy via mobile phones with a hundred
million companies at the speed of light
you know subject to moore's law with
computer programs thinking very fast
you know so you you would buy it because
you believe in digital property digital
energy digital money
right and you believe in uh and you
believe in the philosophy of an
anti-inflationary asset and if that's
the reason you're doing it then it
doesn't really matter what happens day
by day week by week month by month
ask me again in like four years and i'll
give you an interim check
right but what about the u.s perspective
so now i listen to
a lot of
people in the current administration i
won't pick on any names my impression is
is that if you if a few of them had a
magic wand and they could make this
topic disappear maybe make bitcoin
disappear they might actually do it now
luckily our system doesn't allow for
that
but i think that's what they believe i
don't think i don't see that at all
actually i think that some of the alt
coiners spread that kind of of message
but i
i actually think if you look at every
statement by a central banker
or by regulators they're pretty clear
bitcoin is property
bitcoin is a commodity i'll give you the
exact quote bitcoin
is
uh a digital
scarce
speculative store of value unquote
if you took away the word speculative
and you said bitcoin is a digital scarce
store of value
right then that suggests that all 500
trillion dollars in the world should be
converted to bitcoin overnight
so you have to add the word speculative
in order to actually create any
competition at all
and i don't think there's any debate i
mean christina lagarde said that jerome
powell has said that gary gensler has
said that i think janet yellen has said
that i think the people in congress and
the senate have said that
right so i i haven't seen any regulator
actually debate that bitcoin
is a digital store of value and so it's
speculative that means be careful
and think about it when you buy it
no one's talking about taking away your
ability to hold digital property not in
western europe not in the united states
i think all the regulatory fund
is around is it okay for me to not pay
taxes if i sell a billion dollars a
bitcoin with a 900 million dollar tax
gain
no
is it okay for me to transfer a billion
dollars to someone and not disclose it
and not pay taxes on it no
right i mean
there can can i issue a billion dollars
of yoyo coin
you know
to my friends
and call it a currency and a token in a
commodity and not follow regulatory
disclosure on who owns it the answer is
no right so so i think that this that
the regulations coming to securities and
it's and it's
regulation related to
are you abiding by securities laws are
you abiding by tax laws
and that that kind of compliance will
continue but but digital property in the
form of bitcoin isn't really disputed by
anybody
if you looked at the senate hearings
they had last week there was broad-based
consensus
every single senator their body language
and what they said indicated that
they're supportive of bitcoin and the
crypto industry in general everybody
just wants it to be regulated
appropriately and i think the regulators
have agreed so i'm not really concerned
about that i think i think that the the
narratives in the fight are spread by
traders and
speculators and
you know
it'll be worked out
so we have a by my account upwards of
175 currencies in the world today
um what do you think
happens to those currencies 25 years
from now
i think to be a shakeout
i mean i think that uh you'll be a
you'll see the bottom 150 disappear
really in in 25 years i think there's a
shakeout in the cryptocurrencies right
sure i think i think when gensler
pointed out that 6 000 currencies
they're not all going to last people
were up in arms but the truth is
if you believe that the bottom 150
currencies or 100 currencies going to
disappear why wouldn't you think that
the bottom 4 000 or 5 000
cryptocurrencies are also going to
disappear
sure
that's a very different statement than
saying 150 world currency or or
sovereign currencies will disappear
right
the world doesn't need the weak ones
right the world needs the us dollar
it's clear that the rmb is going to last
the dollar is going to last any a
currency issued by a strong country
that's that's decently managed will last
i mean it's it's common for people to
criticize inflation in the dollar but
you should keep in mind that inflation
of the dollar is nothing compared to
inflation and the bolivar
right
so the venezuelan currencies disappeared
the el salvador currency disappeared
many years ago
right currencies in in lebanon
and syria you know the lebanese currency
had you know a 90 percent collapse in 12
months
so i think that those currencies are
discouraging where's the afghan currency
that's gone that's been gone right right
so i think it goes without saying that
the weak currencies will go away the
world doesn't need
all those currencies the world just
needs a few
and the few it needs it it needs the
dollar
people would people would prefer to buy
things that with the dollar in argentina
venezuela and nigeria you know and syria
and lebanon and every in afghanistan
right if they could they would do that
in a heartbeat and in many cases they
are so the world needs that the world
doesn't need the weak currencies and the
world's going to need the cny because as
long as china controls its own capital
markets and controls its own
uh business and trading zone then its
currency is going to be the dominant
currency in that zone everything else is
going to be
somewhat tied to those two currencies i
think
and and so what about the narrative that
you know i get that the boulevards is
going to zero quickly
but what about the narrative that the
dollar is going to zero slowly
right it doesn't just because we're
we're it's not obvious that it's going
to zero doesn't mean that the way we're
inflating the currency does it make it
worthless over time yeah i i just don't
see it's constructive right i mean i
think people are
they're focused on the wrong thing
the thing that's the the thing to focus
on is that gold is dead and you should
sell all your gold and buy bitcoin the
united states government is not dead the
chinese government is not dead as much
as you dislike saving in in the rmb or
saving in the euro or using the euro or
using the dollar
they're actually quite viable and in
fact they're getting stronger
right i mean you're you're saying well
yeah venezuela's currency might be
diving no it
might it's not it might be diving it's
already gone uh 99 collapse right
so if you're asking a practical question
in venezuela what should you be thinking
right now the answer is you should have
a digital wallet with dollars on it and
bitcoin in it
i say it a different way right for
example you know you could you could you
could harp on how much you don't like
the us dollar to me but microstrategy
uses dollars you know we sell all of our
revenues are in dollars all of our costs
are in dollars we use dollars right and
so
you know when will we stop using dollars
to do business well
not this year not next year
so a much more
a much more practical
thing to focus on is how much working
capital do you need in the local
currency you do business
and then how much treasury capital do
you have so microstrategy had
550 million dollars in capital we put 50
million dollars into usd we put 500
million dollars into btc
and we waited a year and today we have
five billion dollars in btc
50 million dollars in usd
okay so what was constructive
what was constructive was for one person
to convert 500 million dollars from usd
to btc that was easy
what is not destruct constructive for me
to hold my breath and wait for 8 billion
people on the planet to stop using
dollars
right like
that you know changing that
telling all my customers to switch and
telling all my employees to start taking
that's like a billion billion times
harder than the obvious thing and i
think every con everybody on earth is
the same way right everyone's got a
savings account and a checking account
so in your savings account you should
have an asset which which will
appreciate in value against currencies
over time
and that's btc
okay so take all your savings and
convert into btc and your checking
account is a currency that you need to
pay for
your room and your board and your
medical care and in china
that's not the euro that's not the
dollar that's not btc
that's cny
in europe that's you you know e
e you are
right whatever i need to pay my taxes
and pay my medical care and pay my my
day-to-day bills is going to be the
local currency
so
they're not going away
and they say in the us it's going to be
usd now in all the weak countries like
afghanistan and afghanistan it's usd
right and in in venezuela you could
probably pay bills and they prefer you
to be paying usd rather than pay in the
bolivar right
and in in argentina they'd rather get
paid in usd i can tell you that for sure
right not not in the peso so
here's a small idea and here's a big
idea the small idea is
i hold one month worth of working
capital in the local currency the
strongest currency
it's it's not like do you hate on the
dollar the point is your choice is the
dollar the peso or the bolivar
or the you know what's the currency of
afghanistan right now
is there a dollar the point is
so so instead of hating on the dollar
embrace the dollar the dollar is the
strongest of the currencies with which
you can you can uh buy and sell things
with liquidity so i
i i think that the idea is i take my
working capital i put in the strongest
currency i can find that's probably the
dollar
i take my
my savings and i put in the strongest
asset i can find
which is right now bitcoin
and
if you're really
smart
you convert all your money into bitcoin
and then you just borrow against the
bitcoin so
so instead of having 500 million dollars
in bitcoin and 50 million in cash
why don't you borrow 500 million you
have a billion dollars in bitcoin 500
million in debt
and now you could fund all of your
expenses just by borrowing against
the asset forever
and uh and that means that because the
the
portion of your capital which is working
capital sitting in the currency is not
appreciating it's depreciating right
you've made that point right
so
if you're really well-run company you
don't want to carry any working capital
zero working capital right you want
negative working capital
so you can work out the math
if you have a million dollars of of
capital and you uh and you expect
bitcoin to appreciate it 10 a year as
long as your expense ratio is less than
10 percent per year you can borrow money
forever yeah if your expense ratio is
less than the expected appreciation of
the asset you're holding on your
treasury
then you can borrow money forever
never sell anything
and get richer
while you wait
right so question so the wealthy have
been doing this with equities for
decades right they go to their their
prime broker they borrow against their
equity they live off of it or they buy
houses they buy more stock they've been
doing it with sports teams too like the
jets or the patriots they've also been
doing it with buildings
like the rockefeller center or any real
estate or any land so they've been doing
it with any property
forever they just finance the property
and live off of it so the question
becomes how do you think this could
affect or would affect the average
consumer potentially 20 years from now
meaning
does that become the base asset that
everyone holds and then ultimately bars
against to live off of or
is it remember
you remember when people put all their
money in their house and their house
appreciated and then what you would do
is you would take a home equity
liquidity right
i mean this is the quote of a home
equity loan
but let's come back to property if i had
a million dollars in florida
and i bought a house i would owe the
state of florida twenty thousand dollars
a year in tax
okay so that the maintenance cost to
carry a million dollars of property in
florida is 20 000 for the tax then i
have to fix the house when it gets
rained on then i have to replace the
roof right then i have to upgrade it so
you could imagine the maintenance cost
on the house is like five percent
50 000 a year so if you took the same
million and you bought bitcoin with it
your 50 000 a year in maintenance went
to zero
okay where will you see that money come
out it'll come out the other end bill
you'll actually
probably be getting a plus five percent
appreciation because
this is higher form of digital it's a
higher form of property
if i took everything i liked about
property i made it digital i i
dematerialized it and i could get rid of
the property tax load and also get rid
of the maintenance load
on
you know how much cost to mow your lawn
if you have a lot of grass
i i i live in florida i have two acres
three acres i have a full-time person
and all he does is maintain the lawn and
he's not alone
multiple people right so
so if you're trying to store money for a
hundred years as property
you're defeated by the tax and the
maintenance obligations and so you can
still do it by the way uh the property
goes up in value by a factor of 10 and
then you take out your home equity loan
so people have done it
but it would be so much more effective a
technique
if you did it on a no maintenance cost
property
for a bunch of reasons one is bitcoin's
going to appreciate faster
bitcoin is going to get taxed less
bitcoin has lower
tax rate bitcoin doesn't get destroyed
by a hurricane that hits miami
there's no insurance cost right
on on bitcoin
and my house in miami isn't interesting
to rich people in beijing and and moscow
and london and paris
and somebody in the comments wrote no
eminent domain issue either
it doesn't get seized right yeah so so
the i if you were starting out you're
like i think i'm going to basically
buy a a big house and then i can live
off it i can reverse mortgage it as i
get older
well that was a that was your best idea
for 30 years bill
that was the american dream own a house
and your walt is them in the house but
bitcoin is so much better idea so the
answer to your to your question a
long-winded way is
yeah
you should put your discretionary wealth
into digital property
you can keep it the rest of your life
and if you're smart you can live off of
either the yield from it or the
borrowing or the reverse mortgage
against it
and you have every reason to think that
that property will appreciate in value
one one more point i didn't make
people keep making if you buy a house if
you buy a a house in florida you're
better off to buy the house on three
acres than you are to buy the condo on
the 37th floor of a condominium because
people can punch up more buildings with
a hundred floors in miami but it's hard
to create three more acres in miami so
if you are buying property your property
is not scarce
right uh tangible property in the real
world is not scarce as much as you wish
it was scarce apartments with views of
central park still aren't scarce when
they punch up another apartment building
next to yours but bitcoin is 21 million
blocks in cyberspace
so it's a lot better idea than buying a
tangible land
or buying a condo or buying a house
it's even better than buying a sports
team right i mean people you the people
might they might build some more
franchises or people might get into
twitch gaming online and stop going to
football games so
if you're looking for scarce property
that's fungible that's digital that's
low maintenance that's transferable that
can be developed
well bitcoin is that best property in
the history of humanity
so
everybody should have a property
strategy you should buy property you
should hold it forever
and ultimately
it's a lot better idea to borrow against
it
than it is to sell it because when you
sell it you re you get a capital gains
bill
which is going up we know that's going
up a lot right we're going to debate how
much when you generate yield on it you
still actually owe you owe
tax on the operating income from the
yield so yield is taxable
sales are taxable
borrowings are not taxable so when i
borrow money
if i borrow five percent of my asset
value every year for the next hundred
years and if the asset goes up ten
percent a year for the next hundred
years
i'm going to be obscenely rich and my my
grandchildren's grandchildren will be
obscenely rich
having never incurred a tax bill
yep and and you i never could have said
that with a straight face about any
other investment idea in my life
but this is the first time where really
it is it is it is quite reasonable to
think that in year 2140
you know when that last block is mined
and the mining network goes to
transaction fees bitcoin's going to be
stronger than ever
and
you're you're only going to regret
having sold
it what happens in 500 years when
bitcoin is worth 28 million dollars a
coin or 280 million a coin and you're
reading in your family history that your
great great great great great great
great great great grandparents
sold some to buy a lambo
you're going to be like i could have
been the richest person in my city i
want to kill them right well they're
going to go what the a lambo it's
going to be the first question
and and second question is why what you
know what what drugs were they on yeah
right
so uh el salvador uh slash twitter kind
of interrelated uh you saw the news
yesterday that twitter is now gonna
basically allow i guess they call it
tipping
uh using the lightning network
did you i assume you saw that
yeah um
i mean they're both bullish like el
salvador drags uh a million people in a
couple of weeks to set up bitcoin
wallets and lightning wallets a great
thing and familiar familiarizes them and
so that's a killer application that
drives
network adoption 100
and twitter is another killer
application driving network adoption
and uh you know i i
i set up uh
that tipping function today i had to
turn it off because i don't really want
people's tips but
but i set it up it took me 15 seconds
to try it out 15 seconds i mean if
you've got strike loaded on your mobile
phone all you got to do
is type in your strike username and it
turns on it was like magic
so i'm very bullish on that
in general i i think that
the the the thing that people don't get
often times is the technical promise of
digital energy
if i can actually move digital money or
digital energy on twitter then why can't
i move it on facebook on why can't i
move it on google
and
there are killer applications tipping is
a nice application the killer
application is is i just post a hundred
thousand satoshi's as a security deposit
against good behavior
like like would you let me move into
your home for the summer without posting
a security deposit
you know probably not so if you actually
just let people post a small cyber
security deposit billions and billions
of people would all download lightning
wallets plug it into google facebook
apple amazon twitter yelp
you ever read a yelp review or whatever
you're like is that a person you ever
read something on youtube you think is
that really a person or is it a bot
so i i think that
i think that the massive mega
applications are going to be when tech
companies plug lightning into their
mobile app the snapchats
i i can't read an instagram dm
bill because it's 18 000
bots that all say hi to me that have
zero followers that want to be my friend
okay
i can't read my twitter dms other than
from people i follow
because it's all spam from bots that
would like me to buy yoyo coin or talk
about you know doofus something or other
and they're not even real people right
right and so we need to clean up
cyberspace
and the way to clean up cyberspace is
with skin in the game
and the way to deliver skin in the game
is bitcoin on lightning rails
and when that comes
hundreds and hundreds of millions of
people
are gonna realize that they need this
stuff and and that's gonna be a sea
change
yeah fantastic
all right so i've kept you for 50
minutes and
as always uh focusing on on getting
every word from you is is mentally
exhausting uh but in a good way so i
appreciate that thank you very much
um by the way the comments have just
been off the charts while we've been
while we've been talking so i've
integrated some of the questions as i
could into the conversation so you
should know that uh a lot of people have
been really interested in what we've
been discussing so
thanks for that any any party thoughts
that you want to want to share anything
we didn't talk about
i i think everything that's happening
right now it's just really bullish for a
bitcoin
and i
i think that um that the stuff with
bitcoin and lightning if i was an
entrepreneur right now if i if you were
asking me how do you fix your p l or how
do you how do you make your product or
your service insanely cool
i would be focused upon
you know plugging lightning into mobile
apps and plugging lightning into
products and i think that that most
people haven't really grasped their head
around the idea of how i move digital
energy at the speed of light
you know a million times a second and
how it fixes
snapchat and fixes youtube and fixes
yelp and fixes amazon and fixes google
and fixes what's up and fixes and
eliminates scammers and spammers an
imposter
i mean that that that is a
mega big idea and
you saw a little inkling of it
when you saw um
you saw strike plug into twitter well
what does that mean it means like
millions and millions of people are
going to want to get a strike account
right so if you actually create
something and you wanted millions or
tens of millions or hundreds of millions
of people to download your app plug it
into something else to solve a
fundamental problem like cyber security
or communications
and i think that's enormously exciting
and we have scratched the surface like
0.1
of the opportunity there a lot
the reason that like i say let's not
let's stop harping on the dollar versus
bitcoin is
is people are fixated upon the dollar
and i i wish i didn't have to pay taxes
and i just hate the dollar i hate
inflation and that's not constructive
what's constructive is
oh my i could pretty much eliminate all
scams
i could eliminate all spam
you know like that means like this is
killer app for microsoft
right
everything in my inbox is spam right so
so bitcoin and lightning is a killer app
for microsoft google facebook amazon
apple twitter every mobile company every
internet company if you're trying to
figure out how to grow something or do
something i would be going to school on
that thinking long and hard because
hundreds of billions of dollars if not
trillions of dollars of technology
wealth
will be created by people that figure
out how to plug bitcoin
via you know either via protocols like
lightning
or you know just go direct as a layer 3
application yep like you guys are doing
at abra
or layer three applications like you
know uh square cache app or
something although the layer threes will
eventually have the layer two the
lightning plugged in the back end of it
absolutely right and and we're seeing
i can't overestimate that i mean i can't
over emphasize
this is really important
and it's underappreciated
and it's a it's an open green field for
anybody that wants to aggressively
pursue it yeah well i think we should
play back that last part in a year
but apple and facebook and google and
and come back and see
uh what's changed in a year right i mean
people i think people forget it's it's
barely been a year since you guys even
started buying right i mean it's
incredible what's happened in the last
18 months and we haven't really seen
kind of the fang adoption at all but we
not kind of we haven't seen bank
adoption at all and i think it's coming
and i think it's coming in in a big big
way
um
yeah if you're if you're looking for the
key catalyst right one catalyst will be
the etfs will be a big catalyst another
catalyst to be lightning adoption on the
big tech networks and bitcoin adoption
on the big tech networks but especially
by lightning your third catalyst would
be potentially this accounting thing
i totally agree yeah big one
michael thank you so much uh really
awesome uh to have you with us on money
talks and i hope you'll come back
uh on a regular basis and fill us in on
what's going on in in your world and and
and keep answering our questions you a
great steward of the bitcoin community
and we're really lucky to have you so
thank you always happy to be here i look
forward to the next one all right thanks
amigo
take care
all right thanks to michael wow uh it's
always exhausting you know michael i
have a lot of one-on-one conversations
and every time every time we do i i
think i sleep for 12 hours the next day
so
um he's he's brilliant but you have to
hang on every word and so uh makes it
like like charles charles cardona from a
few weeks ago he's brilliant guys you
want to hang on every word
um
and uh yeah so but uh always always
interesting and we had some interesting
nuggets and things that i hadn't heard
him talk about before
um i think the accounting thing might be
a little boring for some of you but
don't underestimate its importance
uh just to kind of summarize that point
if you basically hold bitcoin on your
balance sheet as a company you have to
show the losses but you can't show the
gains right and so
and and that's my kind of layman's
explanation and we actually hold bitcoin
on our balance sheet at abram we're you
know still relatively small company
compared to microstrategy but but it's a
huge part of our balance sheet and and
you know as a private company the the
issue is less important but but it's
going to become a big issue if uh the
accounting standards board doesn't
address this issue and i think they will
it's just common sense
okay so normally we get into charts uh
and some other things i'll i'll take two
minutes and fill you all in on what's
going on i know many of you just joined
for michael but i'm going to
give you a little screen share here to
talk about
crypto
prices
so we'll go to
uh the the bitcoin chart right now let
me reload this
um
okay so
luckily we we bounced a little bit off
some lows we obviously tanked
on the china news
the china news the renews i don't know
what you want to call it uh but of
basically you know china banning bitcoin
for the umpteenth time
i'm not gonna say it's bullish or
bearish it just is
look i mean we've had all these things
coming at us in the bitcoin world for
the last six months
china banning mining you know elon's fud
um you know this new uh ban you know
congress and the sec talking about
crypto and yet bitcoin is at 42 000. uh
ethereum's right is hovering right
around 3 000. i think we're at 2900
right now so look um this is not a
technical analysis show as i always say
but the fact that you know we're not
down here you know i should say really
you know down here in in the doldrums uh
is actually pretty cool um and and to me
shows a lot of resilience
and you know i the on-chain kind of
fundamentals
show a much more bullish story even than
what we're seeing right now i mean i'll
go back to the daily here for a second
make it easier to read and let me zoom
out a little bit to make it easier right
so we've recovered see the red chart the
red bar has actually gone up from its
lows of about
forty thousand seven hundred up to about
forty two thousand three hundred but
more importantly
this rubber band seems to be winding up
here and looking for a dramatic move
higher and the on-chain analysis
basically says
large holders steady hands are continue
to accumulate bitcoin and ethereum uh at
a very healthy clip
um and and the on-chain analysis is
bullish no no denying that this week's
price action is bearish uh and the two
were in conflict and price wins in the
short term uh but in the long term as we
say in plumbing water seeks its level
and right now that level seems to be in
the high 50s at a minimum so
i think i think a breakout is coming i
could be wrong we could even test you
know 30 000 before then i don't think so
but it's possible i think the lows are
in now uh we'll see what happens i'm not
a technical technical analyst i just buy
and hold like i hope you all do as well
okay so um i'm exhausted you're probably
tired of listening and this was an
awesome show thank you again to
michael saylor for joining us
and i will stop the share here thanks to
our our producer for doing a great job
today and as always stay safe stay
healthy and we will see you next week on
money talks thanks everyone take care