ICR Conference 2025 - CEO Reception with Michael Saylor & Morgan Brennan
ICR · 2025-01-23 · 1h 02m · View on YouTube →
I'm uh I'm Tom Ryan I'm uh one of the
co-founders and CEO of icr hold your
applause until the end no I'm kidding uh
thanks for being here it's 20 20 uh 27
years of doing this conference uh it's
become uh such a big and cool event and
kind of a must-attend uh thing every
year we appreciate everybody's support
particularly all our
sponsors uh we're very lucky that
Michael saor agreed to uh to come here
and speak to us today I know a lot of
you were in meetings and may have missed
his keynote at noon today super
fascinating it'll be up on YouTube
probably with within uh 48 hours in case
you missed it there were I don't know a
100 slides really making a incredible
argument uh for the Bitcoin standard uh
today we also have another friend of icr
Morgan Brennan of CNBC I don't have her
bio to read but she's been a great
friend uh moderated the panel with uh or
a fireside chat with Jared Jared
isaacman last year the shift for uh
payment founder and uh oh by the way the
commander of the SpaceX Fleet so that
was cool but uh would' love to bring
Morgan and uh Michael up here and uh
we'll hand it over to them at this point
thank you so much
[Applause]
you I think I am maybe on this side
looking at my
mic so it's an honor and priv privilege
to be here tonight and it's great to be
in this room and and Michael it's great
to be here on stage with you Michael
sailor the founder and chairman of micro
strategy and one of the most I would say
extraordinary and Fascinating People
in Tech and finance today given the
strategy you have laid out and what that
has meant in terms of returns for micro
strategy and the message you are now
carrying to the rest of corporate
America so maybe we'll start there
because you did give a presentation
earlier today and it was standing room
only uh and it was a message for CEOs
and companies given what you have been
doing in terms of adopting Bitcoin at
micro
strategy yeah I think um I won't rehash
uh the presentation at lunch uh but what
I'll say if I was called into a
boardroom and I go into a lot of
boardrooms and I talk to a lot of CEOs
and they wonder you know H how can we
create shareholder value my my message
is and this is the Mega big
idea 60,000 publicly traded companies
are capitalized on the US dollar or or a
a dollar uh currency a dollar Peg
currency like the Euro or the JPY and
their Capital asset is a sovereign Bond
it's like a treasury bill short dated
and that has been the status quo for
about a hundred years certainly since
1940 uh if you want a capital asset for
a company it needs to be a liquid
fungible uh
commodity I mean that's long-term store
value money if you will and so that's
treasury bills and the SEC 40 Act
it basically said it regulated the
amount of Securities that a public
company can hold uh no more than 40% of
your liquid assets and when that
happened that meant that everybody in
the public market was stampeded into
holding
treasuries and treasuries generally
yield 3 to 5% returns 3% after tax the
cost of capital that we've all been
taught is the S&P 500 Index and if your
company if your stock is appreciating
faster than the S&P index you can
declare yourself to be Victorious and if
you have an equity and you're
underperforming the S&P index you know
you're normally thought to be wanting
and and I I've been public company CEO
for 30 years or no since 1998 I was and
my investors would say it very simply to
me they'd sayl if you can't beat the S&P
give us the money back
because a brainless investor can take
the money and buy the S&P index and they
can do that that is the hurdle rate and
it doesn't take a rocket scientist to
figure out that if you're buying t-
bills and you're getting 3% after tax
and if the hurdle rate is 12% you're
underperforming by 9% that means holding
a billion dollars of capital you burn 90
million a year holding a 100 billion in
capital You' earn n billion a year in
shareholder value
and so the big idea here is that the in
the year
2024 the SEC approved the first digital
commodity in the history of the world
Bitcoin and fair value accounting became
optional and in January of
2025 this month fair value accounting
for that digital commodity became
mandatory and we
expect uh in the first week of the Trump
Administration for Sab 121 to be
repealed and that means that every major
Bank in the world will be allowed to
handle to bank Bitcoin so what you have
is a status quo for 80 years where a
corporation could have all of their
Assets in real estate in gold in
soybeans and oil or in treasuries but of
course the only thing that looks liquid
and fungible is treasuries and it
doesn't beat the cost of capital capital
and now Satoshi invents this new digital
commodity it takes 15 years for people
to decide that it isn't tulip bulbs it
takes many years for the government to
embrace it and in the year 2025 is
probably the first year where you could
reasonably say the banks will probably
handle it the government's not going to
ban it and it really is a commodity and
so now if you run a publicly traded
company you have a choice between
Bitcoin or
bonds and the bonds are minus 10% real
yield and the Bitcoin is plus 45% real
yield for the past eight
years and you know you might not be sure
that you're going to keep getting plus
45% real yield but I would submit to you
that even if bitcoin's returns collapse
to the S&P index and if you said it's
just as good as the
SNP having a commodity that perform
forms like the SNP is 10% better than
using a bond and so the real revolution
in corporate finance for a CEO uh is you
have the opportunity to recapitalize a
company on a BTC standard instead of a
USD
standard and what that means physically
is you go
from uh from being negatively polarized
to Capital to being positively polarized
to Capital instead of being repulsive to
Capital you're attractive wouldn't you
like to walk into our meetings and be
attractive instead of being repulsive
when you walk in the meeting and and
what that means to micro strategy is we
just stumbled on this we we discovered
this we weren't trying to discover it we
were in the middle of the lockdowns and
we were kind of irritated frustrated
desperate and so we had 500 million of
capital with zero return and we thought
we got to invest in something should we
buy gold should we buy art should we buy
real estate should we buy diamonds or
should we buy crypto gold and we thought
well we'll buy some crypto gold called
Bitcoin and we
inadvertently recapitalized to the BTC
standard and then of course if the thing
if your capital is returning more than
the S&P 500 you're creating shareholder
value how much Capital can you gather
like if I if you I'm a hedge fund and I
say I return consistently twice the S&P
500 how much do you want to invest in me
the answer is how much money do you want
and if I go to you and I say I'm a hedge
fund and I consistently underp the S&P
by 50% how much Capital you want to
invest in me none you're either
magnetically attracting the capital or
you're rejecting it so micro strategy
stumbled on a new idea recapitalize on
an asset which is a creative not deluded
and when we did that
we started attracting more Capital we
went from having 500 million of cash
non-performing like a liability to
having 45 billion worth of bitcoin going
up 60% a year and we went from a $600
million Enterprise Value to a hundred
billion doll Enterprise Value and we
went from not being able to borrow any
money to borrowing 7 billion dollars for
almost
nothing and we went from not being able
to sell we couldn't have sold the entire
company for $10 a share we couldn't have
sold it for a billion dollars or
whatever to being able to sell $18
billion of
equity at you know 30X the price and and
what's happening it's we simply change
the polarity of the balance sheet and I
think that's the exciting opportunity
for a public company or any any
financeable company any company that can
raise equity or debt financing has a use
of
proceeds which is
transparent high-speed accretive and
scalable and you didn't have it four
years ago you didn't have it 10 years
ago you never had it for a hundred years
all Corporate Finance textbooks every
course at Harvard they're all built on a
on a a US dollar treasury standard in
the absence of a crypto capital Network
and I think now you have to rethink
Corporate Finance you have to rethink
everything you just said so much that I
want to that I want to like dig into I'm
going you know what I was really
enjoying the fact that I would never
ever get to say that on CNBC I would
have been cut off oh yeah 30 minutes
ago that was the most you ever listened
to anybody say anything isn't it
probably I mean on TV but no this is
what I always love about these types of
formats is you can understand you can
really you know dig in and have and and
have a a nuanced contextualized
conversation there's a lot you just said
I'm going to I'm going to take it back
to something and at the risk of being
basic here but I can't tell you at least
once a week and I find with some of the
people who are considered some of the
smartest people in the room I find
myself in conversations with seite with
you know with Finance people with others
and they say well why is it not tulips
2. know and and I don't get Bitcoin and
how a digital commodity can be a store
of value so I just want to I just want
to take a step back and and get a sense
from you of why of why it's not tulips
2.0 and how you came to that conclusion
back in
2020 um you know I I think if you could
build it you could build it from first
principles you said okay I got 100 Rich
families they live in uh 47 countries
and um they all have this thought that
they don't really trust their Banks and
they don't really trust their
governments and they don't trust the
currency and they're they're okay in
their country for now but they might
need to leave their country sometime in
the next 30 Years and so they come
together and they think uh where should
we put our money okay like the big idea
is we want to keep our money okay and so
you know as I said if God came down and
said I'll run the bank for you and I'm
going to issue you God coin there's
going to be 21 million of them and then
you can telepathically move them between
each other and I will custody God coin
for the next million years for free for
you then all these rich people would put
their money in God's bank and they would
use the god coin and it would it would
uh serve as a store of value for them
because it's better than gold it's
better than diamonds it's better than
buying Picasso artworks it's better than
buying the local Bond you know in
whatever local African country you live
in ETC but God hasn't chosen to do that
so the next best thing is maybe they
decide to hire a computer programmer and
they get some Cipher Punk or some some
engineer and they say can you actually
program a digital bank that uh does the
same thing so it's not going to be God
coin it's going to be Bitcoin and we
want you to set it up so that we can buy
you know so you've got 21 million of
these uh
units and uh we're going to put our
money in the Bitcoin bank and uh and
that way we don't trust any other bank
and any other government and it's just a
it's a network that we all join a secure
monetary Network and then at some point
one of them says well I don't think I
trust you and so none of the hundred
families trust each other and maybe even
if they did they don't trust their idiot
grandsons that will come along in 60
years so the question is how do you
actually create the Bitcoin Network or
the Bitcoin Bank such that that uh it is
stable it'll go on for hundreds of years
when no one trusts anybody what's the
solution and the answer is we create a
version of the software and we give it
to everybody and all everybody on the
network gets to run the software and the
software checks everybody else's
software and anybody that ends up lying
gets kicked off the network so every
every single family runs a version of
the bank and maybe every person in in
the family runs a version of the bank
and that's how we get to a decentralized
network pretty soon everybody with money
on the network is running the software
now how do you secure it well we we need
somehow to give it some some anchor in
the real world so the software we run
turns electricity into hashes and the
hashes are used to are used to randomize
the trans transactions on the network
and if you end up with billions and
trillions and hundreds of quadrillions
of hashes pretty soon nobody knows who's
going to build the next uh the next
transaction block but what you do know
is that it's impossible for you to hack
the thing with any slight of hand and so
so why is it not tulips it's not tulips
because all of the smart money in the
world wanted to solve this problem why
why wouldn't you right like for a
thousand years people have wanted to
keep their money it's like the theme of
human history people want to keep their
money so they want to solve the problem
this is a this is a crypto solution to
the problem I create a bank in
cyberspace to keep my money and then it
gets copied 100,000 times and the first
50 times it fails and then eventually
someone has a good one and we called the
good one the the one that won was the
one that won right I mean why did you
win and why did everybody else lose
someone had to win there had to be one
Google there had to be one Microsoft why
are we speaking English why aren't we
speaking French we had there had to be a
winning language and why do we use the
US dollar because there was a winner
right so at the end of the day the idea
is simple it's a decentralized network
protocol to keep your money without
depending upon a government or a
corporation or without relying on
anybody right it's a protocol for
economic Integrity it's obviously a good
idea you can duplicate a million times
just like you can copy Wikipedia a
million times but there's there's got to
be one winning Network and the winning
network is the one where all the smart
people with the money join it's just
like you know if everybody puts their
money in JP Morgan and you have yo-yo
bank which is cheaper but all the rich
people have their money in JP Morgan
it's probably safer to put your money in
the bank with all the rich people why I
copied New York City in Kansas why don't
people move there well they can they
they can either go to New York or they
can go to Kansas York and they just went
to New York there's a lot of reasons why
and so Bitcoin is the most powerful
crypto Network in the world it's got all
the computer power it's got all the
economic power it's got all the
political power it's got all the
electrical power is it not tulip bulbs
it's 20 nuclear reactors where of
electricity right that's how it's not
tulip bulbs and um and and another way
to say it though it it it is basically
it is a monetary
Union if you join a union and a million
other workers join the union and all of
you get together and collectively
negotiate your salary and your salaries
go up by 50% and some guy writes an
article saying isn't that tulips what is
no it's there's a million people we all
join together to protect our own
interests how about a million person
Army I got an Army in front of you we
have guns you disagree with me you could
say it's not an army but there's the
Army right so Bitcoin is in essence it's
a it's a monetary Network and it Formed
organically through a competitive
process and every weaker idea or
inferior idea failed in the marketplace
of ideas and the ultimate you know the
ultimate endorsement of a monetary
network is somebody with a billion
dollars willing to put their money into
the monetary Network and if they are
then is someone else with more money
willing to support another Network and
the answer is all the money chose this
one and that's why it's not tulips it
it's just the
network so what does we're a week out
from inauguration what does a trump
Administration mean for this how much
hinges on the Fiat piece of this and the
fact that you have a dollar that is
devaluing you have a$ 37 trillion debt
load here in the US and I know I've had
these conversations with Bankers for
example that you know Bitcoin is from
that standpoint or a geopolitical
standpoint it it's about hedging your
bets in that
world you know I I mean there's a lot of
narrative some people some people would
say the reason you want Bitcoin is
because the currency is being debased
and and that's definitely true if you
live in Lebanon or you live in Venezuela
or you live in Africa it's when the
currency collapses in five years or 10
years years then obviously you want the
Bitcoin but there's another reason the
Bitcoin price goes up and the other
reason the price goes up is because it's
digital and that just means that at the
end of the day uh if I can move a
billion dollars from New York to Tokyo
and back
again every hour every
second every millisecond there there's
utility in that there you know digital
books digital education is is a million
times faster cheaper lighter than the
real thing and so so the digital form of
capital is valuable even if you ran the
country perfectly and there was no
inflation but you could still program
the money to move at the speed of light
247 365 and put a AI That's a billion
times smarter than me or you in charge
there would still be utility for that
and then the the third reason it's going
up is Bitcoin represents digital capital
or capital in cyberspace I give you a
billion dollars and I tell you buy stuff
in in Russia and so you buy a bunch of
stuff in Russia you know and then what
the the Russian government perfectly
operates in every way and then you stop
the passage of time and nothing ever
decays or grows old and then I guess
it's almost as good but not digital but
the point is the passage of time
continues you know governments don't run
efficiently the mayor may not do what
you expected stuff rust there's a
hurricane there's a fire all of those
things are entropy and Chaos in the real
world so it's my long- winded way of
saying Bitcoin is valuable because you
escape the entropy and Chaos of the real
world Bitcoin is valuable because it's a
million times faster smarter cheaper
because it's digital and Bitcoin is
valuable because nobody can debase it
and you only have to believe one of
those three things to think it's going
up forever but of course I think all of
those things it's it's just a better
idea and it's going to continue to
appreciate in price at with the passage
of time with the Improvement of
technology and uh and with the
debasement of the currency all three of
which we can
expect um it goes up it's been going up
dramatically for the last couple of
years but not without dramatic fall and
retracements along the way we're seeing
one of those right now after it
crossed uh 100K a couple of weeks ago
Vol it's volatile it's a volatile asset
so in terms of strapping your seat Bel
in and going along for the ride what
does that look like especially and I'll
ask you because you're buying a heck of
a lot of Bitcoin and micro strategy
moves with the price of Bitcoin well so
first I would
say volatility can be viewed as a
feature or above
if I give you um a billion dollars on
your balance sheet and you have it in
bonds the volatility is the Vol is five
it's like putting a billion dollar
weight in your backyard is not going
anywhere it's sculpture but if I fashion
that sculpture into a flywheel and I
spin it at 60 RPM or 60 Vol it's now a
turbine and you could imagine if you're
spinning uh you know a very heavy a 10
ton weight at 60 UH 60 RPM you can plug
a machine into it you can actually power
you know a factory or power a company or
power a city with it and so volatility
is
energy and uh with micro strategy we
actually run the company to create the
volatility so we have $5 billion dollars
of Bitcoin and we're spending at 90 Vol
you know then we get a hundred billion
doll options Market that forms and the
result is it creates so much suction so
much energy there are people that own my
stock that don't know what we do that
don't know what Bitcoin is that don't
care all they care about is I can sell
the volatility I bought the micro
strategy thing I'm getting 150% interest
on it whatever it is if it doesn't go to
zero in the next three months I'm
getting rich like that that's the power
but you know that's not unlike I spin a
fan 60 RPM and I blow you off the deck
you know of the ship right there's
energy in these things it's a turbine so
I I think volatility can be harnessed I
would say if you're an
investor the right way if you look at it
is it's for long-term capital
preservation so if you have portfolio of
capital you don't need for four years or
more like ideally for 10 years then the
portion of your Capital that you would
hold for 10 years and invest you put
some of that into Bitcoin you'll be fine
if I don't think you should put Capital
you need for four days four weeks and
four months you shouldn't use it's not a
working capital thing it'll give you a
coronary and a heart attack that doesn't
make sense but what my last you know I
got two other points one is it's
volatile because it's the most useful
thing in the world it's because if you
need 10 billion doll of credit on
Saturday night to short the market you
can get it from the Bitcoin Network you
can't get it from any of your other
assets if you needed to sell something
for a billion dollars in five minutes
you can get it from Bitcoin you cannot
sell anything else on a Sunday morning
in 5 minutes if on the other hand you
wanted to take a long position on Sunday
morning after someone else took a short
position Saturday night you can do that
with Bitcoin you cannot do that with
nearly any other asset so it is useful
financially and that makes it volatile
because anybody can express uh an
economic opinion as hard as they want
anywhere in the world and everything is
linked to everything and uh my last
point it's going up 60% a year for the
past eight years if it was going up 60%
a year in a perfect exponential with the
beautiful curve that you drew with your
artist Hand if that's the way it happen
then people stupider than you richer
than you would have all the money
right the the if you know if I'm telling
you it's going up 60% and if you do the
work and you can understand why
thermodynamically it is like why is the
water flowing downhill why does the
waterfall look that way because there's
gravity and the gravity is pulling it
down here why are people running from
insecure assets to secure assets you
know why do why does Capital flow from
one place to another place why why would
you sell your venage in currency and buy
dollars was that random or is there a
reason right if you understand the
fundamental thermodynamic physical
reason why the capital is Flowing from
20th century assets to 21st century
assets from physical to digital from
Financial to digital if you understand
that then the best thing that could
happen to you is for it to appreciate in
a volatile fashion because everybody
else will be scared away from it the 60%
a year is still 60% whether it's vol
volatile or not the difference is
because it's volatile micro strategy is
able to go from a billion dollar market
cap to $100 billion market cap because
people are afraid to do what we're doing
if it wasn't volatile Bill Gates and
Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger would
have bought it all and I wouldn't be
sitting on stage today right now you
would be you would be listening to
Masters of the Universe that were famous
long before I came along telling you how
they bought the Bitcoin and how smart
they are and you would be like well of
course we all bought the Bitcoin because
it's because if it's not if it just goes
up perfectly forever then like where's
the opportunity in it for the committed
right for the convicted for the people
that want to do the work so I kind of
feel like there there's a certain
natural selection to this if you like
money if you need the money if you're
willing to take risk and and you're
willing to bleed to get the money then
Bitcoin will give you the money right
right but those are the people that
deserve it if you're just rich and
arrogant and you only take risk-free
Investments and you just expect to stay
Rich then you know you really want to
help them do do they need help right I
mean is that I don't think so so so I
think the volatility is a feature that's
a benefit to an investor it's a benefit
to a corporation it's a natural
characteristic of a life
form it's alive it's V vital it's
volatile I don't I think that there are
two big ideas in corporate finance that
are traditional Morgan one volatility is
a bug and I think it know volatility is
a feature and two and I'm going to say
this in a hyperbolic way but to make the
point I think conventional Corporate
Finance treats Capital as its
toxic like it's it's it's capital is
toxic to the corporation and I think
capital is
virtuous right what Rich family would
give away all their
money right but but every rich company
does right Apple does Microsoft does
Nvidia does meta does they all brag
about the doing of it they all brag
about their BuyBacks they all brag about
their dividends it's like they're
literally getting rid of their Capital
as fast as they can and you know why
would a all these people that you're
invested in you think are so smart if
they're so smart why are they desperate
to get rid of the
money and the answer is the capital
asset they use is toxic to them if if I
give you a billion dollars and you
invested in bonds that have a negative
real yield of minus 10% then you're
destroying a 100 million a year so if
they're smart and they know that they
know they have to get rid of the the
capital they have to flush it out of the
system as fast as possible and I think
that there's a new there's a new idea
the new idea is Adopt a different
Capital asset called Bitcoin and you get
to keep the money and now capital is not
toxic now capital is life affirming now
instead of blowing away a hundred
billion dollars of capital now you could
keep the 100 billion of capital and it
grows 30 40% a year and pretty soon
you've got 500 billion of capital and
your shareholders get rich that's the
big
idea it's a big idea you actually made
this it it is and I and I I say this
knowing micro strategy is outperformed
these other companies the mag 7
companies other asset classes since you
adopted a Bitcoin strategy pretty
dramatically um you made this pitch to
Microsoft speaking of a couple of months
ago Microsoft turned around and said to
shareholders uh vote this down
shareholders did vote this down so what
does it what does it take to get some of
these other big companies with big
balance sheets and a lot of cash sitting
there that are doing this C you know
that are handing their Capital away to
get on board with what with what you're
pitching bigcoin is on a need to know
basis if you don't need to
know then you won't ever figure it out
so Microsoft is arguably right Microsoft
is one of the seven greatest companies
in the world maybe it's the greatest
company in the world but you know some
people might think it's the one the
first or the second or the third so if
you run the greatest company in the
world and you're a shareholder in the
greatest company in the world arguably
you don't need to know anything you
don't need to take any risk the
companies that are going to embrace
Bitcoin are the ones
that the ones that uh aren't Microsoft
when you get to the point where you
realize you can't compete against
Microsoft when you're not the digital
Monopoly when you're one of the 27,000
retailers that got crushed underfoot by
Amazon right when you're one of the
47,000 media companies is getting beat
to death by Google or by meta you know
when when you look at your stock and
it's been stuck in a rut for a decade
right if you're the CEO or the CFO of
that company and you and you ask
yourself honestly am I going to be able
to outperform Nvidia or outperform
Google or outperform Apple do I have a
monopoly on a billion people do I or not
if you don't have a if you have a
monopoly you're getting regulated if you
have a digital Monopoly that's
unregulated you can actually outperform
until you get
regulated the companies that are
embracing Bitcoin are the ones that that
they're the zombie companies where
there's like I'm public but I'm stuck in
a rut the likelihood that I'm going to
start to grow organically 20% every year
for the next decade is like less than
1% right once you get to the point where
you know you your odds of actually you
know growing organically 20% a year for
the next 10 years or less than 1% then
you're uh then at least at that point
you need to invite uh or consider a new
idea and I think normally what what
happens is when a company hits that
wall they decide to sell thems right
that's one exit I just sell the company
I had 100 competitors Morgan every one
of them sold themself over the course of
20 years everyone so you sell yourself
if you can't sell yourself your next
idea is lbo I'm going to take myself
private I'm going to basically here's
the big idea I have a low Growth Company
growing 5% but if I can borrow money
cheap capital and lever up then I can
actually make my low Growth Company look
like a high growth Equity who does that
Apple's been doing that for five years
right borrow money buy the stock back
lever up the equity so sometimes they go
and do an lbo
third uh they work themselves to death
until they have a heart attack you know
in frustration I mean like how I think I
tried 25 different things to to break
out of a rut before I discovered Bitcoin
I bought the stock back I spent money on
marketing I vented 20 products and it's
just like hitting your head against the
wall so sometimes they do that and they
just give up and they retire and
dejection and now and now you've got
this uh fourth idea uh adopt digital
Capital right re you know recapitalize
your company invert your balance sheet
right that's the that's the new
opportunity I think in the history you
know bitcoin's a paradigm shift and if
you study Paradigm shifts you know
Thomas cun he says he says people only
Embrace new paradigms when there's a
war right or when they die right like
science advances one funeral at a time
right one of the famous
quotes it's like so in this particular
case who gets crypto who gets Bitcoin
the 20s
somethings 20-some person you know a
20-some business person they have no
money they have no hope they're not
going to get ahead the way their father
or their or their grandparents did right
and so you're you're a teenager a
20-some or 30-some you're like streaming
YouTube crypto something they have
everything in the gain nothing to lose
and then and then you have people that
are caught up in a war whether it's the
co war or the lockdown or you know guess
what my my bank just stole all my money
in Lebanon or a
meltdown uh those are the companies that
will flip
first the vote by the way at Microsoft
was uh
99.5% you know against 50 basis points
in favor of
the The Proposal was investigate
Bitcoin that was the research Bitcoin
and management recommended they wouldn't
and it was 50 basis points voted in
favor and I think it's just
demonstrative of the point that you know
if You' got a great company and happy
shareholders people don't
change but that's okay right because
because Rich successful people that
don't need need money don't have any
need to reconsider the monetary
proposition right Bitcoin is money for
people that need it it's not money for
people that have too much of it already
or already have a way to get it so so
there's a natural selection here and
there's a certain Elegance to the entire
process by which this idea spreads I
could keep going with you but it's about
6:45 and what I want I do want to do is
open this up to the room and see if we
have any questions or comments from the
floor yeah people bring up Quantum
Computing every two years they were
thinking about it in 2010 2014 2012 2018
2020 uh the latest is is Google
announced a Quantum proof of concept and
that put it back in people's Minds again
uh Google's quantum computer doesn't
have a practical application all of the
engineers that I know of in the space
think we're 10 to 20 years out before
we've got a computer that we've got to
consider that might be able to crack
modern
encryption when we do have a computer
that can crack modern encryption then
it's got to be addressed by Microsoft
Apple Google the government every Bank
you know and it and Bitcoin will be the
last thing to crack because it has the
strong EST cryptographic security but
the way you should think about it is
right now it's fud in a decade to two
decades it might be real if it if there
ever is enough computer power to
threaten modern encryption protocols
everybody's going to upgrade their
encryption
protocols the most important thing
they're saying about Bitcoin is Bitcoin
is not a system it's a protocol it's
it's not like a single app it's a
protocol it's like it's like the English
Lang anguage it's like what happens when
someone invents a new word that's not in
the English language well we're going to
add it to the English language what if
you know it's an evolving protocol uh
the way to think of it is Bitcoin is all
the smart people in the civilization
that want to keep their
money and what's going to happen all the
smart people in the civilization that
want to keep their money through
cryptography they're the ones that are
going to upgrade the system so as to
keep their money right and and so it is
a dynamic thing Bitcoin does evolve over
time but uh but if you see it as a
protocol like you use base 10 math you
speak the English language you think in
Bitcoin it's a protocol right uh the
more people that adopt the protocol the
more powerful the protocol gets there's
no reason why the protocol shouldn't
last another 500 or thousand years and
yes it will evolve right there'll be new
techniques and the and the software that
we're using to run the Bitcoin protocol
it will go through versions and it will
up upgrade and update from time to time
but I don't think uh you have to be
concerned about quantum computers for
now I think there'll be a lot of
discussions about that in 2025 and
there's no support supp of Congress and
supportive white house but I don't know
H what final shape that'll take that'll
be a very political decision but I I
will say it's a big shifting of the
Overton window because four or five
years ago the discussion was Will the
government ban Bitcoin and now the
discussion is Will the government back
the dollar with Bitcoin and that's a
pretty profound shift in 48
months do we have other questions okay
yes
sir um if you if your company generates
pick a number a billion dollars a year
in cash
flow if you divided it back to the
shareholders you know you're hitting
them with a dividend tax and then they
have to go find something to invest it
in
because you're basically saying that you
don't know what to invest it in so
presumably they're investing it in the
S&P index and and you're giving it to
them because you don't know of anything
better than the S&P index to invest it
in and so if you had something you could
invest in which delivered four times the
S&P index then
presumably instead of giving it to them
and having them capture whatever the
after tax dividend you could actually
reinvest pre-tax and generate 5x the
returns so the reason so that's one
reason uh because you just make the
shareholders a lot of money the other
reason is if you're Microsoft and you
dividend out all your Capital then
Microsoft ends up being valued uh five
5% of the Enterprise value of Microsoft
is tangible assets 95% is forward
expectations so in essence the entire
stock trades on forward expectations and
if they were to Simply go on a
conference call and lower forward
Expectations by 20 or 30% the stock
crashes if they miss a quarter the stock
crashes so uh when you're dividing out
or when you're dispersing Capital via
buyback or a dividend you're DEC
capitalizing the company so it's it's
the analogy I give is Jeff Bezos and
Bernard AR know and and Elon Musk
they're not the richest men in the world
because of forward expectations of their
wages they're the richest men in the
world because of what they own they own
stuff so if Elon Musk said I've decided
to give away all my money am I still the
richest man in the world well no you're
not you just gave everything away you
gave away your assets and the same is
true with any any wealthy family the
same true with any institution if you
just gave away all your assets you
wouldn't have anything so we've
normalized this idea that somehow it's a
good practice for a company to not have
assets and that's because we made the we
made the capital asset toxic and
dilutive but in
fact if a company gives away all of its
capital and has one bad quarter
technically it's bankrupt and you saw
this during covid lockdown I mean every
every lbo company every company that
leverages up in order to compete with
Amazon and this happened for 20 years
people are trying to grow their cash
flow per share or their earnings per
share by 15% but organically they're
only growing 5% so how do they make up
the difference they borrow money and
they buy the shares back and so when
they lever up they end up with no
capital and so they have one bad quarter
your airline shuts down your hotel shuts
down your retailer shuts down you can't
make payroll you're
bankrupt and then 20,000 people get laid
off okay and the towns you know the
towns end up with 27 you know thousand
you know shuttered retailers and why are
they shuttered because they
decapitalized right and how is that good
for anybody the shareholders lost
everything the employees lost everything
the towns lost everything and it's like
if you walked into your dad's office and
said dad I have a big idea let's have
the family just give away all of our
money and then you just work
harder your dad would say well son
that's interesting but we think will
keep the money because I might break a
leg and not be able to work and this way
your sister won't starve to death that
the re there's a reason we have Capital
right that's why we keep it just because
we might not be able to work forever
harder and uh I think I think uh the
tragedy of the modern era is when you
run a money printer and you inflate the
currency by 7 to 10% the hurdle rate the
organic growth in EPS has to be 10 to
15% and if you can't hit that hurdle
rate you have to basically go into debt
and what you do is you replace Equity
Capital with debt capital and all of
these good companies end up bankrupt
when they have one or two or three bad
quarters so that's a longwinded answer
the short answer is if you had a billion
dollars going up 30% a year you make 300
million a year doing nothing why
wouldn't you want to like why why
wouldn't you want to invest something
which makes you 30 40% a year be-
because I mean it's money right it's
like you can make the
money do we have any other
questions Mike
Quick color on ETF
mention I like your New York real estate
analogy because there's only so much
land and it looks like big asset
managers are stepping in and buying up a
lot of that land through the ETFs can
you talk about that and impact on on
bitcoin Supply um we're one year I think
today or this week yeah this is they're
one year old now it's the most
successful ETF launch in the history of
the world black rocks ibit is the most
successful ETF ever um and and what's
going on is permanent capital is flowing
in via the ETFs and that that's the
long-term store of value holders that
just want to hold the asset as opposed
to trade it um it's a very positive
Dynamic for the space
and uh the ETF solve a bunch of problems
they solve the compliance problem like
in Hong Kong you can buy the ETF if it's
if it's a Hong Kong ATF and the Bitcoin
is custody in a Hong Kong bank just like
you know Australia or Brazil would like
for the Bitcoin to be in their country
so they solve Capital control issues
they solve compliance issue they solve
tax issues they solve convenience issues
you can pick up the phone call your
broker and say buy a million dollars of
this in 15 seconds put the phone down
and it's like done and it's no frills
easy so so they've been helpful they're
part of the
ecosystem um you know and uh lots of
other part companies and and actors are
ecosystem I mean the bottom line is
everybody's competing for 450 Bitcoin a
day at 90 95,000 a Bitcoin you're
talking about 40 $45 million a day when
you've got $45 million a day of organic
demand then that's all the natural
Bitcoin available for sale the prices
got to go up right and so right now the
dynamic the fundamentals are very
positive because all of the slack is
taken out of the
system Bitcoin is like this it's like
you
know a hundred people move into a
neighborhood and then one rich idiot
dude buys the hund house at twice the
price the last person paid for it and
everybody's property value is double
like you're hoping for the rich idiot
dude to buy the last house and then it
only takes one marginal buyer to lift
the property values of the entire
network and I think that's a dynamic
that will continue
forever you know with volatility it'll
go up and down but generally the dynamic
is is capital is Flowing from everywhere
in the world on this network via all
these
I just think you can't you can't really
focus your Bitcoin thesis on its
short-term trading Dynamic I think you
just have to say this is cyber Manhattan
and 300 years my grandchildren's
grandchildren's grandchildren will be
insanely Rich if I buy it now and if I
don't buy it now they won't be right
it's like it's it's property you want to
hold for a hundred years and if you
bought a house in Manhattan and you
insisted on getting drunk at parties on
Saturday night and walking up to
everybody and saying I want you to buy
my house for me right now for cash how
much will you pay
me you would sometimes get bids that are
less than the price you paid and it
would depress you you probably drink
more right it's like if you insist upon
liquidating all your assets every minute
end of the day for cash you're going to
find a very volatile bid ask and you're
going to get depressed like I can't sell
it for more than I bought it today or or
yesterday A guy offered to buy my
apartment for 180,000 and today they
only offered 120,000 I'm freaking out
it's like you're freaking yourself out
right you're there there is no other
real estate asset when you buy
commercial real estate you don't force
someone to give you an all cash bid
every minute of the day and then obsess
when the price goes down or goes up you
just say I'm I'm buying it in a decade
we'll check back again but the truth of
the matter is you bought the real estate
because you intend to rent it or you
bought the real estate because in 15
years you'll refinance it you know so if
you think about New York real estate
families and how they think I bought the
most scarce desirable property I got the
best Capital I'm holding it for the long
term I'm never going to sell it I'm just
going to rent it I'm going to develop it
I'm going to refinance it I'm going to
give it to my
grandkids if you think about Bitcoin
like that then you're good that that
constant bid
bid if you stare at it you know with the
wrong attitude it just gives you anxiety
and a heart attack and it'll give you
mental health
issues but on the other hand if you're
more mature and you look at it and you
say it's jittery
then you the right answer is I'm going
to sell the volatility right I'm going
to sell I I want it to be jittery like
you want it to be jittery because that
gives your options value your Equity
value micro strategy stock trades five
billion in a day our stock trades more
than Microsoft a lot of the time why
would our stock trade more than theirs
because ours is jittery it's volatile
it's you know Bitcoin went from like
98,000 to like 89,000 back to
95,000 like in the 24 hours we're here
it's very jittery and that means people
thought they were long they were short
they sold it they Panic sold it they
Panic bought it back they've already
lived through the equivalent of you know
a 100 quarters of
anxiety in just a few days right and I'm
not selling right so the point is I'm
just the beneficiary of what's happening
and I want it to be jittery but you have
to embrace it as the feature as opposed
to as the bug and if you can start to
think in Bitcoin and say it's a feature
it's volatile and that's what gives me
the edge over a person who is less
committed less thoughtful who the person
wants it less than you right it's like
if you live in New York City you know
the value of everything and and
occasionally people panic and offer to
sell it to you for and they Mark
everything down by
75% I I give you a world everything's
marked down irrationally by 80% and it's
marked up irrationally by 80% and you're
smart do you want to live in that world
or do you want to live in a world where
everything is marked
perfectly and the answer is you want to
live in the world where it's all erratic
you get rich that way in a world where
everything is marked perfectly there's
no opportunity for you right and and so
that's the way I see uh volatil of
Bitcoin I think we're up against the end
of the hour here I'm going to ask you
one quick question Satoshi theories on
who it is creator of Bitcoin Anonymous
creator of
Bitcoin yeah lots of
theories
okay but we we don't talk about Satoshi
Satoshi is a figure of reverence in the
community the the most important thing
to know about Satoshi is Satoshi gave us
Bitcoin and conceptualized Bitcoin as a
gift to humanity it was it was the gift
of perfect money if you define money as
long-term store of value Capital this
this gift of perfect money and they
meant for it to be uh to be gifted to
the world without taking any uh personal
benefit or any beneficial interest in it
and that Immaculate Conception is one of
the most extraordinary developments of
the 21st century for sure maybe of the
last Thousand Years of economics and um
it doesn't matter who Satoshi is anym
than it matters who Prometheus is
Prometheus gave us fire and separate us
from the
Apes Satoshi gave us uh clean money and
now you can build an economic life and
maybe you could achieve economic
immortality and uh someone probably gave
us clean water I don't you know mrle
okay
bubble dut of the you clearly tell me
I'm wrong what percent of Americans even
own Bitcoin it went
away of our lives change it disappeared
tomorrow that real estate volatility the
real estate has value because we can
live in it rent it walk in it but if
Bitcoin
tomor how many of our lives have changed
in this room other than certain people
that may make or lose money
so the gentleman who gave us Bitcoin
clean money God gave us tool us both had
a crisis of great proportion and you you
seem to see feel that bitcoin's not
going to reach that F ever I would
take yeah my answer to that would be as
a Science History and I've
read 100, pages of history and I think
the story of history is is
Humanity's condition was improved when
we got clean water clean food clean air
electricity clean power when we got
petroleum when we got uh cars when we
got nuclear energy when we got
antibiotics if you look at the the
plight of the humanity for thousands of
years people are dying at age 30 there's
a 40% infant mortality rate because the
food's dirty the water's dirty and
they've got no hope and when they were
dying of dirty water and dirty food they
didn't know they were dying of dirty
water and dirty food we bled George
Washington to death every rich person in
Middle East in the Middle Ages died of
gout because they drank red wine because
they couldn't drink water because it was
contaminated and so
so all of these companies if you look at
the mortality rate of Corporation is 99%
the average life expectancy of a company
is 10 to 15 years and you can say well
we'll just take it for granted people
company should only last 10 years just
like you know 40% of your kids maybe
they should just die before the age of
five because that's just the way God
will it or maybe we should just die at
age 31 which is the life expectancy in
Elizabeth and England but the point is
is they didn't die because they were
genetically predisposed to die they died
because they had dirty food dirty water
dirty energy they worked themselves to
death and the best thing that ever
happened to humanity was the passage of
technology so Satoshi put his finger on
one
observation the observation is the
money's the money is uh corrupt and
dirty and and it's defective and you
want me to show you how it's effective I
tell you the story a thousand stories of
people being murdered for their money
every single story of of Jews fleeing
from authoritarianism the sto every
story in Germany of the Protestants the
Catholics murdering each other everybody
that came to America they came because
they're fleeing for property rights um
the entire history of the human race is
littered with tragedy because people
never had proper economic energy a type
1 diabetic can't store organic energy
they will eats to death fat is the way
you store organic energy somehow over
the course of hundreds of millions of
years mammals figured out how to store
organic energy and they had fat cells we
as humans have not had the ability to
store economic energy properly we tried
with gold it never quite worked I could
give you a hundred examples of it not
quite working I can give you a thousand
examples of hyperinflation dating back
to 500 BC of money not quite working for
the first time in human history we have
invented a technology that allows a
human to tightly bind economic energy to
their person or for a corporation to
tightly bind economic energy to the
corporation what it means is you don't
have to suffer an early painful economic
death and you can tell
oh that doesn't matter but my I would
point to everyone in Africa I would
point to all of all of the misery in
Cuba and North Korea and Venezuela I
would point to the misery and the
aftermath of hyperinflationary incidents
that took place in Brazil Argentina
Venezuela Russia I could go on forever
there are literally a 100,000 Pages read
the story of Civilization by Will Durant
and you will find a thousand examples of
currency collapse and economic misery
and this person Satoshi offered us this
gift the gift is you get to own your own
money and no one can take it away from
you you get to keep it right you get to
keep your life force and what do I think
will happen I think that company's life
expectancy on the Bitcoin standard goes
from 10 years to 30 years to 40 years to
100 years and I think living longer is a
good thing and I think family's life
expectancy uh you know is is
dramatically
increased I could do the simple math for
you the half life of money in gold is 30
years gold debases at 2% a year 30 35
years the half life of money in Bitcoin
is forever 0% inflation makes your money
last forever so I I think that some
people will not appreciate it and they
won't get it that's okay you don't have
to buy it lots of people won't buy it by
way I do think that if you ask how many
Americans own it or care they just
tipped the election in favor of trump I
think they care I think the crypto Lobby
is the number one political force today
so I do think there's a lot of people
that do agree with me they do get it
there are 800 billion to a trillion
dollars of real money that has been
invested in the network you can trace it
if you like but that doesn't mean for
everybody everyone didn't install
electricity in Florida or sorry air
conditioning right right that's new all
sorts of Technologies don't get embraced
for 30 years and this won't but I would
say clean money is just as important as
antibiotics it's just as important as
fat it's just as important as clean
electricity
right you know so that that's my answer
to you it's technology it makes the
world a better place and and I think
that uh
I think that for a billion human beings
that are destined to economic misery for
them it's the matter of life or death
you're not one of them right we'll
stipulate lots of Americans aren't one
but drop yourself in Nigeria where it's
illegal to own the dollar where the N
naira is going to zero and then try to
give some money to a person you want to
help in Nigeria or capitalize a company
in Nigeria and tell me how you're going
to do it because generally the answer is
well we just don't everybody stays poor
every company fails and all the
economies collapse and that's the same
answer as a type 1 diabetic we just
don't we just die and you know I think
insulin to a type one diabetic is
Bitcoin to an African it's a it's a
useful thing thank you thank you Michael
sor
[Applause]