Volatility Is An Ally For Long Term Holders
Bitcoin Magazine · 2024-08-19 · 31m · View on X →
Hi Michael. Hey Bill nice to be with you. This is fantastic. Okay we'll get right into it Michael. I've talked to many heavy hitters around this conference and
They're all saying the same thing which is this feels like a momentous occasion not only for Bitcoin history but for American history
Can you say a little bit more about what other potential inflections could be ahead for Bitcoin?
Yeah, I mean I first let's not let's not run over that comment too quickly
This is the biggest week in the history of Bitcoin. So this is a big deal
I mean this is the week when we have two of three presidential candidates you have a former president perhaps the next president here as
as
Trump said 10 senators a lot of congressmen
governors and
And the amount of media attention is profound
So this is an extreme. It's a coming out party for Bitcoin
I think and it's
and it's
It's extraordinary week because they recognize the political power of the community
They also they also recognize this as a technology critical to the success of America and of global significance and
So I think it is a great week
um
This is an inflection point and before I tell you the next set of inflection points. Let's talk about what why this is an inflection point
This is an inflection point
because
there's
There's a
a subtext here
an implication and the implication is
Bitcoin is digital property
Bitcoin is property rights
Bitcoin is ethical
Bitcoin is technically sound
Bitcoin is economically sound
Bitcoin is an instrument of economic empowerment and
The establishment now agrees with you
Right and we all knew it four years ago
But it would have been not clear the establishment knew it the mainstream media in 2020 didn't even cover the industry
And so I think that this is a wake-up call this week to the mainstream and the the establishment around the world
that
Bitcoin is here staying
And and Bitcoin is the future
You know, I guess the other thing
That I don't want to I don't want to not comment on is the speech we just heard is
profound and historic
Right is it's pretty important because if you listen to what
Trump just said
He said
We're not going to sell our Bitcoin you do not sell your Bitcoin that recognizes that
You know, you would never say this about most criminal proceeds that you seized right
Actually the truth is if the United States
Seized car if they seized a drugship men if they seized a
Crata foreign currency if they seized pesos if they seized your roast if they seized
Paintings or collectibles if they seized your house
They would sell it
Right, I mean the normal thing is to auction off any kind of that property so the fact that
He would note that we're not it's going to be the policy of the government not to sell it elevates Bitcoin as property that is
economically superior
To all the other property
So first we have an endorsement and acknowledgement Bitcoin is property and
This and if you if it is property you a property rights to it the second thing is it's better property than that other property
And I recognize it the third is
We're going to create a national United States Bitcoin strategic reserve
That's a big deal
That's a big deal because
You know we go from
Bitcoin being something this toxic do you want to get rid of?
To something that is virtuous
That we want to hold on to so I think that that's a profound thing that just happened I think I
Think that Donald Trump's acknowledgement that the Bitcoin community is full of
Intelligent ethical hardworking creative inspired individuals
The kind of which that made America great he pretty much said that the people that that
Created this great country
Would a bit Bitcoiners. He said the founding fathers of Bitcoiners
He said everybody came to America as a Bitcoiner and what he's acknowledging is whereas once
The United States was the new world and it was risky and dangerous to come here for a better life and property
Now Bitcoin is the new world and it's risky and dangerous and people have suffered
Like Ross Olbrek to come here for this property and he recognizes that he honors that
And he's willing to actually stand up until the entire world that
That will be an observation that ripples everywhere in the world throughout the establishment and throughout other governments and there's gonna be a bunch of German politicians looking at that
Saying well if the US is not gonna sell as Bitcoin we must have been pretty stupid to sell our Bitcoin
And I think that's
Big big move forward
So a variety of proposals now we had yesterday rfk
Proposing to buy millions of Bitcoin
Different level of commitment today
What sort of policies would you think could potentially improve Bitcoin and its trajectory?
I think that there's the big three
There's three policies that accelerate us
To institutional adoption, you know that
Three things that take Bitcoin up by a hundred X from where it is today
the first thing is
To to legitimize and accept and endorse it as an institutional grade asset so
so fair regulation of the asset itself in the securities industry and
And January we got the first installment of that with the approval of the spot Bitcoin ETF
But it was an incomplete
an incomplete
regulation because the SEC still denies N kind creation
of ETF shares and
The SEC still denies the ability to trade
Options on top of spot Bitcoin ETF shares and
The acceptance was given grudgingly, you know, you know, it was basically I did it because I had to do it
But I didn't like it, okay?
so so what's the significance of that?
The negative opinion expressed when and when the approval came that
Sits as a shadow over a lot of mainstream investors
We need to flip from a negative opinion to at least a neutral opinion like what?
Why is it that a federal regulator is an expressing an opinion that this asset is good or bad versus that asset?
So so I think that that's got to change still I
Think that the lack of N kind creates and redemption means that it's a taxable event if I want to contribute Bitcoin or
Would draw Bitcoin from an ETF?
So if you were to like invest in an ETF and it 10x'd and then you wanted to take your Bitcoin in self-custody
You're getting charged 30% of the Bitcoin
If you wanted to move the Bitcoin from an ETF to a bank or to another custodian
You're getting charged as if you sold it even though you didn't sell it
So so right now it's it's there's a tax inefficiency and that's hostile
Whenever you tax someone to vibrate the I remember what I talked about vibration and frequency when you tax on the trade or on the transformation
you're
You're hostile you're oppressing the transaction. It's like you're damping you're damping the wave so I think
Allowing in-kind creates and redemptions will be a big advance forward
When you allow people to trade options on them you will you will eliminate the ball are less than the volatility and increase the ability to generate yield and
Those two things are are what you would expect in the maturation of the asset class as a security
So that's the first point
You know, I would say on a scale of one to ten with regard to
institutionalizing the asset
We're at a six there, you know and in terms of embracement and bracing
The second plank is fair accounting
Okay, if I want
If I wanted to keep you from buying anything
I would establish an accounting rule that said you can only lose money on the trade
But you can never make money and and that's a one-way ratchet if I actually set up an accounting system where you
You always lose you never win and if you win you have to act like you lost and
Then if you lose again, you could win 99 times, but the hundred time you lose you report one loss no wins
Okay, that's just prejudicial in hostile
Okay, so indefinite and tangible accounting allows you to lose but not win and it's the kind of accounting you give to things you don't want people to buy
And so fair accounting was critical and this January it became optional and
Next January it will be mandatory and so that's the that's a big step forward
You know, let's just say we're like
We're
75% of the way along there, but but will be sort of at a hundred percent when you have two dozen or three dozen
Companies and they're all using the same fair value accounting and everybody's talking about it and you start to see companies
report multi-billion dollar or ten mega billion dollar gains on that accounting, right?
That'll be a big deal. That's two and then the third the third is
We
If individuals aren't allowed to self-custody
That's hostile to Bitcoin if I passed the law saying you can't custody
That's that's an attack on Bitcoin
If companies can't self-custody
That's an attack on Bitcoin
If if I had a company whose job was to provide to sell custody services to institutions
If I provided custody to Yale and Dalman or to a big hedge fund and then if the government had a law that made it illegal for the custodian
To provide custody for your asset that's hostile
So right now
Sab 121 is a rule that basically makes it impossible for a bank
to custody Bitcoin and the right way to look at it is well
That's basically a regulation preventing companies the want to custody from custody and so the result of that is
You have basically the government saying I
Guess you can buy the ETF but the ETF is not allowed to use their bank to custody the Bitcoin and they can only use a crypto exchange
The custody the Bitcoin and we're gonna sue the crypto exchange and so when you have the government hostile to the crypto custodian
hostile to the banks hostile to the institutional custodian
You're kind of you're undermining the ETF industry and you're undermining the asset
So the third plank is we just need for the SEC the OCC the FDIC
To allow banks like JP Morgan and Citigroup and Goldman
But by the way you might like not like JP Morgan because of what the CEO has said
But let me guarantee you the within a year or two years of when it's possible to custody
Bitcoin JP Morgan will start a process to do that and within four years
They'll be custody Bitcoin because it's money and that's what they do
So you want a world where Goldman Sachs Morgan Stanley Citigroup
JP Morgan can
Custody Bitcoin because if they can custody it they can buy it for you and if they can buy it they can sell it
And if they can buy it and sell it and custody it they will give you a loan on it and
They will also give you yield on it. So the world after the banks can custody Bitcoin will be
I could have Bitcoin at a bank too big to fail back by a trillion dollar balance sheet
They would give me five hundred basis points of you
You know how much money you get if you put your money on T-Bells right now you get five hundred fifty basis points risk free
I think that the banks will give Bitcoiners
550 basis points risk free
When they can custody the Bitcoin and so the world would be very different if you got paid five percent interest on your Bitcoin
While you're actually holding the Bitcoin and I think the other thing is
They will give you a loan at so far which is five hundred fifty basis points plus fifty basis points spread
So you can get a loan of six percent from Citibank or Bank of America when they can custody the Bitcoin and then the third thing is
They'll let you know they'll let you post the Bitcoin is collateral against your house or you're or you're a mortgage
And you'll be able to I think refinance your mortgage
Maybe to a hundred percent loan to value or a hundred and twenty percent loan to value
By putting the Bitcoin is collateral like right now if you go to some of these banks
and you had a five million dollar house and
And you wanted a bar of money that might say well I can loan you
70 percent or 60 percent all loan you three million dollars against the house at
The best interest rate it used to be two and a half percent by way what I told people to take mortgages and buy Bitcoin
Bitcoin was forty thousand and
The mortgages were two and a half percent interest. I took infinite crap for that by the way infinite um
Well
So you want to buy the you want to borrow the three million what they would say is I'll give you a loan for three million against the house
Or you while make the mortgage five million if you post some securities like Apple stock
If you want to post T bills or Apple stock or the S&P
ETL they will give you a five million dollar mortgage a two and a half percent interest
And you could have done that with those institutional great assets
A marginal world where you can top up your mortgage with Bitcoin
Barrow at three or four or five percent interest for ten to thirty years
Right and and what's the requirement the banks got a custody that they got a custody of the Bitcoin
They got to recognize it as an asset that's just as good as Apple stock
Just as good as a T-Bell and so I think
You know we're rippling where we get a couple more
Improvements on the ETFs will be at a hundred percent
You know a few years from now will be at a hundred percent in accounting and people be comfortable with that
You know once once the regulators you know when they start to repeat what
Robert of Kennedy said yesterday and what Donald Trump said today
Which is Bitcoin is digital property Bitcoin is freed of Bitcoin is virtuous
We're not going to sell our Bitcoin when they say that
The banks pay attention
Okay, the banks you know you got to look at this is the banks are looking to the regulator the regulator is looking to the president the
administration
When the president says
You know this is sketchy stuff, you know, it's used by criminals
The banks take that you know and they pay attention and you know what happens if you don't pay attention
The signature and silvergate bank both actually were very pro Bitcoin and pro crypto
And they got out on a limb and the regulators shut down the two banks right and so you can see why banks are conservative
You can see why public companies are conservative the SEC the CFTC the OCC and the FDIC matter
political leadership matters
rhetoric matters
So the words have changed
At Bitcoin is good for them America if it's good for the dollar if it's good for the country's
Prosperity if it's going to grow the economy
If that's the case we're going to see all of those switches flip
those all became catalyst and now
You have the three planks of institutional adoption
And now I want to make an observation
city bank
Is from is it based on national city bank
And you guys know the origin of national city bank
The head of national city bank was John D. Rockefeller's brother
And national city bank was the bank set up by John D. Rockefeller because he didn't want to trust his money with
JP Morgan
And so that happened more than a hundred years ago
People that do business with these banks sometimes keep the same bank for a hundred years
JP Morgan city bank they're more than a hundred years old
So a CFO
They want to do business with a bank they trust
And the world that I'm seeing is a world where
Google generates a billion dollars in month
And they send a billion dollars a month to city bank or JP Morgan and they say
buy a billion a Bitcoin
And it's like a billion a billion now it's two billion a month
Then meta sends a billion a month then Microsoft sends five billion
And if you want to see a world where a billions of dollars a month flow
And then it flows into the Bitcoin ecosystem
Then it has to be with a bank that is too big to fail
When you're a trillion dollar company
You're not going to send your money to a bank that's the third tier bank
That is a two big to fail because your shareholders don't expect you to take that risk
So I think the catalyst is going to be banking acceptance
When that happens you kind of look at that is these are the high power rails
Right these are the rails that move a billion dollars a day
Maybe a billion dollars an hour
Maybe a billion dollars a minute
Right and
When we get there then I think Bitcoin takes its next leg up
So enormous progress on the regulatory front
Yesterday your keynote was phenomenal in highlighting the addressable market for global capital
And how how high the price of Bitcoin could go
You and I share the view that it's inevitable that it will go there
However, if we look out maybe three to four years and Bitcoin is
Lower than it is today
A is that possible
B
It does does Bitcoin have key man risk in Michael sailor
Okay, I'll answer the there two questions the first question is
At Bitcoin is lower than it is right now in four years you should count yourself lucky because you get to buy it
Okay, and by the way, that's that's not me that's Warren Buffett speaking Warren would say the same thing, right
Warren would be a bit coin or if he was just 40 years younger trust me
just
I'm probably not so open to the new like telepathic coin when I'm 99
You know or whatever I mean I might not be on stage talking about the new thing
But my point is Warren Buffett would say you shouldn't be sad with the price is lower as you're opportunity to buy it my second point
If you had a choice in this audience and if I said I know where I know where Bitcoin's going
It's going to 13 million coin
I'm willing to bet
15 billion dollars on it maybe 50 billion maybe a hundred billion on it. That's what I believe
now
If I told you it's going to 13 million of coin tomorrow
Tomorrow
How do you feel?
What would you be thinking?
Now if I told you it'll go to 13 million of coin in eight years
What are you thinking?
Now if I told you it's going to go to 13 million of coin in 21 years
What do you think it and let me tell you what's the most valuable information in the world
It's not knowing what's going to happen tomorrow
In fact if I told you it was going to go to 13 million
In 21 years and it was going to go perfectly linearly with no volatility
Is that better than if it goes to 13 million and it goes all over the place like this
And I'm gonna give you I'm gonna to give you my opinion
The worst thing is to know what happens tomorrow
If I give it goes to 13 million tomorrow
The only big coin you're ever going to have is why you have in your pocket right now
And your thought is going to be damn. I should about more
My second thought is oh all my family and friends it's too late for them
They missed it. I feel really awful because I wanted to get them into it
The third thought is wow, I don't have time to go refinance my house
The fourth thought is well how do I start a business and raise a billion dollars to buy more Bitcoin
I'm not gonna get that done by tomorrow morning fifth thought is
Damn I have all this money. It's not on the exchange. I can't wire it because banks are closed tonight
Okay, that's awful news
You don't want that
Okay
If I give you eight years, okay, you have eight years, but that's not enough time for everybody to get on board
If I give you 21 years and it's perfectly linear
That's awful too because every stupid
Normie person that doesn't believe in Bitcoin that doesn't understand what you understand that has no conviction
They're gonna get more Bitcoin than you because they're just the do you want the stupid dumb money to buy all your Bitcoin before you buy it?
No
You don't want it to be non-volatile
Here's what you want you wanted to be extremely volatile because that way you know something
Nobody else knows
I give you 21 years and you can go start a company borrow money
Raise capital start a hedge fund create a Bitcoin business tell your friends start a podcast build a life for yourself
Get leverage
mortgage your house
Change the view of your bank
I'm giving you the ability to do work
It's a it's a lever. It's a 21-year lever, okay?
Like micro strategy's been working four years
At Bitcoin had gone from 10,000 to 65,000 on August 11th on the day we announced our Bitcoin buy on August 10th
We wouldn't be worth 40 billion right now. We would be worth
4 billion right now you see so
You want the lever you want the time and the second thing you want is you want massive volatility
because
You know like for example when Bitcoin went from 66,000 to 16,000
Everybody else you know had a crap lost their minds freaked out and we doubled down
Right and it was a benefit for us
It was a problem for everybody else we ripped up and and so
You get the chance to prove yourself
Economically and you get a chance to prove yourself intellectually
And you get a chance to prove yourself morally and ethically if you live through the volatility
You should pray for the volatility
When it goes away you'll lose your advantage and you should you should be happy that you know
Where everybody else on the planet's gonna be in 21 years you got a 21-year-old star
That's a career you can make a life out of that
And don't worry about the stuff that comes in the middle it's a good thing
If you look at it
Once Bitcoin's at 13 million a coin there will be no more volatility
No, when Bitcoin is 13 million a coin
If you look at my base case
Bitcoin is like 20 30% of the equity market and so it's just big enough
That the volatility is decreasing but but my model and my mind and what we're thinking is
If the money supply expands at 7%
The the the equity index will spend about 10%
The volatility the S&P index will be about 10 to 12
The volatility of Bitcoin will be 20 to 22 it'll always be more volatile
The performance will be 20 to 22 ARR it'll always be higher performance always be more volatile because it's an open
Unregulated global market because it doesn't have the counterparty risks and it strips away
The risk of a company and it strips away the entropic
uh the entropic degradation of physical property
It's always gonna be better. It's always gonna be more volatile
And I'm not concerned about it
That's why even when Bitcoin's 13 million you'd be stupid to sell your Bitcoin and buy the other stuff
It's all the other stuff's always gonna be inferior
And I didn't answer your last question which is you know
Keyman risk
You know what if I go away, you know and I thought about it and I you know and and what I would just say is uh
First of all, I don't have any errors, but a nonprofit foundation which will amorphan being a public charity
So when I'm gone
My stock my shares my assets flow into a public charity whose mission is to support Bitcoin and the adoption of Bitcoin forever
And so
You don't have to worry about micro strategy changing direction. You don't have to worry about you know the truth is
I'm probably better for a Bitcoin
Gone than here
You know dead than alive as long as you're if you're dead you can't
You know you can't one was the word murder was it slay your heroes
Slay your heroes
You know so
You know like once I'm gone. I'm not gonna be talking so I can't give a bad
tweet I suppose uh and
Micro strategy or just going with the micro strategy and the micro strategy is simple
It's raise capital from the institutions that have capital by Bitcoin
Hold the Bitcoin forever
Don't lose the Bitcoin
Don't sell the Bitcoin
So that's a great note to end on Michael Bitcoin is forever to the moon
Thank you for everybody in the room
You do not sell your Bitcoin
You
You